Why DIY Xmas Decorations to Make are Often Better Than Store Bought

Why DIY Xmas Decorations to Make are Often Better Than Store Bought

I’ll be honest. Walking into a big-box craft store in November feels like a fever dream of glitter and overpriced plastic. Most people just grab a pre-made wreath and call it a day, but there is something fundamentally different about xmas decorations to make yourself. It’s not just about saving money, although that’s a nice perk when a single "designer" glass bauble can run you twenty bucks. It’s about the soul of the thing. You’ve probably noticed that mass-produced decor has a certain "sameness" to it. Your neighbor has the same Target reindeer. Your aunt has the same Hobby Lobby garland. When you sit down with some floral wire and a pair of snips, you’re breaking that cycle.

Making your own stuff is messy. You’ll get hot glue on your dining table. You might find a pine needle in your sock three months from now. But the result is a home that actually looks like you live there, not a showroom.

The Truth About Dried Citrus and Why It Actually Works

If you spend five minutes on Pinterest, you’ll see dried orange slices everywhere. It feels like a cliché, doesn't it? Well, there’s a reason people have been doing this since the Victorian era. It’s cheap. It smells incredible. It catches the light in a way that plastic simply can’t replicate.

Most people mess this up by slicing them too thick. You want them thin—almost translucent. When they dry out in a low oven (think 175°F to 200°F), the sugars caramelize and they turn into these little stained-glass windows. If you leave them in too long, they turn brown and look like burnt toast. Pull them when they’re still vibrant. I like to string them with bay leaves and cinnamon sticks. It’s a classic move, but if you want to modernize it, try using blood oranges or grapefruit. The deep reds and soft pinks give a different vibe than the standard bright orange.

📖 Related: Scholarships Juniors Can Apply For: Why Waiting Until Senior Year Is a Mistake

Why the "Perfect" Tree is a Myth

We’ve been conditioned to think a tree needs to be symmetrical and color-coordinated. That’s boring. Honestly, the most interesting trees I’ve ever seen are the ones covered in homemade clay ornaments and weird felt cutouts. There’s a technique called "salt dough" that everyone remembers from kindergarten, but if you use fine-grain salt and finish them with a matte sealant, they look like high-end ceramic.

Mix two parts flour, one part salt, and one part water. That’s it. If you want to get fancy, use a stamp to press textures into the dough before baking. A sprig of rosemary pressed into the surface leaves a beautiful, fossil-like imprint. It’s tactile. It’s real. It doesn't feel like it came off a container ship.

Modernizing the Traditional Evergreen Wreath

Most store-bought wreaths are built on a Styrofoam base. It’s terrible for the environment and looks fake the second you get within three feet of it. If you’re looking for xmas decorations to make that actually have some curb appeal, start with a grapevine base or a simple metal hoop.

The Scandinavian style is big right now for a reason: it’s minimal. You don’t need to cover the whole circle. In fact, just decorating the bottom third with some eucalyptus, cedar, and maybe a few sprigs of dried lavender looks much more sophisticated. It’s about negative space. You’re letting the structure show.

  • Cedar: Stays green for a long time and has a lovely drape.
  • Boxwood: Great for a tight, formal look.
  • Dried Hydrangeas: Use these if you want a "shabby chic" or vintage feel; they take spray paint surprisingly well if you want a metallic pop.

The Psychology of Crafting and Holiday Stress

Let’s talk about the elephant in the room. The holidays are stressful. There’s a weird pressure to perform happiness. Research from the American Journal of Public Health has actually pointed toward creative expression as a way to reduce cortisol levels. When you’re focusing on the physical act of threading beads or painting a wooden bead garland, your brain shifts gears. It’s a form of mindfulness. You aren't worrying about the turkey or the credit card bill; you're just wondering if that blue paint is the right shade of "winter sky."

📖 Related: Temperature in Paris Tennessee: Why the Weather is Weirder Than You Think

I’ve found that hosting a "making party" is way better than a standard cocktail hour. Give people a task. Give them some felt and some embroidery floss. You’ll find that the conversation flows better when people’s hands are busy. It removes that awkward "standing around a kitchen island" vibe.

Materials You Probably Already Have

You don't need to drop $200 at a craft store to start. Look in your recycling bin. Seriously.

  1. Cardboard: Corrugated cardboard can be cut into stars, painted white, and dusted with silver glitter to look like heavy metal or wood.
  2. Glass Jars: An old jam jar, some Epsom salt (for snow), and a battery-operated tea light is a five-minute centerpiece.
  3. Brown Paper Bags: Cut them into snowflakes. The weight of the paper makes them hang better than flimsy printer paper.
  4. Twine: Wrap it around anything. An old lightbulb? Wrap it in twine, add a little felt hat, and it’s a penguin. Sorta.

Addressing the "I'm Not Creative" Argument

I hear this all the time. "I can’t draw a straight line." Cool. You don’t need to. Most xmas decorations to make are just about assembly, not fine art. If you can use a pair of scissors and a glue gun, you’re overqualified.

Take the "Paper Star" trend. You take seven paper lunch bags, glue them in a specific T-pattern, cut some notches in the sides, and fan them out. It looks like a complex piece of origami that took hours. It actually takes three minutes. The impact-to-effort ratio is massive. That’s the secret of professional decorators—they find the high-impact, low-effort wins.

Sustainability is Not Just a Buzzword

We produce a staggering amount of waste in December. Between the wrapping paper that can’t be recycled and the cheap plastic baubles that shatter if you breathe on them, it’s a lot. Making your own decor allows you to opt out of that. Use scrap fabric. Use things from your backyard.

I once made a "tree" out of driftwood pieces of varying lengths stacked horizontally. It hung on the wall. It took up zero floor space. It cost zero dollars. And every single person who came over asked where I bought it. There’s a certain smug satisfaction in saying, "Oh, I just found some sticks."

👉 See also: Dirty's Bar and Grill: Why This Emporia Legend Still Matters

Logistics: Getting the Lighting Right

No matter how great your handmade ornaments are, they’ll look terrible under harsh overhead LED lights. The secret to showing off DIY work is "layering" your light. Use warm white strings—stay away from the cool blue ones unless you’re going for a specific "Ice Queen" look.

Put lights inside your garlands. If you’ve made a paper chain (yes, the kind from elementary school, but try using pages from an old, damaged book or sheet music), weave a thin copper wire of "fairy lights" through it. It transforms a schoolroom craft into something that looks like it belongs in a boutique hotel in Copenhagen.

Common Pitfalls to Avoid

  • The Glitter Trap: If you use glitter, use a sealant spray afterward. Otherwise, you’ll be finding "holiday cheer" in your rugs until July.
  • Scale Issues: Small decorations on a big tree look like clutter. If you’re making ornaments, vary the size. Make some huge stars to act as anchors.
  • Too Much Color: Pick a palette and stick to it. If you like the natural look, go with greens, browns, and whites. If you want kitsch, go all in on pink and teal. Just don't try to do everything at once or your house will look like a craft store exploded.

The Longevity of Handmade Items

The best part? These things become heirlooms. You aren’t going to cherish a plastic ball from a pack of 50. But you will cherish the slightly lopsided wooden reindeer your kid helped paint, or the garland you made during that one snowstorm when the power went out.

These objects hold memories. They become part of the ritual of "bringing out the Christmas boxes." You’ll remember the year you learned how to fold those stars. You’ll remember the smell of the oranges drying in the oven. That’s the real value.


Actionable Steps for Your DIY Project:

  • Audit Your Stash: Before buying anything, check your pantry for flour/salt (for dough) or oranges/cinnamon. Look in your "junk drawer" for twine or wire.
  • Start Small: Don't try to hand-make 100 ornaments in one night. Start with a single garland or a wreath for the front door.
  • Use Nature: Go for a walk. Collect pinecones, interesting twigs, or evergreen clippings. Soak pinecones in a water-vinegar mix to clean them, then let them dry and open up near a heater.
  • Invest in a Good Glue Gun: If you’re going to buy one tool, make it a high-temp glue gun. The low-temp ones are frustrating and the "bonds" often fail when the decorations are stored in a hot attic during the summer.
  • Seal Your Work: Use a clear matte spray or a simple Mod Podge to protect paper and salt-dough items from moisture. This ensures they actually last until next year.