You know that feeling when you're just scrolling, thumb tired, eyes glazed over, looking for something that actually grabs you? It’s usually 11:00 PM. You want a mystery that feels smart, not some cookie-cutter procedural where the lab tech finds a DNA match in thirty seconds. Crime shows on Hulu have weirdly become the gold standard for this specific itch. It’s not just the sheer volume of stuff they have; it’s the variety. One minute you’re watching a bumbling Steve Martin solve a murder in a luxury apartment, and the next, you’re knee-deep in the grim, damp reality of a 1990s cold case.
Hulu has this knack for picking up the gritty stuff people actually talk about at the office.
Honestly, the landscape of streaming has changed so much lately. Everything feels a bit bloated. But if you look at how Hulu curates their "True Crime" and "Police Procedural" hubs, they aren't just dumping every random documentary into the bin. They’ve got the FX catalog, which is basically the "prestige" badge of crime TV, plus their own originals that actually win Emmys. We’re talking about shows that don't just ask "who did it?" but "why do we even care?"
The Absolute Giants of Hulu Crime
If we’re being real, Only Murders in the Building changed the game. It’s a crime show, sure, but it’s also a parody of us—the people who listen to podcasts while doing the dishes. It’s meta. It’s funny. But the mysteries are actually tight. That’s the secret sauce. You come for the chemistry between Selena Gomez and Martin Short, but you stay because the clues actually lead somewhere.
Then you’ve got Under the Bridge. This one is heavy. It’s based on Rebecca Godfrey’s book about the 1997 murder of Reena Virk. It’s uncomfortable to watch because it deals with "mean girl" culture taken to a lethal extreme. Riley Keough plays Godfrey, and Lily Gladstone—fresh off her Oscar buzz—plays a local cop. It’s slow. It’s moody. It’s exactly the kind of show that makes you want to lock your doors and delete your social media.
The Bear isn't a crime show, technically. But Snowfall? That’s a masterpiece. It’s an FX export, and it tracks the crack cocaine epidemic in Los Angeles during the 80s. It’s sprawling. It shows how crime isn't just a "bad guy" doing a "bad thing." It’s about systemic failure, the CIA, and the way neighborhoods get ripped apart. Damson Idris gives a performance as Franklin Saint that should be studied in acting schools. Seriously.
Why the British Imports Hit Different
Hulu is also the unofficial home for people who love British detectives who look like they haven't slept in three weeks. Happy Valley is the peak. Sarah Lancashire plays Catherine Cawood, a police sergeant in West Yorkshire. She’s tough, she’s grieving, and she’s dealing with a truly terrifying villain in Tommy Lee Royce.
It feels lived-in.
You’ve also got Line of Duty. It’s fast-paced, full of police jargon you won’t understand for three episodes, and focuses on anti-corruption. It asks: who watches the watchers? It’s addictive in a way that makes American procedurals look kind of soft.
The True Crime Obsession and Ethics
We have to talk about the "True" part of crime shows on Hulu.
The Dropout was huge. Amanda Seyfried basically transformed into Elizabeth Holmes—the black turtleneck, the weirdly deep voice, the unblinking stare. It’s a white-collar crime story, which is a nice break from the blood and guts. It shows how ambition turns into fraud when nobody is brave enough to say "this doesn't work."
But there’s a debate here.
Critics like Emily Nussbaum have often pointed out that our obsession with these stories can get a bit voyeuristic. Are we learning something, or are we just consuming someone else's tragedy? Hulu’s Candy (starring Jessica Biel) and the HBO Max version of the same story (Love & Death) sparked a massive conversation about why we keep revisiting the same suburban axe murders. Hulu’s version leaned into the kitschy, claustrophobic 80s aesthetic. It felt like a fever dream.
What Most People Get Wrong About Hulu’s Catalog
People think Hulu is just for "old" TV or reruns of Law & Order: SVU.
False.
They have The Old Man. Jeff Bridges is an ex-CIA operative living off the grid. It’s a "spy-crime" hybrid. The fight scenes are brutal because they look like two old men actually fighting—it’s clumsy, heavy, and exhausting. It’s not John Wick. It’s better.
Also, Dopesick. If you haven't seen Michael Keaton in this, stop reading and go watch it. It’s a crime story where the "criminal" is a pharmaceutical company. It’s infuriating. It’s one of those shows that makes you want to write a letter to your congressman. It covers the Sackler family and the OxyContin crisis with a level of detail that’s honestly staggering.
How to Find Your Next Binge Without Scrolling for Hours
Don't just trust the "Recommended" tab. The algorithm is kinda lazy.
- Check the FX tab first. Most of the high-quality crime drama lives under the FX on Hulu banner. Justified is there. The Americans (which is crime-adjacent) is there.
- Look for the "International" section. Shows like The Bureau (French) or Deutschland 83 (German) are incredible if you don't mind subtitles.
- Use the search bar for specific actors. If you like a specific vibe, search for Stephen Graham or Olivia Colman. They almost exclusively do top-tier crime work.
There’s a specific pacing to these shows. Some are "burners" (slow-build) and some are "poppers" (procedural). If you’re tired, go for a procedural like Will Trent. It’s got a dog. The main character has a cool suit. It’s easy. If you want to lose your mind, watch The Act. It’s the story of Gypsy Rose Blanchard. It’s disturbing, but the acting by Joey King and Patricia Arquette is phenomenal.
The Evolution of the Genre
Crime TV used to be about the "Clue." A cigarette butt. A fingerprint.
Now, crime shows on Hulu are about the "Consequence." We see the trial. We see the family falling apart. We see the detective’s drinking problem. It’s more honest, even if it’s more depressing.
Take A Murder at the End of the World. It’s a Gen-Z take on a Sherlock Holmes story. It involves AI, climate change, and tech billionaires. It’s polarizing. Some people hated the ending; others thought it was a brilliant commentary on where we’re headed. But that’s the point—Hulu is taking risks on these weird, hybrid shows that other streamers might pass on.
Key Shows You Might Have Missed
- Death and Other Details: It’s very "Knives Out" on a boat.
- Fargo: Every season is a different crime. Season 5 with Juno Temple was a massive return to form.
- The Cleansing Hour: If you like your crime with a side of horror.
- Boston Strangler: A film, not a show, but Keira Knightley kills it as a journalist in the 60s.
Actionable Steps for Your Next Watch Session
To get the most out of your subscription, stop watching the same three episodes of Criminal Minds (though no judgment, we all do it).
Start with The Bear if you want high-intensity stress, but for pure crime, go with Snowfall. If you want something that feels like a cold winter night, A Murder at the End of the World is your best bet.
Check the "Expiring Soon" section once a week. Because Hulu shares a lot of licensing with other networks, great crime shows often disappear with only a few days' warning.
Lastly, pay attention to the production credits. Anything produced by Brit Marling or Noah Hawley is going to be a "smart" crime show. These creators don't talk down to the audience. They expect you to keep up.
🔗 Read more: The Truth About Every Anime Femboy With Pink Hair
Hulu’s crime library isn't just a collection of shows; it’s a weird, dark, fascinating map of human nature. Whether you want to solve a puzzle or just see a bad guy get what’s coming to him, the options are there. You just have to know where to click.