Dating is a disaster. Honestly, if you’ve spent more than five minutes scrolling through TikTok or Reddit lately, you’ve seen the fatigue. It’s all "ghosting," "benching," and "situationships." People are tired. That’s exactly why the Ask a Matchmaker book—officially titled Ask a Matchmaker: Your Guide to Finding Love, Keeping It, and Letting It Go—by Maria Avgitidis has become such a massive touchstone for people who are just done with the apps.
Maria Avgitidis isn't just some influencer giving unsolicited advice. She’s the CEO of Agape Match, a fourth-generation matchmaker who has been doing this for over fifteen years. She’s seen it all. She knows why your Hinge profile is failing and why that third date always feels like a job interview.
The book is basically a distillation of her "Matchmaker Maria" persona that blew up on Instagram. It’s blunt. It’s funny. Sometimes, it’s a little hard to swallow because she calls out the behaviors that keep us single. But it works because it treats dating like a skill rather than a magical accident that just happens to "lucky" people.
🔗 Read more: Why Your Cabbage in Soup Recipe Always Turns Out Bland (And How to Fix It)
The Reality of the "Burn the Apps" Movement
We’ve reached a breaking point with digital romance. For years, the narrative was that the more people you swiped on, the higher your chances of finding "the one." Math, right? Wrong.
In the Ask a Matchmaker book, Avgitidis argues against this "paradox of choice." When you have infinite options, you value none of them. This is the core of her philosophy. She advocates for something she calls "selective intentionality." It’s not about meeting everyone; it’s about meeting the right people with a specific mindset.
A lot of readers go into this book expecting a list of "tricks" to get a guy or girl to like them. They’re disappointed—at first. Instead, Maria focuses on the "Three-Date Rule," which isn't what you think. It’s not about when to have sex. It’s about a framework for evaluating compatibility before you’re too emotionally invested to see red flags.
The book breaks down the "Green Flags" we often ignore because we’re too busy looking for a "spark." Maria is famously anti-spark. She thinks the "spark" is often just anxiety or a trauma bond disguised as chemistry. Real love, she argues, feels like "coming home." It’s calm. It’s boring, in a good way.
Why the "Ask a Matchmaker Book" Hits Different
Most dating books are written by psychologists or "pickup artists." One is too clinical; the other is too predatory. Maria occupies this middle ground of "Professional Yenta."
She brings in actual data from her matchmaking firm. When she says men prefer a certain type of communication in the early stages, it’s not a guess. It’s based on thousands of feedback sessions she’s conducted after first dates. That’s the "secret sauce" of the Ask a Matchmaker book. It’s the feedback we never get in the real world. Think about it: when someone stops texting you, they don’t send a constructive PDF explaining why. Maria provides that "why."
The "Agape Method" Explained
One of the most talked-about sections of the book involves the "Agape Method" for profile curation. It’s hyper-specific.
- No sunglasses in the first three photos.
- Show your teeth.
- Have a "full body" shot that is current.
- Use prompts that invite a conversation, not just "I like tacos."
It sounds simple. It is simple. Yet, most people fail at it.
Maria explains that your profile is an advertisement, not a diary. You’re looking for a "qualified lead," to use business speak. If you’re a homebody who loves knitting, don’t post photos of yourself hiking a mountain just because you think it looks "active." You’ll just attract hikers who will be annoyed when you want to stay in on Saturday night.
Managing Your Own Expectations
The book tackles the "list" problem. You know the one.
"I want someone who is 6'2", makes six figures, loves dogs, and lives within five miles."
Maria is ruthless here. She asks readers to differentiate between "deal-breakers" and "preferences." A deal-breaker is "doesn't want kids." A preference is "has blue eyes." If you have too many preferences labeled as deal-breakers, you’re not looking for a partner; you’re looking for a unicorn. And unicorns don't exist.
She often cites the "80/20 rule" in a different context. If someone hits 80% of your needs, the other 20% is stuff you can live with or learn to love. The Ask a Matchmaker book encourages people to stop looking for perfection and start looking for "good enough" in the most positive sense of the phrase.
Dealing with the "Ex" Factor
A huge portion of the book is dedicated to "Letting It Go."
Maria talks about "The Waiting Room." This is that period where you’re hung up on an ex, so you aren't actually "on the market" even if you’re on the apps. You’re physically there, but emotionally, you’re unavailable.
She offers a "no-contact" strategy that is intense but effective. It’s about reclaiming your brain's dopamine receptors. You can’t find the next person if you’re still checking your ex’s Instagram stories at 2:00 AM.
✨ Don't miss: Why Winter Leather Jackets for Men are Better Than Your Technical Parka
The advice is grounded in reality. She acknowledges that it hurts. She acknowledges that it’s hard. But she also points out that your "future self" is waiting for you to get over it. It’s tough love. It’s what a best friend would say if they weren't afraid of hurting your feelings.
Is it Just for Straight People?
This is a common critique of traditional matchmaking books. While Maria’s personal experience often leans toward heteronormative dynamics because of the bulk of her client base, the core tenets of the Ask a Matchmaker book are remarkably universal.
Communication styles, boundaries, and self-worth don't change based on your orientation. The "Four Stages of a Relationship" she outlines—Exploration, Exclusive, Engaged, and Exit—apply to almost everyone.
She also touches on the cultural aspects of dating. Being a first-generation Greek-American, Maria understands how family pressure and cultural expectations play into our romantic choices. She encourages readers to separate what they want from what their mother wants for them.
The Practical Side of First Dates
What do you actually talk about on a first date?
The book suggests avoiding the "interview" style. Don't ask what they do for a living in the first five minutes. Ask about their favorite "third place"—the place they go that isn't work or home. Ask about the last thing that made them laugh.
The goal of the first date isn't to decide if you want to marry them.
The goal of the first date is to decide if you want a second date.
That’s it.
People put too much pressure on that initial meeting. They try to figure out the next forty years over a cocktail. Maria argues for "Low Stakes, High Frequency." Get out there. Meet people. Practice being a person who dates.
The Problem with "Situationships"
The Ask a Matchmaker book takes a hard line on the "situationship."
If you’ve been seeing someone for three months and you don't know where you stand, you have your answer. You’re not "going with the flow." You’re being "dragged by the current."
👉 See also: What Does the Name McKenzie Mean? The Real History Behind the Hype
Maria empowers readers to ask for what they want. If the other person runs away because you asked for clarity, they weren't the right person anyway. It’s better to know at month three than at year three.
Final Thoughts and Moving Forward
The Ask a Matchmaker book isn't a magic wand. You won't read it and suddenly find a ring on your finger the next morning. What it does provide is a shift in perspective. It moves you from a passive participant in your own life to an active curator of your future.
It's about dignity. It's about knowing your worth without being "entitled." It’s about realizing that dating is a numbers game, but you can tilt the odds in your favor by being authentic and prepared.
Next Steps for Better Dating:
- Audit Your Profile: Open your favorite dating app right now. Delete any photo where you are wearing sunglasses or standing in a group of five people where we can't tell who you are.
- Define Your Top Three: Write down three non-negotiable values (not physical traits). If someone doesn't share these, they don't get a second date.
- The 72-Hour Rule: If you’re interested in someone, move the conversation from the app to a date (or at least a phone call) within 72 hours. Don't become a pen pal.
- Embrace the "No": Start looking at a "no" from a potential partner as a gift. They just saved you months of wasted time. Thank them (internally) and move on.
- Read the Source: Grab a copy of the Ask a Matchmaker book and keep it by your bed. Flip to a random page when you’re feeling frustrated with the dating scene. It’s a great reality check.
Dating doesn't have to be a chore. It can be an adventure, provided you have a map. Maria Avgitidis has basically drawn that map; you just have to follow the lines.