Time loops are usually stressful. You're stuck in a car crash, a murder mystery, or a war zone, over and over until you figure out how to stop the bleeding. But then there’s Hallmark Round and Round. It’s basically what happens when you take the high-concept physics of Groundhog Day and drop them into a cozy Hanukkah celebration in a Brooklyn apartment. No world-ending stakes. Just a lot of latkes, a very persistent mom, and a girl named Rachel who really, really wants to get to her parents’ party on time.
Honestly, most holiday movies feel like they were written by an algorithm that was fed nothing but gingerbread and "I'm a big city lawyer returning to my small town." This one is different. It’s smart. It’s fast. It stars Vic Michaelis, who brings this chaotic, frantic energy that makes you feel like you’re actually losing your mind along with her character. If you've ever felt trapped in a family holiday that seemingly won't end, this movie is going to hit a little too close to home.
The premise is straightforward but the execution is where it gets weirdly deep. Rachel is stuck in the seventh night of Hanukkah. She wakes up, her alarm goes off, she gets on the train, she meets a nerdy guy named Zach (played by Bryan Greenberg), and she ends up at her parents' house. Then it resets. Wash, rinse, repeat.
The Physics of a Hanukkah Time Loop
Most people think Hallmark movies are just background noise while you wrap gifts. Hallmark Round and Round demands you actually pay attention because the writing team, led by screenwriter Marianna Gallegos, leans into the "nerd" aspect of the plot. Zach, the love interest, isn't a rugged lumberjack or a corporate shark. He’s a guy who works at a comic book shop. This matters. When Rachel realizes she’s in a loop, she doesn't go to a scientist; she goes to the guy who knows the rules of the genre.
It’s refreshing.
👉 See also: Why The Oceanography of the Moon Still Hits Different Years Later
Instead of the usual "magic of Christmas" (or Hanukkah) hand-waving, the movie treats the time loop like a puzzle to be solved. They talk about tropes. They talk about "save states." It’s meta without being annoying. You’re watching a movie about a time loop where the characters know they are in a time-loop movie. It’s a bit of a brain-bender for a network known for predictable endings.
The chemistry between Michaelis and Greenberg works because it’s built on shared frustration. Rachel is a perfectionist. She’s trying to land a big publishing deal and she’s trying to be the perfect daughter. The loop isn't just a gimmick; it’s a cosmic intervention forcing her to stop "performing" her life and actually live it. You see her go through the classic stages of grief. First, she’s confused. Then she’s terrified. Then she gets bored and starts doing whatever she wants—which, in a Hallmark setting, mostly involves eating way too many donuts and being brutally honest with her sister.
Why the Seventh Night Matters
Hanukkah isn't just a backdrop here. The eighth day represents "new beginnings," but Rachel is stuck on the seventh. There is a symbolic weight to being stuck right before the finish line.
Director Stacey N. Harding captures the claustrophobia of a New York apartment perfectly. You know that feeling when you're at a family gathering and you've told the same story three times and you're just ready to go home? Now imagine doing that for an eternity. The film uses a warm, amber-toned color palette that usually feels comforting, but as the loops progress, that same warmth starts to feel heavy. It’s clever filmmaking.
🔗 Read more: Kerry Condon F1 Role: Why Kate McKenna is the Movie’s Real MVP
One of the best things about Hallmark Round and Round is the supporting cast. Rick Hoffman (who you probably know as Louis Litt from Suits) plays Rachel’s dad. He’s fantastic. He brings a grounded, fatherly warmth that keeps the movie from drifting too far into sci-fi territory. The family dynamics feel real. They argue about the "right" way to make latkes. They needle each other about career choices. It feels like a real Jewish family in Brooklyn, not a caricature.
Breaking the Cycle (Without the Usual Cliches)
In a typical romance, the "lesson" is usually just that the protagonist needs to fall in love. In this story, the romance is almost a byproduct of Rachel’s personal growth. She has to learn that she can't control every outcome. She can’t "optimize" her way out of life.
There’s a specific scene where Rachel just stops trying to fix the loop and decides to help everyone else with their problems instead. It’s the "Phil Connors" moment, but it feels more intimate because it’s happening in her childhood home. She helps her sister with a secret project. She actually listens to her mom. She learns things about her family that she was too busy to notice during the "first" seventh night.
This is where the movie earns its keep. It argues that we are all in loops of our own making. We wake up, we check our phones, we go to work, we say the same three things to our partners, and we go to sleep. We don't need a magical glowing dreidel to be stuck in a cycle. We’re already there.
The Production Behind the Magic
Filmed in Winnipeg (standing in for New York, as is tradition), the production managed to make a Canadian winter look like a crisp Brooklyn December. But the real star is the script. It’s snappy. The dialogue moves at a clip that feels more like a 1940s screwball comedy than a modern TV movie.
Michaelis, coming from an improv and sketch comedy background, was a casting masterstroke. Their timing is impeccable. When you have to repeat the same lines ten times in one movie, you have to find a way to make it funny or poignant in a different way each time. Michaelis finds those layers. One minute they are playing the scene for laughs, the next they look genuinely heartbroken that they are still trapped.
- The Dreidel Factor: The movie uses a specific heirloom dreidel as the "anchor" for the loop.
- The Nerd Representation: Seeing a Hallmark lead who genuinely likes comic books and doesn't treat it as a "quirk to be fixed" is a nice touch.
- The Music: The score leans into the repetitive nature of the plot without being grating.
Common Misconceptions About This Movie
People hear "Hallmark Hanukkah movie" and they expect a watered-down version of a Christmas movie where they just swapped the tree for a menorah. That has happened in the past. But Hallmark Round and Round is culturally specific. It feels authentic to the experience of a secular Jewish family. The jokes about the "best" bakery, the specific rhythms of the dinner conversation—it’s all there.
Another misconception is that it’s just a Groundhog Day rip-off. While it clearly pays homage to the Harold Ramis classic, it’s more of a spiritual cousin to Palm Springs or Russian Doll, but with a G-rating. It’s less about the cosmic horror of existing forever and more about the small-scale beauty of getting a second (and twentieth) chance to be a better person.
The stakes are low, but the emotions are high. That’s the Hallmark sweet spot. You aren't worried that Rachel is going to die; you're worried that she’s never going to find out what her sister is hiding, or that she’ll never get to have that one perfect dance with Zach.
How to Get the Most Out of Your Viewing
If you’re going to watch it, pay attention to the background details. Because it’s a time loop movie, the set dressing changes slightly to reflect Rachel’s state of mind. When she’s chaotic, the apartment looks more cluttered. When she starts to find peace, the lighting shifts.
It’s also worth watching with someone who loves "Easter eggs." There are plenty of nods to classic sci-fi and romance tropes hidden in the comic book shop scenes.
Actionable Insights for the Hallmark Fan
If you enjoyed the structure and tone of this film, there are a few things you can do to find similar high-quality "elevated" holiday content:
- Look for the Screenwriter: Keep an eye out for Marianna Gallegos’ future projects. She has a knack for taking tired tropes and injecting them with actual wit.
- Follow the Lead: Vic Michaelis is a rising star in the comedy world. Check out their work in the improv space—it explains why their performance in this movie feels so spontaneous.
- Check the "New" Hallmark: This movie is part of a broader trend at the network to move away from the "Cookie Cutter" era. Look for movies under the "Hallmark Movies & Mysteries" or "Hallmark+ " banners for more experimental storytelling.
- Host a Comparison Night: Watch this back-to-back with Groundhog Day. It’s a fascinating exercise in how the same "logic" can be used to tell a completely different story about family and faith.
Ultimately, Hallmark Round and Round succeeds because it doesn't take itself too seriously, yet it takes its characters very seriously. It’s a movie that understands that sometimes, the only way to move forward is to stop running and just enjoy the latkes while they’re hot.
✨ Don't miss: Why Panic\! At The Disco's When the Day Met the Night is the Best Song You’ve Probably Forgotten
To dive deeper into the world of holiday films that break the mold, you can check out the official Hallmark Channel schedule or look up the "Countdown to Christmas" and "Miracles of Hanukkah" lineups. There’s a lot of fluff out there, but every now and then, you find a gem that’s worth watching on repeat—literally.