High school is a fever dream of bad haircuts and unearned confidence. You remember that one kid who took the Les Misérables solo way too seriously? Or maybe you were the person hiding in the back of the chorus line, just hoping your voice didn't crack during the big finale. Well, Kristen Bell decided to bottle that specific brand of nostalgia, anxiety, and theater-kid energy and turn it into a show called Encore!
It's been a few years since the series hit Disney+, but it’s still one of the most painfully relatable things on the platform. Honestly, it’s not just about singing. It’s about facing the person you were at seventeen.
What actually happened on Encore!
The premise was pretty simple, though the logistics must have been a nightmare for the producers. Essentially, the show reunited former high school castmates to restage their original musical—decades later. We’re talking about adults with mortgages, kids, and back pain trying to fit back into their 1994 costumes for Annie or The Sound of Music.
They only had five days.
Think about that for a second. These aren't Broadway professionals. They are accountants from New Jersey or stay-at-home parents from California who haven't looked at a script since the Clinton administration. In less than a week, they had to relearn lines, master choreography from industry legends like Adam Shankman, and perform in front of a live audience. It was chaotic. It was messy. And that’s exactly why it worked.
The cast that broke the internet
One of the most talked-about episodes featured the 1991 cast of Anything Goes from Los Alamitos High School. It wasn't just the performance that grabbed people; it was the raw, unfiltered look at how life changes people. You had cast members who hadn't spoken in twenty years dealing with old grudges and unrequited crushes.
The show didn't lean too hard into the "reality TV drama" tropes, though. It felt more like a therapy session with jazz hands.
Why Encore! hit different than other reality shows
Most reality TV feels fake. You know the drill: scripted fights, staged "walk-outs," and people desperate for fame. Encore! felt like the opposite. These people didn't want to be famous; they just wanted to see if they still had "it." Or, at the very least, they wanted to prove to their kids that they weren't always boring.
The stakes were weirdly high.
If you mess up a dance routine on Dancing with the Stars, who cares? You’re a celebrity getting a paycheck. But if you mess up your solo in front of your old high school drama teacher? That's a soul-crushing defeat. The vulnerability was real.
Broadway experts behind the scenes
To keep the show from being a total train wreck, Disney brought in the heavy hitters. We're talking about world-class directors and choreographers.
👉 See also: Victor Mature: Why We Still Get This Hollywood Legend Wrong
- Jeremy Jordan: The Broadway star helped guide the cast of The Sound of Music.
- Susan Egan: The original Belle on Broadway worked with a group doing Beauty and the Beast.
- Anne Kaye: A veteran who didn't let anyone slack off.
These experts didn't baby the participants. They pushed them. It reminded the audience that musical theater is actually incredibly hard work. You can't just "wing it" when you're doing Oklahoma!.
The "Cringe" factor is a feature, not a bug
Let’s be real. There are moments in Encore! that are hard to watch. Watching a 45-year-old man try to hit a high note while his voice cracks is objectively uncomfortable. But that’s the point. We live in a world of filtered Instagram photos and perfectly edited TikToks. Seeing people be bad at something—and then getting slightly better—is weirdly inspiring.
It taps into this universal feeling that our best years might be behind us. The show argues they aren't. It suggests that you can reclaim a piece of your younger self, even if you can't hit the high C anymore.
The logistics of a reunion
You might wonder how they found these people. The production team spent months tracking down entire casts. Imagine getting a call out of the blue asking if you want to play a teapot again for a Disney+ special. Some people said no, obviously. But the ones who said yes usually had something to prove to themselves.
The filming took place at various theaters across the country, often returning to the original high school stages where these people first performed. The smell of floor wax and old curtains is a powerful drug.
Is there a Season 2?
This is the question that haunts the forums. As of now, Disney+ hasn't moved forward with a second season. The first season aired back in 2019/2020, and then the world kind of shut down. Coordinating a show that requires dozens of people to fly in, rehearse in close quarters, and perform for a crowd became impossible for a while.
But the demand is still there.
Fans constantly tweet at Kristen Bell asking for a revival. The show has a "long tail" on streaming because it’s evergreen. You can watch it today and it feels just as relevant as it did four years ago.
Why it’s harder to make than you think
Music licensing is a beast. Getting the rights to perform Grease or Guys and Dolls on a streaming platform isn't cheap. Each episode of Encore! required separate negotiations for the songs. Plus, you have to pay the original cast members, the professional directors, and the crew. It’s a high-budget production for what is essentially a niche "human interest" story.
Still, the emotional payoff is huge.
How to have your own Encore! moment
You don't need a Disney+ budget to tap into this feeling. Honestly, the show sparked a bit of a movement of people looking up their old high school friends. If you're feeling that itch to revisit your "glory days," here is how you can actually do it without the camera crew.
- Dig up the old tapes: Most of us have a grainy VHS or a DVD of a school play gathering dust. Digitalize it. Watching yourself mess up a line at sixteen is the best ego check you can get.
- The "Five-Day" Challenge: Pick a hobby you gave up. Piano? Painting? Singing? Give yourself five days of intensive practice. Don't worry about being good. Just worry about doing it.
- Reach out to one person: You don't need the whole cast. Just text that one person you used to share a dressing room with. You’ll be surprised how much they remember.
- Support local theater: If you miss the energy of the show, go see a community theater production. Those people are doing exactly what the Encore! cast did—working 9-to-5 jobs and then rehearsing until midnight because they love the craft.
Encore! reminds us that the curtain never really closes. You just get different roles as you get older. Maybe you're not the lead anymore. Maybe you're the parent in the audience. But the music is still there if you're willing to sing along.
Go find your old script. It’s probably in a box in the attic. Even if you don't perform it, just reading the lines will bring back the smell of hairspray and the feeling that anything was possible. That’s the real magic Kristen Bell was trying to capture.
The next step is simple. Stop scrolling and go do that thing you used to love before you got "too busy" for it. Whether it's singing in the shower or signing up for an adult improv class, just start. Life is too short to leave your best performances in the past.