You’ve probably been there. Standing in the hardware aisle, staring at a wall of gold, silver, and black oxide coatings, wondering why a single bit costs four dollars while the one next to it is fifteen. It’s tempting to grab the cheap one. Then you get home, try to pierce a piece of stainless steel, and within ten seconds, the tip is glowing red, the flutes are dull, and you’ve essentially just made a very expensive, very ineffective friction stirrer.
Honestly, picking the best drill bit material for metal isn't about buying the most expensive option on the shelf; it’s about matching the metallurgy of the bit to the hardness of your workpiece. If you're drilling into soft aluminum, a high-end carbide bit is overkill and actually might snap because it’s too brittle. But try using a standard High-Speed Steel (HSS) bit on a hardened leaf spring? You'll have better luck using a sharpened pencil.
The HSS Reality Check
High-Speed Steel is the baseline. It’s the Toyota Corolla of the tool world—reliable, ubiquitous, and generally "fine" for most things. Most HSS bits are made from M2 steel, which contains a mix of tungsten, molybdenum, and vanadium.
It's tough.
But "tough" in metallurgy doesn't mean "hard." It means it can take some abuse without snapping. If you’re drilling through mild steel, wood, or plastic, HSS is great. However, the moment you hit something with a high carbon content, HSS loses its "red hardness." That’s the temperature at which the steel softens and loses its cutting edge. Once an HSS bit gets too hot, the edge rolls over. It's toast. You can resharpen them, sure, but most people just toss them in the junk drawer.
Why Cobalt is the Actual King of the Garage
If you ask any machinist what the best drill bit material for metal is for heavy-duty DIY or automotive work, they’re going to say Cobalt. Specifically M35 or M42 grade.
Now, a common misconception is that Cobalt bits are "coated." They aren't. Cobalt is mixed throughout the entire alloy, usually at a 5% (M35) or 8% (M42) concentration. This is a game changer because it significantly raises the melting point and the red hardness of the tool.
You can get these things hot.
I’ve seen M42 bits smoking while eating through stainless steel, and they come out the other side still sharp enough to cut your finger. The downside? Cobalt makes the steel more brittle. If you’re using a handheld drill and you wobble even a little bit, a Cobalt bit is more likely to snap than a standard HSS bit. They lack the "flex" of cheaper steel. But for drilling out broken bolts or tackling 304 stainless? Nothing else comes close for the price.
The Titanium Coating Scam (Sorta)
We need to talk about those gold-colored bits. Titanium Nitride (TiN) is a ceramic coating applied to HSS bits. It looks cool. It’s very slippery, which helps reduce friction and heat.
But here’s the rub.
The coating is only a few microns thick. The moment you sharpen a TiN-coated bit, you’ve ground away the "best" part of the tool on the very edge where the cutting actually happens. It’s basically a disposable bit. For high-volume manufacturing where bits are thrown away after a certain number of holes, TiN is amazing because it speeds up the process. For a guy in his garage? You’re often better off putting that money toward a solid Cobalt set that you can sharpen over and over again.
Carbide: The Nuclear Option
Tungsten Carbide is the hardest material we’re going to discuss. It’s not even really steel; it’s a cermet—a mix of ceramic and metal. In a CNC machine or a high-end drill press, carbide is the best drill bit material for metal because it can run at blistering speeds.
✨ Don't miss: Two Braids into a Ponytail: Why Your Technique is Probably the Problem
It eats through hardened steel like it's butter.
However—and this is a massive "however"—carbide is incredibly fragile. If you try to use a solid carbide bit in a handheld cordless drill, you will almost certainly snap it the moment you break through the back of the material. The slight "grab" that happens when a bit exits a hole creates enough torque to shatter carbide. Unless you have a rigid setup and a deathly serious commitment to RPM control, stay away from solid carbide. Stick to "carbide-tipped" if you're doing masonry or specialized hard-metal drilling.
Heat is the Silent Killer
Regardless of the material you choose, the way you use it matters more than the price tag. I see people all the time running their drills at max speed, thinking faster is better.
It’s not.
Metal drilling is about "surface feet per minute." Harder metals require slower speeds and higher pressure. You want to see "chips," not "dust." If you’re getting fine metal dust, you’re just grinding the bit away. You need to press hard enough that the bit bites and peels off a long, curly ribbon of metal. This carries the heat away from the tip.
A Quick Guide to Cooling
- Motor Oil: Better than nothing, but smells terrible when it burns.
- WD-40: Okay for aluminum to keep it from "loading up" the flutes, but useless for steel.
- Dedicated Cutting Fluid: Like Rapid Tap or Tap Magic. This stuff is formulated to chemically bond with the metal and reduce friction at a molecular level. Use it. It’ll make a $5 bit perform like a $20 bit.
Real-World Specs: M35 vs. M42
If you’re shopping for the best drill bit material for metal and you see "Cobalt" on the box, look for the fine print.
M35 is the 5% cobalt variety. It’s the "sweet spot" for most people. It’s hard enough to handle stainless but tough enough that it won't shatter if your hand shakes a little.
M42 is the 8% variety. It’s much harder and much more heat resistant. It’s what you want if you’re drilling Grade 8 bolts or thick titanium plate. But be warned: M42 is noticeably more brittle. If you’re not using a drill press, you’re playing a dangerous game with your wallet.
The Geometry Secret: 118 vs 135 Degrees
Material isn't the only thing that matters. Look at the tip.
Most cheap bits have a 118-degree point. It’s pointy and great for wood or soft metals because it centers easily. But for hard metal, you want a 135-degree "split point." These are flatter and have extra cutting edges at the very tip that prevent the bit from "walking" across the metal. A 135-degree Cobalt bit is the gold standard for automotive and industrial repair. It starts on contact and stays cool.
Actionable Steps for Your Next Project
Don't just buy a "set" and hope for the best. Most sets are 80% sizes you’ll never use.
💡 You might also like: Why the McDonald’s on Broad St in Richmond is Actually a Local Landmark
First, identify your material. If it's aluminum or thin sheet metal, a standard HSS bit with a TiN coating is honestly fine. It’s cheap and replaceable.
If you are working on a truck frame, stainless steel appliances, or anything "hardened," go buy individual M35 Cobalt bits in the specific sizes you need. It’s cheaper to buy three $8 bits that actually work than a $40 "Titanium" set that fails on the first hole.
Second, check your drill speed. Most people run 2,000 RPM for everything. For a 1/2 inch hole in steel, you should be closer to 400 or 500 RPM. Slow down.
Finally, get a real center punch. Even the best material in the world won't help you if the bit wanders and scratches your workpiece. A deep dimple gives the bit a place to "sit" so it can start generating the pressure needed to cut.
If you follow those rules—M35 Cobalt for the hard stuff, slow speeds, and plenty of cutting fluid—you’ll stop burning through bits and start actually getting work done.