Ever get that sinking feeling when a company messes up your order, loses your data, or double-charges your account, and then—somehow—you’re the one who has to spend three hours on hold to fix it? It’s a phenomenon that’s basically become the default setting for modern commerce. We’re living in an era where our mistake is your responsibility is the unwritten Fine Print at the bottom of almost every digital contract you sign.
It’s frustrating. It’s exhausting. And honestly, it’s a calculated business strategy.
Think about the last time a flight was canceled. The airline’s scheduling software glitched—their mistake—but you were the one sleeping on a terminal floor, navigating a broken app, and fighting for a voucher that barely covers a lukewarm sandwich. They made the error. You inherited the labor. This isn't just bad luck; it's a structural shift in how risk and work are distributed in the global economy.
The Invisible Labor of the Modern Consumer
Economists sometimes call this "shadow work." It's a term popularized by Craig Lambert, and it perfectly describes the tasks we now do for free that used to be handled by paid employees. But there’s a darker version of shadow work that goes beyond scanning your own groceries. It happens when a system fails.
When a bank’s "security update" locks you out of your funds, the onus is on you to prove your identity through a gauntlet of biometric checks and phone trees. They broke the access; you perform the repair.
✨ Don't miss: 100 trillion zimbabwe dollars to us: Why a worthless bill is now worth hundreds
This "our mistake is your responsibility" loop is incredibly profitable for firms. By offloading the "recovery" phase of a service failure onto the customer, companies save billions in labor costs. If a software company pushes a buggy update that breaks your workflow, they might issue a dry apology on social media, but you’re the one staying up until 2 AM troubleshooting the patch. Your time has zero value on their balance sheet.
The Psychology of Compliance
Why do we take it? Mostly because we don't have a choice. In a consolidated market, where three or four players control an entire industry—think ISPs or major airlines—there is no "competitor" who treats you better. They all use the same lean-staffing models.
Psychologically, companies rely on "sunk cost" and "learned helplessness." You've already paid for the service. You need the service to function. Therefore, you will do the work to fix their error because the alternative is losing your money or your access entirely. It is a hostage situation disguised as "customer empowerment."
Real-World Examples of the Responsibility Shift
Let's look at the financial sector. In 2023, several major banks faced scrutiny for how they handled "authorized" fraud. If a scammer tricks you into sending money via a peer-to-peer app, the bank's stance is frequently that since you pushed the button, it’s your problem—even if their security filters failed to flag a known fraudulent account.
The system's vulnerability is their mistake. The financial loss is your responsibility.
- The Tech "Beta" Culture: Software is now released in a state of "perpetual beta." Companies ship products they know are unfinished, relying on user bug reports to find the holes. You are paying to be their Quality Assurance department.
- Healthcare Billing: A hospital enters the wrong insurance code. The claim is denied. Instead of the hospital correcting their clerical error, you spend weeks acting as a middleman between the provider and the insurer.
- E-commerce Returns: A retailer sends the wrong size. You have to repackage it, find a printer for the label, and drive to a drop-off point. They failed the fulfillment, yet you provide the logistics labor.
The Legal Shield: Forced Arbitration and TOS
You probably didn't read the Terms of Service (TOS) the last time you updated your phone. Nobody does. But inside those 40,000 words is usually a clause that ensures "our mistake is your responsibility" is legally binding.
Most modern contracts include a "limitation of liability" clause. This basically says that even if the company's gross negligence causes you a loss, their responsibility is limited to the amount you paid for the service—or sometimes, nothing at all.
Then there's forced arbitration. This prevents you from joining a class-action lawsuit when a company makes a massive, systemic mistake. If a data breach leaks your social security number because a tech firm left a server unencrypted (their mistake), you can’t sue them in open court. You have to go through a private arbitrator, a process that is statistically skewed in favor of the corporation. They've effectively outsourced the legal consequences of their failures back onto the victim.
The "Self-Service" Trap
The rise of AI chatbots has made this worse. Have you noticed it’s nearly impossible to find a "Contact Us" phone number anymore?
Companies have replaced human empathy with "self-service portals." This is the ultimate expression of the trend. When a problem arises, the company gives you a library of articles to read. "Here," they say, "go fix our mistake yourself." If the chatbot can't help you, the friction is often so high that most people simply give up. That "give up" rate is a metric companies track; it's called "deflection," and it's seen as a win for the bottom line.
Reclaiming the Narrative: What You Can Actually Do
You can't single-handedly rewrite the global corporate playbook. But you can stop being a passive participant in the "our mistake is your responsibility" cycle. It requires a shift from being a "polite customer" to an "assertive advocate."
First, document everything. When a company fails, the first thing they will try to do is gaslight you into thinking it was your fault or a "unique glitch."
- Keep a Paper Trail: Screenshot the error messages. Save the chat logs. If you’re on a call, take down the agent's name and an interaction ID. In many states, you can record the call (check your local laws first).
- Value Your Time: When a company makes an error that requires your labor to fix, ask for a "billing credit for time spent." Use a specific hourly rate. They will probably say no the first time. Ask for a supervisor. Make it more expensive for them to argue with you than to settle the issue.
- Use Social Media Publicly: Private DMs are where complaints go to die. Public posts on platforms like X or LinkedIn, tagging the executive team, often trigger a faster response because it threatens their brand equity.
- Chargebacks are Your Friend: If you paid for a service that wasn't delivered or was botched, and the company is making it your job to fix it, call your credit card provider. A chargeback shifts the "labor" back to the company; they have to prove to the bank why they should keep the money.
The Power of Regulatory Pressure
We are starting to see some pushback at the government level. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) in the United States has been aggressive about "junk fees" and the labor customers have to perform to cancel subscriptions. The "Click to Cancel" rule is a perfect example of regulators realizing that "our mistake (or difficult system) is your responsibility" is an unfair trade practice.
In Europe, the GDPR and various consumer protection laws put a much higher burden of proof on the company. If they lose your data, it’s their responsibility to notify you and mitigate the damage, with massive fines if they don’t.
Moving Toward Real Accountability
True "Customer Success" isn't about having a nice-looking app. It's about a company owning the lifecycle of its errors. A truly customer-centric organization doesn't say "our mistake is your responsibility." It says, "We messed up, and we've already initiated the fix so you don't have to."
Imagine a world where an airline automatically refunds your ticket and books you on a competitor’s flight the moment a delay is detected. Or a bank that detects a fraudulent charge and handles the entire dispute process without you needing to sign a single affidavit.
The technology to do this exists. The data is there. What’s missing is the incentive.
As long as we continue to accept the burden of corporate incompetence, companies will continue to outsource their failures to us. It's cheaper for them. It's easier for them. But it's not sustainable for a society that is already stretched thin by the "labor" of just existing in a digital world.
Actionable Steps to Take Today
- Audit your subscriptions. Look for companies that make it intentionally hard to leave or fix issues. Switch to competitors who prioritize human-to-human support.
- Don't "self-serve" for complex errors. If a company makes a major financial or service error, bypass the chatbot immediately. Type "speak to an agent" or "legal" to get past the deflection filters.
- Report systemic issues. Use the CFPB website or your local Better Business Bureau. These reports create a trail that regulators use to build cases for larger fines and policy changes.
- Stop apologizing. When you call a support line to fix their mistake, don't start with "I'm sorry to bother you." You aren't bothering them; you are performing unpaid consulting work for their broken system.
The shift happens when the "cost" of shifting responsibility back to the customer becomes higher than the cost of just fixing the mistake in the first place. Be the person who makes it expensive for them to be incompetent. Over time, that’s the only language that moves the needle in the boardroom.