Sometimes you just want to wing it. We live in a culture that worships the "disruptor"—that person who breaks all the rules, ignores the manual, and manages to build a unicorn startup from a garage while wearing pajamas. It sounds cool. It looks great on LinkedIn. But honestly? Most of the time, that's a recipe for a total train wreck. There is a massive, underrated power in going by the book, and it’s time we stop treating "the book" like a dusty relic of the 1950s corporate world.
Rules exist for a reason. Usually, that reason is that someone, somewhere, messed up so spectacularly that a policy had to be written to prevent it from happening again. When you follow the established protocol, you aren't being uncreative. You're being efficient. You are leveraging the collective trauma and experience of everyone who came before you.
The Real Cost of Ignoring the Manual
Let’s look at aviation. If there is any industry where going by the book is the difference between a normal Tuesday and a national tragedy, it’s flight. Pilots don't "vibe" their way through a pre-flight check. They use checklists. Even if they’ve flown the same Boeing 737 for twenty years, they read the lines. Every single time.
In the medical field, it's the same story. Dr. Atul Gawande wrote a famous book—ironically titled The Checklist Manifesto—about how simple, "by the book" procedures dramatically slashed infection rates and surgical errors. We're talking about world-class surgeons, people with a decade of post-grad education, realizing that they aren't "too good" for a basic list of rules. If a neurosurgeon can follow a manual, you can probably follow the SOP for your marketing campaign or your plumbing business.
People hate rules because they feel restrictive. It feels like your boss is breathing down your neck. But flip the script for a second. When you follow the procedure, the responsibility shifts. If you follow the manual and things go sideways, the system failed, not you. If you go rogue and it breaks? That’s all on your head.
Why We Fight the System
Why do we resist? Ego. Pure and simple. We want to feel special. We want to believe our intuition is better than the "boring" way everyone else does it. In business, this shows up as "skipping the paperwork" or "eye-balling the budget."
It feels faster in the moment. It’s not.
You save ten minutes today by skipping the documentation, and then you spend ten hours next month trying to figure out what you did when it inevitably breaks. It’s a classic case of "slow is smooth, and smooth is fast." This phrase is a staple in military training, particularly with the Navy SEALs. They prioritize the technical, by-the-book mechanics of handling a weapon because, in a high-stress environment, your "creativity" will fail you. Your training—the rules—won't.
🔗 Read more: Jack in the Box Olathe: Why the Tacos Vanished and What's Next
When Going by the Book is Actually a Competitive Advantage
In a world where everyone is trying to be "disruptive," being the person who actually follows through and does things correctly is a superpower. Think about your last experience with a contractor. If they showed up on time, followed the building code to the letter, and filled out all the permits without you asking, you’d probably marry them.
Why? Because it’s rare.
Reliability is built on the foundation of going by the book. It creates a predictable result. For a business, predictability is more valuable than occasional flashes of brilliance. If I go to a restaurant, I want the burger to taste exactly like it did last time. I don't want the chef to have an "experimental phase" with my dinner. Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs) are what allowed companies like McDonald's or Starbucks to scale globally. It’s not about the best coffee; it’s about the most consistent process.
The Nuance: When to Throw the Book Away
Look, I’m not saying you should be a robot. There are times when the book is wrong.
Usually, the book is wrong when the environment changes faster than the rules can be updated. This is what happened in the early days of the digital revolution. Traditional retail "books" said you needed physical storefronts to be credible. Jeff Bezos ignored that. But notice something: he didn't ignore the rules of logistics or customer service. He followed those "books" better than anyone else. He just picked a different book to follow.
💡 You might also like: Pre Market Gainers and Losers: What Most People Get Wrong
You have to know the rules to break them effectively. Picasso didn't start with cubism. He spent years mastering traditional, "by the book" painting and anatomy. Only once he could paint a perfect realistic portrait did he decide to start moving the eyes around. Most people try to move the eyes before they know how to draw a face.
- Master the standard first. Don't try to innovate until you can execute the basic version perfectly.
- Audit your "book." Is your company manual from 1994? If the rules are based on outdated tech, they aren't rules; they're obstacles.
- Document the "why." If you’re a leader, don't just tell people to follow the rules. Explain the disaster that happened the last time someone didn't.
Practical Steps for Implementation
If you want to start reaping the benefits of a more structured approach without losing your soul, start small.
First, identify the one task you do every week that stresses you out. Usually, it stresses you out because you’re reinventing the wheel every time you do it. Sit down and write a three-step process for it. That’s your book. Follow it next week. See how much mental energy you save when you don't have to make a dozen tiny decisions.
Second, check your compliance. In many industries—finance, healthcare, construction—going by the book isn't just a good idea; it's the law. The fines for "winging it" are often enough to bankrupt a small firm. Take a day to actually read the regulations you’re supposed to be following. You might be surprised at what you're missing.
Lastly, value the "boring" people on your team. We often prize the "rockstars" who pull off miracles at the last minute. But the person who does their job steadily, follows the process, and never has a "miracle" because they never let a crisis develop in the first place? They are your most valuable asset. Reward the people who stay the course.
Stop looking for the shortcut. The shortcut is usually just a longer path to a mistake. By strictly going by the book, you clear the mental clutter, reduce your risk, and actually give yourself the freedom to be creative in the areas that actually matter. Consistency is the only thing that scales.
Everything else is just luck.
Actionable Takeaways to Master the Process
- Create "Minimum Viable Documentation." Don't write a 50-page manual. Start with a one-page "Cheat Sheet" for your most frequent tasks. Use bold text and simple steps.
- Conduct a "Rule Audit." Every six months, look at your internal processes. If a rule no longer serves a purpose or protects against a real risk, delete it. A "book" filled with useless rules is a book no one will read.
- Practice "Deliberate Compliance." For one week, commit to following every instruction exactly as written. Note where you feel the urge to deviate. Those "urges" are often where your biggest mistakes are hiding.
- Reference Real Standards. Instead of making up your own rules, look to industry leaders. Use the ISO standards or the Project Management Body of Knowledge (PMBOK). These are the "books" for a reason—they've been vetted by thousands of experts.