The wings are ordered. The beer is chilling. For most of America, the second Sunday in February is a secular holiday dedicated to over-the-top commercials and the elite athleticism of the NFL. But for a growing, vocal segment of the population, the TV stays off. Choosing to boycott the Super Bowl isn't just about missing a game; it’s a specific, often painful decision to step away from a cultural juggernaut. It’s a protest.
Honestly, it's hard to ignore the gravity of the NFL. It’s a multi-billion dollar machine. Yet, every year, the hashtags crawl back up the trending charts. People are walking away for reasons that range from systemic social justice issues to the brutal, physical reality of what the game does to the human brain. You've probably heard the arguments before, but the landscape of this protest has shifted significantly over the last few years.
The Colin Kaepernick Legacy and Social Justice
You can't talk about a boycott without talking about 2016. That was the year Colin Kaepernick first sat, then knelt, during the national anthem. He was protesting police brutality and racial inequality. The ripple effect was massive. While the NFL has since transitioned into "Inspire Change" end-zone stencils and social justice stickers on helmets, many activists feel these are empty gestures—"performative activism" at its finest.
The boycott the Super Bowl movement gained its most significant steam during this era. High-profile celebrities even turned down the halftime show. Remember 2019? Rihanna famously told Vogue she couldn't be a "sellout" by performing, standing in solidarity with Kaepernick. Cardi B did the same. For many fans, the league's treatment of Kaepernick—who hasn't played in the league since that season—remains an unforgivable sin. They see a league that effectively blackballed a player for exercising his right to protest while simultaneously profiting off a culture that he was trying to protect.
It’s complicated. Some fans feel that by tuning in, they are subsidizing a system that doesn't actually care about the black players who make up roughly 70% of the league. They see the "End Racism" messages in the end zone as a cynical marketing ploy designed to keep sponsors happy while the actual power structure—the owners—remains largely unchanged and politically homogeneous.
Brain Damage and the Ethics of the Hit
Then there’s the medical side of things. It’s grisly.
Chronic Traumatic Encephalopathy (CTE) has changed how many parents look at the game. When you watch a "big hit" now, you aren't just seeing a defensive stop; you're potentially seeing a life-altering brain injury in real-time. Dr. Bennet Omalu, the forensic pathologist who first discovered CTE in football players, has been blunt: he believes the game is fundamentally unsafe.
Some people boycott the Super Bowl because they simply can't enjoy the spectacle anymore. It feels like a modern-day gladiator pit. Knowing that players like Junior Seau or Dave Duerson took their own lives after struggling with the neurodegenerative effects of the game makes the "Big Game" feel a bit more like a tragedy than a triumph.
- The 2023 season saw high-profile scares, like Tua Tagovailoa’s repeated concussions, which reignited this debate.
- The league has implemented "Guardian Caps" in practice, but the physics of a 250-pound man hitting another at full speed haven't changed.
- For the "ethical fan," the math just doesn't add up anymore.
The Economic Impact: Does a Boycott Actually Work?
Let’s be real for a second. Does skipping the game actually hurt the NFL's wallet?
💡 You might also like: Joe Burrow Injury History: What Really Happened to Cincinnati’s Franchise Savior
Probably not in the way you think.
The NFL’s revenue is largely driven by massive broadcast deals that are locked in for years. These deals—with networks like CBS, NBC, FOX, and ESPN/ABC—are worth over $110 billion. Whether you turn your TV on this Sunday or not, that money is already in the bank. However, the advertisers are the ones watching the ratings.
A 30-second spot during the Super Bowl costs around $7 million now. If viewership dips significantly, the leverage the NFL has in the next round of negotiations weakens. But more importantly, a boycott is a tool for cultural signaling. It’s about withdrawing "social license." When a brand or a league loses its status as a "universal good," it becomes vulnerable.
Take the 2019 Super Bowl in Atlanta. Ratings were the lowest they had been in a decade. While many attributed that to a boring game (the Patriots beat the Rams 13-3), a significant portion of the decline was linked to the #BoycottBowl movement in support of Kaepernick. It showed that the audience isn't a guarantee. It's a privilege the league has to earn.
Public Subsidies and the Business of Football
There is also a growing movement of people who are fed up with the "stadium scam." Most NFL stadiums are built using hundreds of millions of dollars in taxpayer money. For many, the boycott the Super Bowl sentiment is rooted in local economics.
Why should a city give $800 million to a billionaire owner for a stadium that is used eight or nine times a year, while schools and infrastructure crumble? This isn't just a sports issue; it's a municipal policy issue. Fans in cities like St. Louis, who lost their team after the city spent years paying off stadium debt, have very little interest in celebrating the league's biggest night. It’s a matter of principle. They refuse to participate in the glorification of an entity that they view as a "corporate welfare queen."
How People Actually Spend the Day Instead
If you aren't watching the game, what are you doing?
It’s not just sitting in a dark room being angry. The "Puppy Bowl" on Animal Planet has become a genuine cultural alternative, often pulling in millions of viewers who want something wholesome instead of high-impact. Others use the time for "Super Bowl Sunday" hikes or grocery shopping—honestly, it’s the best time to go to Costco because the aisles are empty.
Some activist groups host "Counter-Programming" events. They might hold community service days or watch documentaries about the issues the NFL is currently facing. The goal is to reclaim the time. If the Super Bowl is a time for national unity, these groups want that unity to be focused on something other than a leather ball and commercialism.
The Future of the NFL's Dominance
The NFL is currently king, but no empire lasts forever.
Gen Z and Gen Alpha are less tied to traditional sports broadcasts than their parents were. They consume highlights on TikTok and YouTube. They care deeply about the values of the organizations they support. If the NFL continues to find itself at odds with the social values of younger generations—or if the health risks become too much for parents to ignore—the boycott the Super Bowl movement might not be a fringe protest anymore. It could become the new normal.
The league knows this. That’s why you see the heavy investment in international games in London, Germany, and Brazil. They are looking for new audiences because they know the domestic market might have a ceiling, especially if the "ethical boycott" continues to gain traction.
👉 See also: What Time Do the Phillies Play Tomorrow? Why the 2026 Schedule is Different
Actionable Steps for the Conscious Consumer
If you’re on the fence about whether to tune in or join the boycott, here is how you can approach it thoughtfully.
- Define Your "Why": Are you protesting the league's handling of social issues, or are you concerned about player health? Knowing your specific reason helps you communicate it to friends and family who might give you a hard time about skipping the party.
- Support the Players, Not the Shield: You can still follow your favorite athletes on social media or support their charitable foundations without giving the NFL your TV ratings. Many players do incredible work through the "Walter Payton Man of the Year" program; you can donate directly to those causes.
- Host an Alternative Event: If you usually host a party, don't just cancel it. Turn it into a board game night, a movie marathon, or a "volunteer-from-home" session where you pack kits for a local shelter.
- Engage with Local Sports: If you love the game of football but hate the NFL's corporate structure, look into local high school or non-professional leagues. Often, the "purest" form of the game is found where the stakes aren't billions of dollars.
- Voice Your Concerns to Sponsors: If there’s a specific reason you're boycotting, let the Super Bowl’s biggest sponsors know via social media. Companies like Anheuser-Busch or Pepsi pay for eyeballs; if those eyeballs are looking away, they need to know why.
Deciding to boycott the Super Bowl is a personal choice that reflects how you want to spend your "attention currency." In a world where every click and view is tracked, choosing to look away is one of the few forms of power the average person still has.