You’ve seen it a thousand times. It’s right there on every greenback in your wallet, tucked neatly between the Federal Reserve seal and the portrait of a dead president. The phrase for all debts public and private looks like a straightforward legal command. Most people think it means a cashier has to take your crumpled five-dollar bill if you’re buying a soda. Honestly, it doesn't. Not exactly.
Federal law is a funny thing. The specific language comes from Section 31 U.S.C. 5103. It says United States coins and currency are legal tender for all debts, public charges, taxes, and dues. But there is a massive gulf between "legal tender" and "required payment method."
The Retail Reality Check
Walk into a high-end boutique in Manhattan or a trendy salad chain in D.C., and you might see a sign that says "No Cash Accepted." You’d think that’s illegal, right? Because of the for all debts public and private rule?
✨ Don't miss: NVDA Stock Current Price: What Most People Get Wrong About the $185 Mark
Nope.
The Federal Reserve itself clarifies this quite bluntly on its own website. There is no federal statute mandating that a private business, a person, or an organization must accept currency or coins as payment for goods or services. If a business wants to develop a "cards only" policy, they are generally free to do so, provided there isn't a specific state law saying otherwise.
Think about it this way: a transaction at a store is a contract. Before you buy that $10 salad, the business can set the terms of the contract. If they say "we only take seashells," and you agree to it by staying in line, that's the deal. The phrase for all debts public and private only really kicks in when a debt already exists.
When the Phrase Actually Matters
Debt is the keyword.
If you eat a full meal at a restaurant and then the bill comes, you now have a debt. You have consumed a service and owe money. In this specific scenario, if you offer U.S. currency and they refuse it, they might have a hard time suing you for non-payment. Why? Because you offered a valid "legal tender" to satisfy a debt that already occurred.
The same applies to the IRS or your local DMV. These are "public" debts. If you owe back taxes, the government basically has to accept the currency they issued. It would be pretty ironic if they didn't.
The History of Legal Tender in America
We didn't always have a unified currency that worked for all debts public and private. Back in the mid-1800s, the U.S. was a mess of "broken bank" notes. Local banks printed their own money. It was chaotic. Imagine trying to buy a horse in Ohio with a piece of paper issued by a bank in Georgia that might not even exist anymore.
The Legal Tender Act of 1862 changed everything.
The Union needed to fund the Civil War. They started printing "Greenbacks." To make people actually use them, the government declared them legal tender. This was controversial. People hated it. They wanted gold. The Supreme Court even waffled on it. In Hepburn v. Griswold (1870), the court initially said the government couldn't force people to accept paper money for debts contracted before the act.
They reversed that decision just a year later in the Legal Tender Cases. The Justices basically realized that if they didn't back the currency, the entire post-war economy would collapse.
Sovereign Citizen Myths
You might have stumbled across some dark corners of the internet where people claim for all debts public and private means you can pay off your mortgage with a "Bill of Exchange" or some secret government trust account.
It’s all nonsense.
These "Redemptionist" theories usually involve some wild misinterpretation of the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC) or the idea that the U.S. went bankrupt in 1933. They argue that because we left the gold standard, we don't have "real" money anymore, so any debt can be discharged by just saying the right magic legal words.
Don't try this. People have gone to prison for trying to pay their "public and private" debts with fake documents based on these theories. The courts have heard these arguments thousands of times. They lose every single time. Federal Reserve notes are the only legal tender for these debts, whether you like the fiat system or not.
State Laws That Fight Back
While federal law doesn't force businesses to take cash, some states feel differently. They think "cashless" stores discriminate against the "unbanked"—people who don't have credit cards or bank accounts.
- Massachusetts has had a law on the books since 1978 requiring retailers to accept cash.
- New Jersey and Rhode Island passed similar bans on cashless stores more recently.
- Cities like Philadelphia and San Francisco have also jumped on the bandwagon.
In these places, the phrase for all debts public and private gets some extra teeth from local legislation. But even there, there are exceptions. Parking garages or vending machines often get a pass because it's "impractical" to handle cash.
Why Does This Matter Today?
We are moving toward a digital-first economy. Central Bank Digital Currencies (CBDCs) are being discussed globally. If the physical dollar disappears, what happens to the legal tender status?
If the phrase for all debts public and private eventually applies to a digital token, the privacy implications are massive. Cash is anonymous. A digital dollar isn't. This is why the technical wording on your physical bills is becoming a rallying cry for privacy advocates. They see the physical "legal tender" status as a final frontier of financial freedom.
Actionable Steps for Navigating Payments
If you’re a consumer or a small business owner, knowing the nuances of legal tender saves you from unnecessary legal headaches.
For Business Owners:
Check your state and local laws before going 100% cashless. If you are in a jurisdiction that requires cash acceptance, you must provide a way for customers to pay in physical currency, or you risk significant fines. Even if it's legal in your area, consider the "unbanked" population—roughly 6% of U.S. households—who might be excluded from your business.
For Consumers:
Understand that a private business can refuse your $100 bill. Many stores do this to avoid counterfeit risk or because they don't keep enough change in the drawer. This is perfectly legal. However, if you are paying off a pre-existing debt (like a hospital bill or a car loan), the creditor is generally obligated to accept legal tender. If they refuse a cash payment for a debt, document the refusal in writing.
For Those Concerned With Privacy:
Continue to support the use of physical currency. The legal tender status of the dollar is what keeps cash viable in a world of digital tracking. Using cash for "private" debts is one of the few ways to maintain a transaction record that isn't sold to advertisers or monitored by third-party processors.
The words on the bill haven't changed in decades, but the world around them has. Whether we're talking about a cup of coffee or a federal tax lien, the way we settle our debts is constantly evolving. Just don't expect the "legal tender" line to save you if you try to buy a sandwich with a bucket of pennies—most judges will call that an "unreasonable" attempt to satisfy the debt.
✨ Don't miss: Who Owns Google Inc: What Most People Get Wrong
Maintain a mix of payment options. Stay aware of your local statutes. And remember: the paper in your pocket is a tool, not a magic wand that overrides a store's right to set their own rules.