Guillermo del Toro is a monster nerd. I mean that in the most respectful way possible. When he made Hellboy II: The Golden Army, he didn't just want to make a sequel; he wanted to build a world that felt like it had existed for a thousand years before the cameras even started rolling.
It's been years since it hit theaters in 2008. People still talk about The Dark Knight from that same summer—and for good reason—but honestly? Big Red’s second outing is just as impressive in its own weird, clockwork-heavy way. It’s a movie that balances a blue-collar demon eating pancakes with a heartbreaking elven genocide. That's a hard tightrope to walk.
The visual insanity of the Troll Market
Most directors would have used green screens for everything. Not del Toro. When Hellboy and the B.P.R.D. head into the Troll Market hidden under the Brooklyn Bridge, you're looking at a physical set. It was massive. They built it in a former cavernous limestone quarry in Hungary.
📖 Related: Do You Hear What I Hear: The Surprising History of a Cold War Carol
The detail is staggering. You’ve got vendors selling "cat meat," strange multi-limbed creatures shuffling in the background, and a guy with a giant hand on his head. It’s dense. You can watch that scene ten times and still see something new in the corner of the frame. It’s the kind of practical effects work that feels tactile. You can almost smell the dampness and the rot.
Ron Perlman is the heart of it all. Under hours of makeup, he manages to be incredibly expressive. He’s grumpy. He’s tired. He just wants to smoke his cigar and watch TV with Liz Sherman, played by Selma Blair. Their relationship is the grounding force. It’s not a "superhero" romance; it’s a messy, domestic argument between two people who happen to have thermal-nuclear powers and demonic heritage.
Prince Nuada and the villain problem
Most Marvel movies today have a "villain problem." They’re usually just mirror versions of the hero who want to blow up the world because... reasons. Hellboy II: The Golden Army gives us Prince Nuada, played by Luke Goss.
Nuada isn't "evil" in the traditional sense. He’s an environmentalist with a sword. He’s watched humanity destroy the natural world, paving over the magic of the old earth with parking lots and shopping malls. He wants to wake up the Golden Army—an unstoppable legion of 4,900 mechanical soldiers—to take back the planet.
You kinda get where he’s coming from.
The tragedy is that Hellboy is stuck in the middle. He’s a creature of magic who works for the humans who fear him. Nuada spends half the movie trying to convince Hellboy that he’s on the wrong side. "They will tire of you," he warns. And he’s right. That’s the punch in the gut. Hellboy is fighting for a world that will eventually put him in a cage.
The Angel of Death and the cost of living
One of the most haunting designs in cinema history appears in the final act: The Angel of Death.
Doug Jones, who plays Abe Sapien and the Chamberlain, also took on this role. The creature has no eyes on its face—they’re all along its wings. It’s creepy. It’s beautiful. And it delivers a prophecy that hangs over the rest of the (sadly unmade) trilogy. It tells Liz that saving Hellboy’s life will eventually lead to the destruction of the world.
She chooses him anyway.
That’s a heavy theme for a movie based on a Dark Horse comic. It moves away from the Lovecraftian "tentacle monsters" of the first film and dives straight into dark fairy tales. Mike Mignola’s art style is all about shadows and sharp angles, and while del Toro brings more color and "roundness" to the world, the soul of the comic is still there.
Why we never got Hellboy 3
It’s the question that haunts film forums. Why did this story end here?
The numbers are the boring answer. The movie made about $168 million against an $85 million budget. It did okay, but it wasn't a "megahit" by studio standards, especially because it opened right before the cultural earthquake of The Dark Knight. Universal Pictures wasn't willing to cough up the $150 million plus that del Toro needed for the finale.
Del Toro’s vision for the third film was massive. He described it as a "war" where Hellboy finally accepts his destiny as the Beast of the Apocalypse to defeat a greater foe. We got a reboot in 2019, but we won't talk about that. It lacked the grease, the gears, and the love that was poured into the 2008 film.
The mechanical genius of the Golden Army
Let’s talk about the soldiers themselves. They aren't just robots. They are clockwork machines powered by magic. The sound design here is incredible—every time they move, you hear the whirring of gears and the clinking of metal.
When they get broken, they self-repair. It’s a terrifying concept for an army. They don't feel pain, and they don't stop. The fight choreography in the final chamber is some of the best of that era. It’s fast, but you can always tell what’s happening. No "shaky cam" nonsense here. Just pure, operatic action.
Actionable ways to appreciate Hellboy II today
If you’re revisiting the film or watching it for the first time, don't just look at the main characters.
- Watch the background in the Troll Market: Look for the "fragile" beings and the weird anatomy of the background actors.
- Listen to the score: Danny Elfman took over for Marco Beltrami, and his work here is much more whimsical and gothic.
- Pay attention to the color theory: Notice how the B.P.R.D. scenes are cold, blue, and sterile, while the elven world is full of gold, amber, and deep reds. It’s a visual representation of the clash between technology and nature.
- Check out the "making of" documentaries: The DVD and Blu-ray extras for this film are a masterclass in production design. You can see how they sculpted the creatures and built the mechanical effects.
The legacy of Hellboy II: The Golden Army isn't just that it’s a "good comic book movie." It’s a reminder that blockbusters can be weird. They can be personal. They can be full of practical puppets and strange philosophy. It remains a high-water mark for the genre precisely because it cares more about its monsters than its explosions.