Let's be real for a second. Marvel's First Family gets no respect in the digital world. While Spider-Man is out there swinging through high-budget masterpieces and the Avengers—despite some hiccups—get the AAA treatment, the fantastic four video game history is a weird, disjointed mess of movie tie-ins and missed opportunities. It’s actually kind of impressive how many times developers have tried to translate four distinct, contrasting powers into a cohesive gameplay loop and just... failed. Or, at best, landed squarely in the "it's fine, I guess" category.
The problem isn't the source material. You’ve got a genius who can stretch, a pilot made of orange rock, a woman who can vanish and throw force fields, and a hothead who literally flies. That's a built-in class system for any RPG or action-adventure title. Yet, if you look back at the 1997 PlayStation 1 release, you’ll see exactly where the curse started. It was a side-scrolling beat 'em up that felt ancient even for its time. It had jazz music. Like, actual elevator-style jazz playing while you punched lizard men. It was bizarre.
The Movie Tie-In Era: Peak Mediocrity
Most people actually remember the 2005 fantastic four video game that launched alongside the Ioan Gruffudd and Jessica Alba movie. This was the era when every summer blockbuster had to have a console release. Developed by 7th Level and published by Activision, it was actually okay. Not great. Just okay. It captured that mid-2000s "brawler" energy where you just mashed buttons until everything on screen turned into particles.
What it did well, surprisingly, was the character switching. You weren't stuck as just one hero. You could cycle through the team to solve basic environmental puzzles. Reed Richards was basically your grapple hook and long-range poker. Ben Grimm was the tank. Sue Storm was the stealth/crowd control element. Johnny Storm? He was the glass cannon. But the levels felt like corridors. Long, metallic, repetitive corridors that lacked the cosmic scale the Fantastic Four are known for.
Then came Rise of the Silver Surfer in 2007. Honestly, the less said about that one, the better. It felt rushed. It looked worse than its predecessor in some ways. It was the quintessential example of "licensed shovelware," a relic of a time before Marvel Games realized they could actually make billions by hiring top-tier studios like Insomniac or Eidos-Montréal.
Why the Gameplay Mechanics Are a Nightmare to Balance
Designing a fantastic four video game is a logistical headache for any lead designer. Think about the power scaling. If the Thing is as strong as he is in the comics, he should be able to walk through every wall in the level. If Susan Storm is utilizing her full potential, she’s arguably the most powerful member of the team, capable of ending fights before they start.
Most games nerf them. They have to.
In Marvel Ultimate Alliance—which many fans consider the best "unofficial" Fantastic Four experience—the team actually feels great. Why? Because the game isn't about them. It’s a top-down dungeon crawler where their powers are distilled into four mapped buttons. When you try to make a third-person, over-the-shoulder action game specifically for them, the camera becomes your biggest enemy. How do you animate Reed Richards stretching across a room without it looking like a glitchy mess? How do you handle Johnny Storm flying in a restricted indoor environment?
The Cancelled 2012 Project
There is a legendary "lost" game that actually looked promising. Back around 2012, a studio called Seventh Chord was working on a Fantastic Four title that was supposed to be a bit more "New 52" in its vibe—darker, more modern. Leaked concept art showed a much more tactical approach to the team. But the project was scrapped when the licensing deal between Marvel and Fox got... complicated. This was during that weird period where Marvel started de-emphasizing the X-Men and the Fantastic Four in games and comics because they didn't own the film rights. It was a dark time for fans. We got Marvel vs. Capcom: Infinite without a single mutant or Fantastic Four member. It felt hollow.
The Modern Hope: Marvel's First Family in the 2020s
We are currently in a drought. There hasn't been a dedicated fantastic four video game in over a decade. Sure, they showed up in Marvel Ultimate Alliance 3: The Black Order as DLC. They’re in Marvel Snap. They’re in LEGO Marvel Super Heroes. But a standalone, narrative-driven epic? It’s nowhere to be found.
However, the industry has changed. We’ve seen that superhero games don't have to be "for kids." They can be complex. They can be emotional.
💡 You might also like: Getting the Botw Amiibo Drop List Right: What Most Players Miss
Imagine a game developed by a studio like Remedy (the Control and Alan Wake devs). They know how to do "weird." The Fantastic Four aren't just superheroes; they are explorers. They go to the Negative Zone. They fight Galactus. They deal with the Microverse. A modern game needs to lean into the sci-fi horror and wonder of Lee and Kirby’s original run. It shouldn't just be about punching Doctor Doom’s robots. It should be about the family dynamic.
The Family Dynamic as a Gameplay Mechanic
If someone finally makes a new fantastic four video game, the "bonding" needs to be the core mechanic. Think God of War (2018) or Guardians of the Galaxy by Eidos. In Guardians, the combat was fine, but the chatter was world-class. You felt like part of a dysfunctional group.
For the Fantastic Four, this is essential. Ben and Johnny should be bickering during fights. Reed should be distractingly clinical while Sue holds the whole team together emotionally and tactically. If you don't have the "family" part right, you just have four random people in blue jumpsuits.
- The Thing: Needs to feel heavy. Every step should shake the controller.
- The Invisible Woman: Should be the tactical powerhouse. Force fields for defense, invisibility for flanking.
- The Human Torch: High-speed flight and heat-management mechanics.
- Mr. Fantastic: Creative problem solving. He shouldn't just punch; he should reshape the battlefield.
Moving Beyond the Movie Tie-In Curse
The biggest mistake any future fantastic four video game could make is tying itself to the upcoming MCU film. We've seen that movie-games are usually hampered by production schedules. They have to come out when the movie does, which leads to bugs and half-baked ideas.
Look at Marvel's Spider-Man. It’s its own universe. It has its own suit designs. It has its own version of Peter Parker. That’s what the FF needs. A standalone story that respects the 60+ years of comic history without being beholden to a two-hour film script. We need a Baxter Building that acts as a hub world, full of Reed’s inventions and trophies from previous adventures.
Actionable Steps for Fans and Gamers
If you’re looking to scratch that itch right now, you’ve basically got three real options.
First, play Marvel Ultimate Alliance 3 on the Switch and get the "Shadow of Doom" DLC. It’s the most modern representation of the team and their powers are handled with a lot of love. The chemistry is there, even if the gameplay is a bit grindy.
Second, go back to LEGO Marvel Super Heroes. Honestly. It’s one of the only games that actually lets you use their powers for puzzle solving in a way that feels clever. Reed turning into a teapot or a pair of bolt cutters is exactly the kind of Silver Age goofy charm the series needs.
Third, keep an eye on the rumor mill. With the MCU movie on the horizon, several "insiders" have suggested that a major studio is currently in early pre-production on a Fantastic Four project. While nothing is confirmed, Marvel Games' recent track record with Wolverine and Black Panther suggests they are finally putting their heavy hitters in the hands of capable developers.
The fantastic four video game of our dreams hasn't been made yet. But for the first time in twenty years, the technology and the industry's respect for the source material actually exist to make it happen. We just have to wait for someone to realize that the First Family deserves more than a mobile game cameo.
Stop looking for a perfect 1:1 movie adaptation. Instead, look for games that capture the "Team" or "Family" vibe. Titles like It Takes Two actually prove that co-op mechanics can be deep and narrative-driven. That's the DNA a future FF game needs. Focus on the interplay between the characters. Support developers who prioritize unique power sets over generic skill trees. The best way to ensure we get a quality game is to stop settling for the mediocre ones.