Most bread pudding is fine. It’s okay. It’s a way to use up the stuff sitting on your counter that’s turned into a brick. But honestly, if you’re using a standard sandwich loaf or even a basic brioche, you’re kind of missing the point. You want something that can take a beating from a heavy custard without disintegrating into a sad, mushy pile of beige. That is exactly why bread pudding with challah has become the gold standard for anyone who actually cares about texture.
Challah is different. It’s an enriched bread, meaning it’s loaded with eggs and oil, but unlike brioche, it usually skips the dairy. This gives it a specific kind of structural integrity. It’s sturdy. It’s fluffy. When you soak it in a mixture of heavy cream, eggs, and sugar, it doesn't just dissolve; it transforms. It holds onto its shape while absorbing every drop of flavor you throw at it.
📖 Related: 1973 Canadian dollar bill value: What most people get wrong
The Science of the Soak
You can’t just throw bread in a pan and hope for the best. Well, you can, but it won’t be great. The magic of a successful bread pudding with challah lies in the hydration levels. Think of the bread like a sponge. If the sponge is already wet (fresh bread), it can't pick up any more liquid. This is why you see every chef from Ina Garten to local bakery owners insisting on "stale" bread.
If your challah isn't at least two days old, you’re basically fighting a losing battle. Fresh bread has too much internal moisture. When you add custard to fresh bread, the outside gets slimy while the inside stays dry. It’s a textural nightmare. To fix this, if you're in a rush, you’ve got to toast your cubes in a low oven—around 300°F—until they feel like croutons. You aren’t looking for color here. You’re looking for dehydration.
The custard itself is a simple emulsion, but people mess it up by being shy with the fat. Use egg yolks. Lots of them. While a whole egg provides structure, the yolks provide that silky, melt-in-your-mouth feel that separates a "decent" dessert from something you’d pay $14 for at a bistro. Professional recipes often lean on a ratio of about 4 to 5 yolks for every two whole eggs. It sounds like a lot. It is. It's also why it tastes good.
Why Challah Beats Brioche Every Single Time
People love to argue about this. They say brioche is the king of enriched breads because of the butter content. And sure, butter is great. But in a bread pudding, brioche can sometimes be too rich. It’s so high in fat that it can feel greasy when combined with a heavy cream custard. Challah, being oil-based, has a cleaner crumb. It creates a more neutral canvas that lets the vanilla bean or the cinnamon really pop.
✨ Don't miss: Getting a happy birthday card for mum right is harder than it looks
Also, the braid. The way challah is twisted creates these wonderful nooks and crannies. When you tear—don't slice, tear—the bread into chunks, you get more surface area. More surface area means more crispy bits on top. And let’s be real, the crispy, sugary top is the only reason we’re all here.
Common Mistakes That Ruin Your Pudding
- Under-soaking. You think thirty minutes is enough? It’s not. If you want that custard to reach the very center of the bread, you need at least two hours. Overnight is better. Just put it in the fridge and forget about it.
- Too much sugar. The bread itself is often slightly sweet. If you go overboard with the sugar in the custard, you lose the nuance. You want the sweetness to be a backdrop, not the main event.
- Skipping the water bath. People think a bain-marie is just for cheesecake. Wrong. Baking your bread pudding with challah in a larger pan filled with hot water ensures the edges don't curdle before the center sets. It keeps the heat gentle.
The Flavor Profiles That Actually Work
Forget raisins for a second. I know, they’re traditional. But have you tried bittersweet chocolate chunks and a pinch of flaky sea salt? The salt cuts through the richness of the egg yolks and makes the whole thing feel more "adult."
Another heavy hitter is the "Boone County" style—basically adding a splash of bourbon to the custard. Alcohol acts as a flavor enhancer, much like salt does. It brings out the woody notes in the vanilla. If you’re feeling adventurous, orange zest is a game changer. The acidity of the citrus oils cuts right through the heavy cream.
👉 See also: Finding Your Spot at the Beltsville Laurel Senior Center: What to Actually Expect
Real World Results
Take a look at any high-end brunch spot in New York or New Orleans. They aren't using white Pullman loaves. They are sourcing massive, braided challah loaves because they know it holds up under a heat lamp or a heavy pour of crème anglaise. It’s about the "tooth" of the bread. You want to be able to identify a piece of bread on your fork, not a spoonful of mush.
Interestingly, the Jewish diaspora has influenced this dish more than people realize. While bread pudding has roots in 11th-century England as a "poor man's pudding," the use of challah specifically gained massive popularity in American Jewish-deli culture before migrating into the mainstream culinary world. It was a logical evolution; challah is a staple, and there's almost always leftovers after Shabbat.
The Final Step: Temperature Control
Don't eat it boiling hot. I know it smells incredible. I know you want to dive in the second it leaves the oven. But the custard needs time to "carry over" cook and firm up. If you cut into it immediately, the liquid will run out, and you’ll be left with dry bread and a pool of sweet egg milk. Let it sit for at least 20 minutes. The texture will tighten up, and the flavors will actually become more pronounced as it cools slightly.
Actionable Steps for Your Next Batch
- Dry it out: Slice your challah into 1-inch cubes and leave them on a baking sheet overnight. If you're short on time, bake them at 300°F for 15 minutes.
- The Ratio: Aim for 1 cup of liquid (mix of heavy cream and whole milk) for every 2 cups of bread cubes.
- Salt is Mandatory: Add a half-teaspoon of kosher salt to your custard. It is not optional.
- The Crunch Factor: Sprinkle turbinado sugar (sugar in the raw) over the top right before baking. It won't dissolve as easily as granulated sugar, giving you a literal crust you can crack with a spoon.
- Test for Doneness: Use a knife to poke the center. If it comes out with wet liquid, keep going. If it comes out clean or with a bit of thickened custard, pull it out. The internal temperature should be around 160°F.