He wasn't always a bloated, gout-ridden tyrant screaming for turkey legs. Honestly, if you look at the way any Henry VIII TV show portrays the man, you're usually getting a caricature of his final five years rather than the complicated athlete who ruled for nearly forty.
People are obsessed with the wives. Obviously.
But the obsession with the six marriages often masks the weird, high-stakes political thriller that was actually happening in the Tudor court. When you sit down to watch The Tudors or Wolf Hall, you’re stepping into a version of history that has been filtered through centuries of Victorian gossip and Hollywood glitz. Some of it is spot on. Most of it? Total fiction.
The Problem With Jonathan Rhys Meyers and the Sexy Tudor Myth
Let’s talk about The Tudors. Showtime basically turned the 16th century into a runway show. Jonathan Rhys Meyers played Henry as a smoldering, lean rockstar for almost the entire run of the series.
It worked for TV. It didn't work for history.
The real Henry VIII was a physical specimen, but in a very different way. By the time he was in his late twenties, he was over six feet tall—a literal giant in a world where the average man was much shorter—and built like a linebacker. He was an elite athlete. He wrestled, he played tennis, and he was arguably the best jouster in Europe.
The Henry VIII TV show trope of the "young, skinny king" ignores the fact that Henry’s identity was tied to his massive physical presence. When he was injured in a jousting accident in 1536, his life shifted. He couldn't exercise. His leg ulcer became a constant, stinking source of agony. That's when the "Monster Henry" we see in portraits really began to take shape.
Wolf Hall, on the other hand, gives us a much more grounded version. Damian Lewis plays Henry with a sort of mercurial, terrifying stillness. You never know if he’s going to hug you or execute you. That’s probably the closest any actor has ever gotten to the actual vibe of the Tudor court. It was a place where a single wrong word could get your head chopped off, even if you were the King’s best friend.
Why the Costumes Always Look Too New
Have you noticed how everyone in a Henry VIII TV show looks like they just stepped out of a dry cleaner?
Tudor England was filthy. Even the palaces smelled like old rushes and damp stone. While the royalty wore silks and gold thread, those clothes were heavy. They were stiff. A real doublet could weigh twenty pounds. In most shows, the actors move too fluidly. They look like they're wearing polyester blends because, well, they usually are.
✨ Don't miss: Why the Cabin Fever Diary of a Wimpy Kid Movie Actually Worked
The Six Wives: Beyond the Divorce, Beheaded, Died Rhyme
We have to address the elephant in the room: the wives.
Most people watch a Henry VIII TV show to see the drama between Henry and Anne Boleyn. The Spanish Princess tried to reclaim Catherine of Aragon’s narrative, showing her as a warrior queen, which is actually historically backed. She did lead an army toward Scotland while Henry was away in France. She wasn't just the "sad first wife."
Then there's Anne.
The media loves to paint Anne Boleyn as either a scheming temptress or a total victim. The truth is somewhere in the middle. She was a brilliant political operative who survived the cutthroat French court before coming to England. When you watch Natalie Dormer or Claire Foy play her, you're seeing two very different interpretations of power.
But why does every Henry VIII TV show ignore the others?
- Anne of Cleves: Usually played as "the ugly one." In reality, she was probably perfectly fine-looking, just not Henry’s type. She was also the smartest of the bunch, out-negotiating Henry for a massive divorce settlement and outliving him.
- Catherine Howard: Often portrayed as a flighty teenager. She was a teenager, but she was likely a victim of sexual predation by older men long before she reached the King.
- Catherine Parr: The intellectual. She was the first woman to publish a book under her own name in English. You rarely see that in a TV drama because "woman writes theology" isn't as "sexy" as "woman gets executed."
The Religious Context Most Scripts Ignore
You can't talk about Henry without the Reformation. But let’s be real: theology is boring for most TV audiences.
Most shows treat the break with Rome like a messy divorce settlement. It was so much more than that. It was a total restructuring of the English soul. People were being burned at the stake for believing the wrong thing about bread and wine. If a Henry VIII TV show doesn't capture the sheer terror of that religious shift, it's missing the point of why Henry was so feared. He wasn't just a king; he became the Supreme Head of the Church. He basically told his subjects that he, not the Pope, held the keys to their eternal salvation.
Imagine the psychological pressure of that.
Ranking the Best (and Worst) On-Screen Henrys
If you're looking for the "definitive" version, it doesn't exist. You have to piece it together from different performances.
- Damian Lewis (Wolf Hall): Best for seeing the psychological instability and the sheer "Kingliness."
- Robert Shaw (A Man for All Seasons): Old school, but captures the jovial-yet-deadly nature of the man. His Henry is a guy you want to have a beer with, right up until he orders your arrest.
- Jonathan Rhys Meyers (The Tudors): Great for the "soap opera" version of history. It captures the passion and the vanity, even if the timeline is a total mess.
- Ray Winstone (Henry VIII 2003): This miniseries leans into the "thug" aspect of Henry. He treats the English throne like a mob boss. It’s gritty, it’s loud, and it feels surprisingly authentic to the brutality of the era.
What's Next for the Tudor Genre?
We are currently seeing a shift in how these stories are told. The focus is moving away from the King himself and toward the people in the shadows.
Shows like Becoming Elizabeth or Firebrand (the 2023 film) are looking at the survivors. The "Henry VIII TV show" of the future probably won't be about Henry at all. It’ll be about the women who navigated his madness.
The reality is that Henry VIII was a man of massive contradictions. He was a composer of music who ordered the deaths of his closest friends. He was a devout Catholic who destroyed the monasteries. He was a romantic who couldn't stay married.
🔗 Read more: Why The End of the Affair the Movie Still Hurts to Watch
How to Watch These Shows Like a Historian
If you want to get the most out of your next binge-watch, keep a few things in mind. First, look at the background. Are the servants visible? In the real Tudor court, you were never alone. There were people sleeping on the floor of your bedroom. There was no privacy.
Second, watch the hands. In the 16th century, etiquette was everything. How someone bowed, how they held a cup, how they sat—all of it signaled their rank. Most modern actors struggle with this; they're too relaxed.
Lastly, remember the age gaps. Henry was significantly older than his later wives. When you see a 40-year-old actor playing Henry with a 20-year-old actress playing Catherine Howard, that’s actually the most "accurate" part of the show, as uncomfortable as it feels.
Your Tudor Deep Dive Checklist
If this has sparked a need to see what's actually real versus what's Hollywood fluff, here is how you should proceed:
- Read "The Six Wives of Henry VIII" by Antonia Fraser. It is the gold standard for understanding the women behind the myths.
- Visit the Tower of London virtually. Many of these shows film there, but seeing the actual site of the executions changes your perspective on the "drama."
- Compare the portraits. Look at Hans Holbein the Younger’s paintings of the court. Then look at the actors. You’ll notice the actors are almost always more "traditionally" attractive, while the real people had much more character (and often much smaller eyes) in their faces.
- Check the dates. If a show has Henry meeting someone who died ten years prior, turn it off if you want accuracy—or keep watching if you just want the vibes.
The Henry VIII TV show phenomenon isn't going anywhere. We are endlessly fascinated by a man who had the absolute power to reshape a country just because he fell in love—or fell out of it. Just remember that behind the velvet and the jewelry, there was a very real, very sick, and very dangerous man who would be horrified to see himself portrayed as a romantic lead.
For the best experience, start with Wolf Hall for the politics, The Spanish Princess for the early years, and keep a Wikipedia tab open. You'll need it.