Books don't usually hit you like a physical weight, but this one does. Heather Marshall’s debut, Looking for Jane a novel, isn't just a story about the past. It’s a messy, heartbreaking, and ultimately defiant look at the lengths women go to for bodily autonomy. Most people pick it up thinking it’s a standard historical drama. It’s not. It is a multi-generational puzzle that tracks the "Jane" underground abortion network in Toronto, spanning from the 1960s to the 2010s.
Marshall tells a story that feels uncomfortably relevant. We follow three women: Evelyn, Nancy, and Angela. Their lives are decades apart, yet they are tethered by a single, secret thread.
Honestly, the real-world history behind the fiction is what keeps you up at night. The Jane Network wasn't some invented plot device for a book; it was a very real, very dangerous necessity in pre-1988 Canada. Before the Supreme Court of Canada’s R. v. Morgentaler decision, obtaining a safe abortion was a legal nightmare. Women were dying. This book captures that desperation without feeling like a dry history lecture. It feels like a heartbeat.
The Real History Behind Looking for Jane a Novel
If you’re diving into Looking for Jane a novel, you have to understand the "Janes." In the 1960s and 70s, "Jane" was the code name used by a clandestine group of women in Chicago, which inspired similar movements across North America, including the Toronto-based fictionalization Marshall presents.
It worked like this: you’d call a number, ask for "Jane," and get connected to a network that provided safe, albeit illegal, medical services.
Heather Marshall didn't just stumble onto this. She spent years researching the dark corners of Canadian history, specifically the "maternity homes" of the post-war era. These weren't homes. They were essentially prisons for unwed mothers. The "Bibi-Scoop" era, as it’s often called, involved the systemic forced adoption of babies born to single women. It’s a stain on the country’s history that many Canadians are still processing. In the book, Evelyn’s journey through one of these homes is perhaps the most gut-wrenching part of the narrative. It’s brutal. It’s honest.
You've probably heard people compare it to The Handmaid’s Tale. That’s a bit of a lazy comparison, if I’m being frank. Margaret Atwood’s work is speculative fiction. Marshall’s work is deeply rooted in things that actually happened to real people. That makes it scarier.
💡 You might also like: Van Zant: Why the Donnie Van Zant Band Still Matters in 2026
Three Timelines, One Secret
The structure of the book is a bit of a whirlwind.
We start in 2017 with Angela. She’s a modern woman who finds a misplaced letter that was never delivered. This letter is the "inciting incident," as they say in writing workshops. It leads her down a rabbit hole involving her own family’s history.
Then we have Nancy in 1971. She’s the heart of the "Jane" operations. She discovers the network after a personal crisis and becomes an integral part of the resistance. Her perspective is where the "spy thriller" elements of the book come out. You feel the tension of every phone call and every shadowed meeting.
Finally, there’s Evelyn in 1961. This is the hardest timeline to read. Evelyn is sent to St. Agnes’s, a home for unwed mothers run by the church. The coercion she faces to give up her child is documented with such visceral detail that you can almost smell the antiseptic in the hallways.
The way Marshall weaves these three together is masterful. Short sentences punctuate the trauma. Long, flowing descriptions bring the vintage Toronto setting to life. It’s a balancing act.
Why This Book Hits Differently in 2026
The world has changed since the book was published, and yet, it hasn't. With the reversal of Roe v. Wade in the United States and the ongoing global debates about reproductive rights, Looking for Jane a novel has transitioned from a historical look-back to a cautionary tale.
✨ Don't miss: Why Listen to Chappell Roan Red Wine Supernova Still Hits Different in 2026
Many readers are surprised to learn how recently these events occurred. We aren't talking about the 1800s. We are talking about our mothers and grandmothers.
The nuance in the writing is key. Marshall doesn’t paint every character in black and white. She acknowledges the complexity of the doctors who risked their licenses and the women who were forced into impossible choices. It isn't just "pro-choice" propaganda. It’s a human study of what happens when the state tries to control the most intimate aspects of a person's life.
Common Misconceptions About the Jane Network
- It was only in the U.S.: Wrong. While the Chicago group is the most famous, secret networks existed in almost every major Western city where abortion was banned.
- They were all doctors: Actually, many of the "Janes" were ordinary women who eventually learned to perform the procedures themselves because the demand was so high and the risk for licensed doctors was too great.
- It ended in 1973: Legislation changes didn't instantly make everything accessible. The struggle for actual, physical access to clinics lasted decades longer.
Looking for Jane a Novel: Literary Impact and Themes
The central theme here is motherhood—the stolen kind, the chosen kind, and the kind that is forced.
The book asks a difficult question: What makes a mother? Is it the biological act, or is it the choice to care? By following Angela’s modern-day discovery, we see the ripple effects of trauma across generations. It’s about the secrets families keep to protect themselves, which usually end up poisoning them instead.
Marshall’s prose is accessible. She doesn't use overly flowery language to hide the grit. When a character is in pain, you feel it. When Nancy is terrified of being caught by the police, your heart rate actually goes up.
There's a specific scene involving a lost letter that serves as a metaphor for the entire book. It’s about communication that was cut off—voices that were silenced by the law and the church. Finding that letter is about restoring those voices. It's about truth.
What to Do After Reading
If you’ve finished Looking for Jane a novel and you’re feeling a bit overwhelmed, you aren't alone. It’s a lot to process. The best way to handle the "book hangover" is to look into the actual history of the 1960s-80s reproductive rights movement.
- Research the "Bibi-Scoop": Look into the historical records of maternity homes in Canada and the UK. It’s eye-opening and provides much-needed context for Evelyn’s story.
- Support Reproductive Health Archives: Groups like the Ontario Women's History Network or local feminist archives often have primary sources from the real Jane networks.
- Read the Author’s Note: Heather Marshall includes a detailed section at the back of the book explaining where her research came from. Don’t skip it. It bridges the gap between the fiction you just read and the reality people lived.
- Visit Toronto's Historic Sites: If you’re in the area, seeing the neighborhoods mentioned—like the Annex or areas around the University of Toronto—makes the setting of the "Jane" clandestine meetings feel much more grounded.
The legacy of these women isn't just in books. It’s in the laws we have today and the rights that are still being fought for. Looking for Jane a novel serves as a vital reminder that progress is never a straight line; it’s a series of hard-won battles fought by people whose names we might never have known if not for stories like this one.