We’ve all been there. You show up to someone's living room, wine in hand, cheese plate ready, and then it happens. Silence. Or worse, the "polite circle." That's the part where everyone takes turns saying, "I liked the writing, but the ending was sad," and then proceeds to talk about their kids or the neighborhood's new parking permits for the next two hours. It’s a tragedy, honestly. If you’re picking book club books that everyone just "kind of liked," you’re doing it wrong. A good book club choice shouldn't be a crowd-pleaser; it should be a grenade.
The goal isn't to find something everyone agrees on. Who wants to sit in a room and nod for sixty minutes? You want the book that makes your friend Sarah get weirdly defensive about the protagonist's questionable parenting. You want the one that makes your quietest member finally snap and explain why the historical accuracy of the Victorian corsets is fundamentally flawed.
The Myth of the Likable Protagonist
There’s this weird pressure when picking book club books to find a character people can "root for." It’s a trap. If everyone likes the main character, there’s nothing to argue about. Take a book like The Push by Ashley Audrain or The Silent Patient by Alex Michaelides. These aren't necessarily "feel-good" stories. They are polarizing. People get heated about whether the mother in The Push was actually seeing what she thought she was seeing. That’s where the magic happens.
If you pick a book where the hero is a saint and the villain is a cartoon, your meeting will be over in ten minutes. Boring. You need moral ambiguity. You need characters who make bad choices for understandable reasons. Or bad choices for terrible reasons. Basically, you want a book that forces the group to talk about their own values.
Why "Vibe" Matters More Than Genre
Don't get stuck in the "we only read historical fiction" rut. It’s a death sentence for engagement. I’ve seen groups thrive on a mix of high-brow literary fiction like Demon Copperhead by Barbara Kingsolver—which, let’s be real, is a massive commitment—and then pivot to a fast-paced thriller or even a deeply researched non-fiction piece like Killers of the Flower Moon by David Grann.
Switching it up keeps the energy from stagnating. If you just finished a 500-page slog through 1940s France, for the love of everything, pick a beach read next. Or a memoir. Crying in H Mart by Michelle Zauner is a fantastic book club pick because it hits on grief, food, and identity—things everyone has an opinion on. It’s relatable, but it’s sharp.
The Secret Sauce: Narrative Tension vs. Page Count
Let’s be honest about something. People have lives. Sometimes, picking a 700-page epic is the quickest way to ensure only two people actually finish the book. Length matters. But what matters more is "propulsion."
A 200-page book can feel like a thousand pages if nothing happens. Conversely, something like Dark Matter by Blake Crouch moves so fast that people will finish it in two sittings. When selecting book club books, look for the "hook" within the first fifty pages. If it doesn't grab you by then, it’s probably going to be a struggle for the person in your group who is juggling a full-time job and three toddlers.
📖 Related: Beasts of burden meaning: Why we still rely on animals in a high-tech world
How to Actually Vet Your Book Club Books
Stop relying solely on the "Best Sellers" list at the front of the bookstore. Those lists are influenced by massive marketing budgets and pre-orders, not necessarily "discussability." Instead, look for what librarians are recommending or check out the longlists for the Booker Prize or the National Book Award. These often feature titles that are a bit more experimental or challenging.
Check the "Discussion Guide" trap. You know those questions in the back of the book? "How did the setting represent the character's inner turmoil?" skip them. They’re often too academic and dry. If you need a guide to find something to talk about, the book might not be meaty enough. The best questions are the ones that come up naturally: "Would you have stayed in that marriage?" or "Was the ending a cop-out?"
The Reliability Factor
Trust is everything in a book club. If the person picking the book hasn't even read the synopsis properly, the group loses faith. You don't have to have read the whole thing beforehand—that ruins the fun—but you should check a few "spoiler-free" reviews. Look for mentions of "pacing issues" or "unsatisfying endings." Sometimes a bad ending is actually great for a book club because everyone can complain about it together. Bonding through shared hatred is a very real thing.
Practical Steps for Your Next Selection
If you’re the one tasked with picking the next title, don't just throw out a single name.
- Offer a "Menu" of Three: Give the group three distinct options. Maybe one thriller, one contemporary fiction, and one "wildcard" (like a graphic novel or a true crime book).
- State the "Commitment Level": Be upfront. "This one is short but heavy," or "This is a long one, but it reads like a movie."
- Check Availability: There is nothing worse than picking a book that has a six-month waitlist at the local library or costs $30 in hardcover because the paperback isn't out yet. Always check if it’s available in multiple formats (audiobook, ebook, paperback).
Don't Fear the DNF (Did Not Finish)
We need to normalize not finishing the book. Seriously. If half the club couldn't get past page 100, that’s a discussion in itself! Why was it boring? Was it the prose? The characters? Sometimes the most interesting meetings happen when everyone agrees the book was a disaster. It’s better to be honest about it than to sit there pretending you enjoyed a slog.
Moving Forward with Better Reads
The best book club books are the ones that linger. You want the story that pops into your head three days after you’ve finished it. To find these, look at "Read-Alikes" for books your group previously loved. If you liked the atmospheric tension of The Sanatorium, look for other "locked-room" mysteries. If the group was fascinated by the historical details of The Nightingale, try something like The Island of Sea Women by Lisa See.
Start by looking at the "Indie Next" list from independent booksellers. These are titles chosen by people who actually read for a living, not just algorithms. Pick something that feels a little risky. Worst case scenario? You have a mediocre book and great wine. Best case? You have a conversation that lasts until midnight and changes how you see your friends.
Focus on the conflict. Focus on the "what would you do?" factor. And most importantly, stop picking books just because you think you "should" read them. Read what makes you want to talk.
To keep the momentum going, set a hard date for the next meeting before everyone leaves the current one. Use a shared digital poll like Doodle or even a simple WhatsApp group to vote on your three curated choices. This shifts the pressure off one person and gives everyone a sense of "buy-in" for the next month's journey. Keep the list of "runners-up" for future months so you’re never starting from zero when the next rotation comes around.