Glass is basically trash. At least, it starts that way. You toss a Heineken bottle or a jelly jar into the waves, and the ocean spends the next thirty to forty years sandblasting it into something jewel-like. It's a weirdly beautiful form of recycling. But if you’re into crafts made with sea glass, you’ve probably noticed something frustrating lately: the beach is getting "cleaner."
Plastic happened.
Since the late 1970s, the transition from glass bottles to plastic PET containers has absolutely nuked the supply of genuine beach glass. What you find now is often "shards"—sharp, dangerous bits that haven't spent enough time in the "tumbler" of the tides. To make something worth keeping, you need the frosted, rounded stuff. The "gems."
The Chemistry of Why Some Sea Glass Fails
Most people think sea glass is just broken glass that got smooth. It's more complex. It's a chemical reaction called hydration. Over decades, the soda and lime in the glass leach out when exposed to salt water, creating those tiny, C-shaped pits on the surface. That’s the "frost" you see.
If you're making jewelry, you can’t fake this. Or rather, you shouldn't.
Why "Craft Glass" is a Scam for Serious Makers
Go on Amazon or walk into a big-box craft store. You’ll see bags of "sea glass" for five bucks. Honestly? It’s just tumbled scrap glass. It looks uniform, matte, and—frankly—boring. Real sea glass has soul. It has history. Experts like Richard LaMotte, author of Pure Sea Glass, can literally look at the curve and thickness of a shard and tell you if it came from a 19th-century bitters bottle or a Depression-era fruit jar.
When you start working on crafts made with sea glass, the first thing you realize is that the glass dictates the design. You don't choose to make a necklace; the triangular piece of "cornflower blue" you found tells you it wants to be a necklace.
Drilled Jewelry: The Most Stressful Craft
Drilling glass is terrifying. You’ve spent three hours walking a rocky beach in Maine or California. You found one perfect piece of "multis"—glass with two colors fused together, usually from old decorative vases. Now you have to put a hole in it.
- The Gear: You need a diamond-tipped drill bit.
- The Medium: Never drill dry. If the glass gets hot, it cracks. You drill in a shallow dish of water.
- The Technique: You don't push. You let the drill "kiss" the glass.
It takes forever. Your hand gets cramped. But when that bit finally pops through the other side without shattering the piece? Pure dopamine. Most hobbyists start with wire-wrapping because it’s safer, but drilling allows for a minimalism that lets the glass speak.
Beyond Jewelry: The Mosaic Reality
Not everything has to be a pendant. Some of the most impressive crafts made with sea glass are actually structural. I’m talking about "window art" or "sand casting."
Because sea glass is translucent, it plays with light in a way that regular tile can't. If you’re doing a mosaic, don't use white grout. It kills the glow. Use a clear silicone or a very pale, sandy epoxy. This keeps the edges "hot" when the sun hits them.
The Color Hierarchy
You need to know what you’re looking at. White, brown, and "beer bottle green" are the bread and butter. They make up about 90% of what’s on the beach. Then you have the holy grails:
- Red: Often from old boat lights or Schlitz bottles. Super rare.
- Orange: The "Unicorn." Usually from decorative glassware.
- Yellow: Often 1930s dinnerware.
- Turquoise: Think old seltzer bottles.
If you find a piece of red glass, don't glue it to a picture frame. That's a waste. That piece deserves a bezel setting in sterling silver.
Mistakes Most Beginners Make (And How to Avoid Them)
The biggest mistake is oiling the glass.
People love the way sea glass looks when it's wet. It's vibrant. So, they rub baby oil or mineral oil on their finished crafts made with sea glass to keep that "wet look."
Don't.
The oil eventually attracts dust and turns into a sticky, grey mess. It also fills in those beautiful C-shaped pits that prove the glass is authentic. If you hate the frosted look, you don't actually like sea glass—you like polished glass. Stick to the frost. It’s the mark of the ocean.
Another big one? Over-cleaning. You want to get the salt and bacteria off, sure. A soak in a mix of water and a tiny bit of dish soap is fine. But don't use harsh chemicals or bleach. You can actually damage the "patina" of the glass if it’s particularly old or porous.
The Ethics of Beachcombing in 2026
We have to talk about "seeding."
Some people are so desperate for materials for their crafts made with sea glass that they buy jars of broken glass and dump them into the ocean, hoping to "harvest" them in a year. This is littering. Plain and simple. It’s also fake. The ocean takes time. You can’t shortcut forty years of tidal energy.
If you can't find glass on your local beach, look for "river glass." It’s similar but usually has a different texture—smoother but less pitted. Or, better yet, join a local exchange. There are massive communities on social media where "glassers" trade colors. Maybe you have tons of brown from the Chesapeake Bay, and someone in Scotland has an abundance of sea-foam green.
Creating a Sea Glass "Memory Jar"
Sometimes the best craft isn't a complex piece of jewelry. It's a display.
But don't just throw it in a Mason jar. That's what everyone does. Use a shallow "shadow box" frame. Arrange the glass by color—a gradient from dark forest green to pale sea-foam. It looks like a Rothko painting but made of trash.
If you're doing a flat-lay mosaic on glass (like a "glass on glass" frame), use a UV-resistant adhesive. Regular E6000 glue can yellow over time if it sits in a sunny window. And since the whole point of these crafts is to catch the sun, yellow glue is a disaster. Look for "HXTAL NYL-1"—it’s what museums use for glass repair. It’s pricey, but it stays clear forever.
Practical Steps for Your First Project
If you’re ready to stop collecting and start creating, don't overthink it.
Start by sorting your "stash" by "grade." Grade A is perfectly frosted with no chips. Grade B might have a tiny sharp edge. Grade C is basically just a rock.
Use the Grade C stuff for the bottom of a flower vase. It’s beautiful but doesn't need to be the star. Use Grade B for mosaics where the edges are buried in mortar. Save your Grade A pieces for jewelry or sun-catchers.
Go get a set of specialized pliers—round-nose and chain-nose. Grab some 20-gauge copper or silver-filled wire. Start by just trying to "cage" a piece of glass. Don't worry about it being perfect. The glass isn't perfect. That’s why we like it.
👉 See also: Lily Pond Lane East Hampton NY: Why This Stretch of Sand Stays So Exclusive
The most important thing? Keep the stories. If you found a specific blue shard on a specific anniversary or a trip to the Outer Banks, write it down. Put a tiny note in the back of the frame or the jewelry box. Crafts made with sea glass are basically just physical manifestations of memories. Without the story, it’s just a piece of a broken bottle. With the story, it’s an heirloom.
Head out to the tide line at low tide—ideally after a storm. That’s when the "heavy" stuff gets churned up. Look for the glint, but don't rush. The best pieces are usually hiding under a flap of seaweed or tucked behind a pebble. Happy hunting.