Honestly, it’s a miracle they still work. You’ve seen them a thousand times. The jerky stop-motion, the slightly off-kilter voice acting from the sixties, and the fuzzy hand-drawn lines that look like they were sketched on a napkin during a lunch break at Rankin/Bass. Yet, every December, these classic animated christmas movies dominate our screens. It isn't just nostalgia talking. There is something fundamentally "un-corporate" about them that modern CGI just can't replicate.
Think about Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer. It debuted in 1964. That is over sixty years ago. General Electric originally sponsored it, which is why the elves used to find GE appliances in their workshop. Even with the weird glitches and the fact that Santa is kind of a jerk for the first forty minutes, we watch it. We have to.
The Weird, Wobbly Magic of Rankin/Bass
Most people think "classic" means Disney. In the world of holiday specials, it actually means Arthur Rankin Jr. and Jules Bass. They didn't even call it stop-motion; they called it "Animagic." They shipped the production off to Japan, specifically to studios like MOM Production in Tokyo, where Tadahito Mochinaga oversaw the painstaking process of moving puppets frame by frame.
It was grueling work.
The puppets were tiny. Rudolph was about four inches tall. Because they used real wool and leather, the hot studio lights would actually cause the puppets to "wilt" or get dirty over time. If you look closely at the original 1964 broadcast footage, you can sometimes see the wear and tear. That’s the soul of it. You’re seeing human hands at work.
The Misfit Factor
Why does Rudolph still hit? Because it’s surprisingly dark. Hermey wants to be a dentist, which in the context of a magical elf community, is treated like a profound psychological breakdown. The "Island of Misfit Toys" is essentially a colony of unwanted souls. It’s heavy stuff for a kids' show.
📖 Related: Who is The Brain Voice Actor? Meet the Legends Behind Pinky’s Partner
There's a common misconception that these movies were instant, polished hits. In reality, the 1964 version of Rudolph didn't even include the scene where the Misfit Toys are actually rescued. Viewers were so upset that they wrote letters to the network. Rankin/Bass had to go back and animate a new sequence for the 1965 airing where Santa actually picks them up. That’s the power of the audience.
Charlie Brown and the Jazz Revolution
Then there’s the 1965 masterpiece A Charlie Brown Christmas. This shouldn't have been a hit. CBS executives hated it when they first saw it. They thought the pacing was too slow, the jazz soundtrack by Vince Guaraldi was too sophisticated for kids, and the lack of a laugh track was a death sentence for a mid-sixties special.
They were wrong.
Charles Schulz was famously stubborn. He insisted on using real children for the voice acting, not adults pretending to be kids. If you listen to the original audio, the kids stumble over lines. It’s imperfect. It’s real.
The animation was "limited," which is a polite way of saying it was cheap. Characters often move in jerky loops. But the script? It’s a scathing critique of the commercialization of the holidays. When Charlie Brown screams, "Isn't there anyone who knows what Christmas is all about?" it’s a genuine moment of existential dread.
The special was produced on a shoestring budget in just a few months. Animator Bill Melendez and producer Lee Mendelson were convinced they had a flop on their hands. Instead, half of the entire television-watching population of the United States tuned in.
The Grinch and the Perfection of Chuck Jones
In 1966, How the Grinch Stole Christmas! took things to a different level. This wasn't the wobbly, low-budget style of Charlie Brown. This was Chuck Jones, the man behind Bugs Bunny.
He gave the Grinch those signature expressive eyebrows. He made him green. In Dr. Seuss's original book, the Grinch was actually black and white with some pink and red accents. Jones decided on the "ugly green" color based on some rental cars he had driven that summer.
- The Voice: Boris Karloff did the narration. Contrary to popular belief, he didn't sing "You're a Mean One, Mr. Grinch."
- The Singer: That was Thurl Ravenscroft. He wasn't credited in the original airing, leading many to think Karloff did the singing.
- The Tone: It manages to be cynical and heartwarming simultaneously, a balance modern movies rarely strike.
Frosty the Snowman: The End of an Era
By 1969, Rankin/Bass moved into traditional cell animation for Frosty the Snowman. It feels different. It’s brighter, faster, and more "cartoony." They hired Paul Frees and June Foray—the titans of voice acting—to handle most of the roles.
Interesting bit of trivia: June Foray originally voiced Karen (the little girl), but her tracks were later re-recorded by an uncredited child actress in subsequent airings. Nobody is quite sure why, though it likely had to do with the "realism" factor of having an actual kid play the part.
Why Modern CGI Struggles to Compete
We have 4K resolution now. We have ray-tracing and hair simulations. Yet, The Polar Express (2004) often falls into the "uncanny valley," where the characters look just human enough to be creepy.
The classic animated christmas movies of the 60s and 70s avoid this by being unapologetically abstract. We know a wooden puppet isn't a real reindeer. Because our brains don't expect it to look "real," we engage with the emotion instead of the physics.
Also, the music.
You can't compete with Burl Ives or the Vince Guaraldi Trio. Those scores weren't just background noise; they were the backbone of the narrative. They created an atmosphere of "Christmas melancholy" that feels authentic to the bittersweet nature of the season.
The Forgotten Gems and the "Wackier" Side
Not everything was a home run. Have you ever seen The Christmas Tree Train or some of the weirder 1980s offshoots? They lack the staying power because they tried too hard to be "products" rather than stories.
Even Nestor the Long-Eared Christmas Donkey (1977) is a bit of a stretch for some. It’s basically Rudolph but with a donkey in the Roman Empire. It’s incredibly sad—like, "Bambi's mother" levels of trauma. This era of animation wasn't afraid to let kids feel a little bit of sadness.
The Evolution of the "Classic" Label
What makes a movie join this pantheon? It’s usually about the twenty-year mark. The Year Without a Santa Claus (1974) took a while to become a "top tier" classic. Now, the Heat Miser and Snow Miser are icons. Their song-and-dance numbers are arguably the most recognizable parts of the Rankin/Bass catalog outside of Rudolph himself.
Actionable Tips for a Proper Holiday Rewatch
If you’re planning to dive back into these, don't just stream them on a tiny laptop. The grain is part of the experience.
- Seek out the Remastered Versions: While the "fuzz" is nice, the 4K restorations of The Grinch and Charlie Brown actually reveal the beautiful brushstrokes in the background art that were lost on old tube TVs.
- Watch for the Errors: In Rudolph, look for the moment where the "Misfit Bird" is shown swimming instead of flying—then, in the finale, he’s dropped out of the sleigh to fly. It’s a famous continuity error that makes the film feel more human.
- Check the Audio: If you can, find a version with the original mono or remastered stereo tracks. Modern "surround sound" remixes often drown out the delicate percussion in the jazz scores.
- The "B-Sides": Give Emmet Otter's Jug-Band Christmas a look. It’s Jim Henson, not strictly "animated" in the traditional sense, but it uses the same storytelling DNA as the Rankin/Bass classics.
The reality is that these films were made by people who weren't sure if their work would survive until the next year, let alone the next century. They were working against deadlines and tiny budgets. That scrappiness is why they feel like home. They aren't perfect. They are handmade. In a world of AI-generated content and polished-to-death blockbusters, that wobbly, hand-painted charm is the most valuable thing on the screen.
Next time you watch the Grinch's heart grow three sizes, look at the lines around his eyes. You can see the hand of the animator shaking just a tiny bit as they drew that frame. That’s the magic.
To get the most out of your holiday viewing, start with the 1960s "Big Three": Rudolph, Charlie Brown, and The Grinch. Follow those with The Year Without a Santa Claus for a bit of 70s flair. If you want to see the transition to more modern styles, finish with the 1980s The Snowman (the British one by Raymond Briggs). This sequence shows the evolution of the medium from stop-motion puppets to hand-drawn watercolors, giving you a full picture of why these stories refuse to fade away.