When the white smoke finally curls out of the Sistine Chapel chimney, the world holds its breath for two things. First, who is the guy? Second, what is he going to call himself? Honestly, it’s one of the weirdest and most enduring traditions in the world. Imagine getting a massive promotion at work and suddenly telling everyone, "Actually, don’t call me Dave anymore. I’m Clement now."
You’ve probably wondered why they do it. Is it a legal thing? A religious superpower move? Or just a way to hide a past they’d rather people forget? It turns out, the reason why don't popes use their real names is a mix of awkward history, ancient branding, and a dash of biblical symbolism.
The Awkward Moment That Started It All
For the first few centuries, popes were just... guys. They kept their birth names because, frankly, there was no rule saying they couldn't. If your name was Linus or Cletus, you just stayed Linus or Cletus.
👉 See also: Why the Chinese cat waving arm is actually Japanese (and why it keeps waving)
Everything changed in AD 533.
A priest named Mercurius was elected. Now, Mercurius is a cool name, but there was a glaring problem: it was the name of the Roman god Mercury. For a man about to lead the entire Christian world, being named after a pagan deity was, well, a bit of a PR nightmare. It would be like a modern pacifist leader being named "Ares" or "God of War."
Kinda weird, right?
Mercurius decided he couldn't keep it. He took the name John II to honor a previous pope he admired. He didn't realize he was starting a trend that would eventually become a hard-and-fast rule. But even after him, the change wasn't instant. For hundreds of years, it was a "sometimes" thing. Some did it; most didn't.
The German Invasion and the "Foreign" Name Problem
By the 10th century, the tradition got a massive boost because of geography. Popes started coming from outside Italy—specifically from Germany and France.
They had names like Bruno or Gerbert. To the ears of the Roman people, these sounded "barbaric" and totally foreign. To blend in and show they were part of the Roman tradition, these guys started swapping their Germanic names for classic, "popely" names like Gregory or Sylvester.
It was basically 10th-century rebranding.
Why Don't Popes Use Their Real Names Anymore?
By the time we hit the mid-1500s, the tradition was set in stone. The very last guy to use his birth name was Marcellus II in 1555. He only lasted 22 days in office. Maybe the bad luck of keeping his name scared everyone else off? Probably not, but it’s a fun coincidence.
Since then, every single pope has chosen a regnal name.
1. The "New Man" Concept
In the Bible, when God gives someone a big job, He often changes their name. Abram became Abraham. Simon became Peter. Saul became Paul.
When a Cardinal becomes the Pope, the Church views it as a total transformation. You aren't just a guy with a job; you are a new person with a new destiny. Dropping your birth name is a way of saying, "The old me is gone. This version of me belongs to the Church."
2. Setting a "Vibe" for the Papacy
The choice is never random. It’s the first real "policy statement" a new pope makes.
When Cardinal Jorge Mario Bergoglio was elected in 2013, he chose Francis. No one had ever used that name before. By picking St. Francis of Assisi—a man famous for living in poverty and loving the environment—he was telling the world exactly what he cared about without saying a single word.
3. Honoring the "Boss"
Most popes choose a name to honor someone they liked.
- John Paul I (1978) was a rebel. He was the first to use two names. Why? He wanted to honor both John XXIII and Paul VI, the two popes who came before him.
- Benedict XVI (2005) picked his name to honor Benedict XV, who was a "peace pope" during World War I.
- Leo XIV, who was elected more recently in 2025, chose the name to signal a focus on social justice, following the legacy of Leo XIII.
The Names They Simply Won't Touch
There are some names that are basically "off-limits," even though there's no official law against them.
Peter II is the big one.
St. Peter was the first pope. There is a very old, very spooky superstition (popularized by a 12th-century "prophecy" attributed to St. Malachy) that the final pope will be named Peter II and will lead the Church through the end of the world.
Whether they believe the prophecy or not, most popes have enough ego-checks to realize that calling yourself "Peter II" is a bit like a rookie basketball player demanding to wear Michael Jordan's jersey number. It’s just too much pressure.
Also, you'll never see a Pope Judas or a Pope Lucifer. Obviously.
What Happens if a Pope Doesn't Change His Name?
Technically? Nothing.
Canon law doesn't actually force a pope to change his name. If a guy named Mark got elected and wanted to be Pope Mark, he could. But the weight of 500 years of tradition is a lot to push against. In the Vatican, tradition usually wins.
When the Senior Cardinal Deacon steps out onto that balcony and says "Habemus Papam" (We have a pope), he follows a very specific script:
✨ Don't miss: Halloween Candy With Razor Blades: Why the Legend Just Won’t Die
- He says the pope’s birth first name (in Latin).
- He says the birth last name (in its original language).
- Then he announces the new name: "Qui sibi nomen imposuit..." (Who has taken the name...).
Actionable Insights: How to Understand a Papal Name
If you’re watching the news the next time a pope is elected, don't just look at the face. Look at the name. It’s the key to the next decade of Church history.
- Check the Number: If he’s "Pius XIII," expect a traditional, conservative approach. Popes named Pius generally favored strict adherence to doctrine.
- Look for "The First": If a pope chooses a brand new name (like Francis did), he’s likely a reformer who wants to break the mold.
- The "Mentor" Rule: Most popes pick the name of the man who made them a Cardinal. It’s a massive "thank you" and a sign that they will continue that man's specific legacy.
The tradition of why don't popes use their real names might seem like a weird relic of the past, but it's actually a very clever way of signaling intent. It’s the ultimate name-drop. By picking a name from history, they are telling you which team they are on and what kind of world they want to build.
Next time you hear a name like Benedict or Leo, remember it's not just a title—it's a mission statement.
Explore the history of the most popular papal names:
- John: Used 23 times (The most popular by far).
- Gregory: Used 16 times (Often associated with reform).
- Benedict: Used 16 times (The "scholarly" name).
- Clement: Used 14 times.
- Leo: Used 14 times.
Understanding these names is the fastest way to "read between the lines" of Vatican politics. It turns a confusing religious ritual into a clear map of where the Church is headed.