Walk along the northern edge of East New York, right where the terrain starts to roll upward into a series of unexpected ridges, and you’ll find yourself in Cypress Hills. It’s a place that gets lumped into broader conversations about "East New York" far too often, yet it feels entirely different when you're actually standing on the corner of Fulton Street and Pennsylvania Avenue. For decades, Cypress Hills Brooklyn NY has lived in this weird, liminal space—part historic cemetery district, part bustling immigrant hub, and part residential escape for people who found Brooklyn Heights too pricey and Bushwick too loud.
It is gritty. It is green. Honestly, it’s one of the last places in Brooklyn where you can still feel the "old" city without it being a curated museum piece.
People think they know this area because they’ve driven past it on the Jackie Robinson Parkway. They haven't. If you only see the gravestones of the massive "Cemetery Belt" that borders the neighborhood to the north, you're missing the Victorian architecture on Highland Boulevard or the smell of fresh pan de bono wafting out of a bakery on Atlantic Avenue. This isn't just a place people pass through; it’s a neighborhood with a distinct, stubborn identity that refuses to be gentrified into a bland carbon copy of its neighbors.
The Geography of a Border Town
Cypress Hills is defined by its boundaries. To the north, you’ve got the sprawling green expanse of Highland Park and the massive cemeteries—Cypress Hills Cemetery and Mount Hope—that give the area its name. To the south, it hits Atlantic Avenue. To the west, it bleeds into Bushwick and Bedford-Stuyvesant. To the east, it stretches toward the Queens line.
This positioning is everything. Because it’s tucked under the "arm" of Highland Park, the air feels different here. It’s literally at a higher elevation than much of the surrounding basin.
Back in the 19th century, this was a weekend getaway spot. No joke. People from the congested parts of Manhattan and downtown Brooklyn would take the train out here just to breathe. Today, that legacy lives on in the housing stock. While much of East New York is defined by public housing and mid-century multi-family units, Cypress Hills has these incredible, decaying-but-stunning Queen Anne and Victorian homes. Some have been meticulously restored by families who have lived there for three generations. Others are covered in vinyl siding that hides the original woodwork.
It’s a mix that shouldn't work, but somehow does. You’ll see a $900,000 renovated townhouse right next to a bodega that’s been there since the 1970s.
The Highland Park Factor
You cannot talk about Cypress Hills Brooklyn NY without talking about the park. Highland Park is the neighborhood’s backyard, but it’s more than just a place to jog. It sits on the Ridgewood Reservoir, which was built in 1858 to provide water to the then-independent City of Brooklyn.
The reservoir is now a massive ecological experiment. After it was decommissioned, nature just... took over. Now, it’s a 50-acre forest and wetland right in the middle of a dense urban environment. If you go there at dawn, you’ll see birdwatchers tracking over 150 species of birds. It feels like you’ve been teleported to the Catskills, right up until you hear the J train rumbling in the distance.
The park serves as a social anchor. On weekends, it’s a chaotic, beautiful symphony of sounds: Caribbean cookouts, soccer matches, kids on the playground, and local seniors walking the perimeter path. It’s the lungs of the neighborhood.
Transit and the Elevated Reality
Life in Cypress Hills is dictated by the "El." The J and Z subway lines run right over Jamaica Avenue, casting long shadows over the shops below. It’s loud. It’s metallic. It’s quintessential New York.
For commuters, this is a blessing and a curse. You can get to Lower Manhattan in about 35 to 40 minutes, which is better than most parts of deep Brooklyn. But the "El" also acts as a physical barrier. The area under the tracks feels subterranean even though it’s above ground. It’s where the local economy happens—the barbershops, the hardware stores, and the massive supermarkets.
One thing people often get wrong about Cypress Hills is the "danger" factor. Yes, like any part of New York with high density and lower-than-average income, it has its issues. But the narrative that it's a "no-go zone" is a holdover from the 1980s. Today, it’s a neighborhood of families. You see it in the mornings when the sidewalks are packed with parents walking kids to P.S. 108 or the Cypress Hills Community School.
A Cultural Melting Pot that Actually Melts
New York loves to brag about being a melting pot, but many neighborhoods are actually quite segregated. Cypress Hills is one of the few places where the integration feels organic.
Historically, it was German and Irish. By the mid-20th century, that shifted. Today, it is a powerhouse of Latin American culture—specifically Dominican, Puerto Rican, and Guyanese influences. But there’s also a growing South Asian population and a steady Black middle-class presence.
This shows up most clearly in the food. You can find some of the best roti in Brooklyn just a few blocks away from a spot serving world-class mangu. There’s no pretense here. You aren't paying $18 for a craft cocktail. You’re paying $6 for a massive plate of food that could feed a family of three.
Local Staples Worth Knowing
- The Bakery Scene: Many of the local bakeries aren't just for bread; they are community centers. You’ll see guys sitting there for three hours over a single cup of coffee, arguing about baseball or politics back home.
- The Botanicas: Sprinkled throughout the neighborhood, these shops offer a glimpse into the spiritual life of the community, selling everything from candles to medicinal herbs.
- Highland Boulevard: Take a walk here if you want to see the "mansion row" of Cypress Hills. It’s a glimpse into the wealth that used to define this ridge.
The Real Estate Paradox
If you look at the numbers, real estate in Cypress Hills Brooklyn NY is fascinating. For years, it was one of the last bastions of "affordable" Brooklyn. That’s changing, but not in the way it changed for Williamsburg.
There aren't many glass towers being built here. Instead, the "gentrification" is incremental. It’s individuals buying distressed homes and fixing them up. It’s families staying put and renovating rather than selling to developers.
However, the pressure is real. The rezoning of East New York, which includes parts of Cypress Hills, has brought in more investment but also more fear of displacement. Organizations like the Cypress Hills Local Development Corporation (CHLDC) have been instrumental in fighting for affordable housing and making sure the long-term residents don’t get pushed out by the rising tide of the Brooklyn brand. They’ve been active since 1983, which tells you everything you need to know about the neighborhood's resilience. They didn't wait for a crisis; they've been building the community's defense for forty years.
Misconceptions and Nuance
People often ask: Is it safe? Is it worth moving there?
Safety is relative. If you’re used to the quiet streets of the Upper West Side, the noise and bustle of Cypress Hills might feel overwhelming. But if you value community, visibility, and a place where people actually know their neighbors, it’s safer than many "sterilized" parts of the city.
The biggest mistake people make is treating Cypress Hills like a "starter" neighborhood. It’s not a place you live in while you wait to move somewhere better. For the people who live here, this is the destination. There’s a fierce pride in the "Hills."
The Climate Reality
One thing that doesn't get talked about enough is how the topography of Cypress Hills protects it. During Hurricane Sandy and subsequent major flooding events that devastated other parts of Brooklyn and Queens, the "Hills" mostly stayed dry.
As climate change becomes a bigger factor in New York real estate, being on high ground is no longer just a luxury—it’s a strategic advantage. The Ridgewood Reservoir acts as a natural sponge for the area, and the elevation keeps the neighborhood out of the primary flood zones that plague places like Canarsie or Howard Beach.
🔗 Read more: Why Books by Nathaniel Hawthorne Still Haunt Us
How to Actually Experience Cypress Hills
Don't just go for a "tour." That's weird.
Instead, take the J train to the Cleveland Street station. Walk north.
- Visit the Reservoir: Walk the path around the Ridgewood Reservoir. Look at the skyline of Manhattan from the distance. It looks like a toy city from up there.
- Eat on Jamaica Avenue: Find a spot with no English sign and a line out the door. Order whatever the person in front of you is getting.
- The Architecture Walk: Wander the side streets between Atlantic Avenue and Highland Park. Look at the cornices. Look at the gardens.
- Cypress Hills National Cemetery: It’s the only National Cemetery in New York City. It’s where soldiers from the Civil War are buried. It is quiet, haunting, and incredibly beautiful in the winter.
Cypress Hills Brooklyn NY isn't trying to impress you. It isn't trying to be the next "it" neighborhood. It is a working-class, culturally rich, geographically unique slice of Brooklyn that has managed to keep its soul intact while the rest of the borough became a global brand.
If you want the real Brooklyn—the one that still has some sharp edges and a lot of heart—this is where you find it.
Actionable Steps for Navigating Cypress Hills
If you are looking to move to or invest in the area, your first stop should not be a corporate real estate site. Connect with the Cypress Hills Local Development Corporation. They have their pulse on the actual community needs, from tenant rights to local job placement.
For those just visiting, check the NYC Parks website specifically for events at the Ridgewood Reservoir. They often host guided bird-watching tours and historical walks that explain the engineering marvel of the old water system.
💡 You might also like: Current Nail Trends Popular Nails 2025: Why Everyone Is Obsessed With High-Tech Textures
Finally, if you’re driving, park near Highland Park and walk. The streets are narrow and parking is a nightmare, but you’ll see ten times more of the neighborhood's character on foot than you ever will from behind a windshield. Pay attention to the murals. Many of them tell the history of the various waves of migration that have made this neighborhood what it is today.