You’ve seen them. Those chalky, pastel little bricks that taste like a mixture of wintergreen and drywall. They’ve been around longer than your grandparents, and honestly, the heart of candy industry wouldn't be the same without the Conversation Heart. We’re talking about a candy that has survived world wars, company bankruptcies, and the rise of artisanal chocolate.
It’s weird, right? We live in an era of gourmet sea-salt caramels, yet every February, we find ourselves digging through a box of Necco or Brach’s just to find the one that says "UR CUTE."
The history isn't just about sugar. It’s about machinery. Back in 1847, an English pharmacist named Oliver Chase was trying to make lozenges. He invented a machine—basically the first American candy machine—that cut dough into discs. He realized people liked the sugar more than the medicine. Eventually, his brother Daniel Chase figured out how to print words on them using vegetable dye. That was the birth of the heart of candy tradition.
The Drama Behind the Sweetness
Most people don’t realize how close we came to losing these things forever. In 2018, the New England Confectionery Company (Necco) went under. It was a disaster for fans of the original Sweethearts. People were literally panic-buying boxes on eBay for $100. It sounds fake, but it happened.
📖 Related: YNAB Paying Credit Card: What Most People Get Wrong
Eventually, Spangler Candy Company—the folks who make Dum Dums—bought the brand. But they ran into a massive problem. They didn't have the original equipment ready for the next Valentine’s season. For one whole year, there were no official Sweethearts on the shelves.
It was a total mess.
When they finally brought them back, the printing was blurry. Some hearts were blank. People were furious. It shows you how much we rely on the nostalgia of the heart of candy to ground our holidays. If the "Kiss Me" heart is missing, is it even February 14th? Probably not.
How They’re Actually Made (It’s Not What You Think)
You might think these are baked. They aren't.
Basically, the process is more like making ceramics than cooking. You mix sugar, corn syrup, gelatin, and flavors into a dough. It feels like Play-Doh. Then, you roll it flat, stamp out the shapes, and let them air dry for up to 48 hours. That’s why they have that specific "snap" when you bite them.
The Flavor Profile
Let's be real: the flavors are controversial.
- Yellow: Usually banana (everyone hates these).
- Green: Wintergreen (tastes like toothpaste, but in a nostalgic way).
- Orange: Standard citrus.
- Purple: Grape or sometimes "clove" in the old-school batches.
- White: Peppermint or plain sugar.
- Pink: Cherry or wintergreen, depending on the brand.
Brach’s and Sweethearts have slightly different recipes. Brach’s tends to be a bit softer, while the original Sweethearts are the ones that could probably survive a nuclear winter.
The Evolution of the Message
The "heart of candy" has to stay relevant, or it dies. In the early 1900s, the messages were long and formal. Things like "Please send a lock of your hair" or "Can you cook?" (Seriously). Imagine giving that to a date today. You’d be blocked immediately.
As the hearts got smaller, the messages got shorter.
Now, we have "Text Me," "YOLO," and "Galentine." Spangler actually takes suggestions from the public. They look at what’s trending on social media to decide which phrases to retire. "Fax Me" is definitely in the graveyard now.
Why We Keep Buying Them
It isn't about the taste. Honestly, most people would rather eat a Reese’s. It’s about the ritual. The heart of candy serves a social purpose. It’s a low-stakes way to flirt. It’s a classroom tradition for kids who are too shy to say anything out loud.
There's also a psychological element called "sensory-specific satiety," but in reverse. We don't eat them because they're the best-tasting thing in the world; we eat them because they represent a specific moment in time.
Market Dominance
The numbers are staggering.
Over 8 billion conversation hearts are produced every year. That’s enough to stretch from Rome to Arizona and back. Most of these are sold in the six weeks leading up to Valentine’s Day. If a company misses that window, they're toast.
Spotting the Fakes
Not all conversation hearts are created equal. If you’re looking for the "authentic" experience, you have to look at the texture.
- Chalky vs. Gummy: The true heart of candy is compressed sugar. If it’s chewy, it’s a modern variation, often called "Sour Hearts."
- The Print Quality: Since 2020, the printing has been hit or miss due to the move to new factories. Some people collect the "misfit" hearts with upside-down text.
- The Smell: It should smell like a vintage pharmacy.
Is the Heart of Candy Healthy?
Look, it’s 90% sugar. We’re not going to pretend this is kale. However, compared to chocolate, they are fat-free. They’re basically pure glucose. If you have dietary restrictions, you need to watch out for the gelatin, which means most traditional hearts aren't vegan. Some brands use cornstarch instead, but you’ve gotta check the label.
✨ Don't miss: ¿Cuantas coras son un dolar? Lo que nadie te explica sobre el cambio en la calle
Modern Variations and DIY
Lately, there’s been a huge surge in "Anti-Valentine" hearts. These are hilarious. They say things like "Ugh," "No," or "Friend Zone." It turns the whole heart of candy concept on its head.
If you’re feeling crafty, you can actually make these at home with some fondant and edible ink pens. It’s a lot of work, but at least you can control the flavor. No more yellow banana hearts if you don't want them.
Actionable Steps for the Best Experience
If you're planning on using conversation hearts this year, here’s how to actually enjoy them:
- Check the "Best By" Date: While they last forever, they do get rock-hard after a year. If you find a bag in the back of your pantry from 2023, just throw it out. Your teeth will thank you.
- Use Them for Decor: They look better in a glass jar than they taste in your mouth. Use them as a "filler" for candle holders or vases.
- Go Brand Specific: If you want the classic "medicine" taste, go for Necco/Sweethearts. If you want something that actually tastes like fruit, go with Brach’s or even the Starburst version.
- Read the Bag: Look for "Natural Flavors" if you're sensitive to dyes, though most of these use Red 40 to get that iconic pink.
- Pairing: Surprisingly, the tartness of the hearts goes okay with a dry sparkling wine. It cuts through the sugar.
The heart of candy isn't going anywhere. It’s a billion-dollar niche that relies on our collective memory of being a kid in a classroom, handing out little paper boxes. Whether you love the taste or use them as literal gravel, they are the undisputed heavyweights of the holiday season.
Next Steps for Your Valentine's Prep
- Audit your stash: Check your local stores early (late January) because the "good" brands like Spangler’s Sweethearts sell out weeks before the 14th.
- Get creative: Use the hearts as "tokens" for a board game or as cupcake toppers rather than just eating them by the handful.
- Read the labels: If you have allergies, be aware that many of these are processed in facilities that handle peanuts and soy, even if the ingredients seem "clean."