Money moves in shadows. Honestly, if you’re looking at spy returns by year, you aren’t just looking at a ticker symbol; you're looking at the heartbeat of the American economy. The SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust, famously known by its ticker SPY, is basically the "gold standard" for how we measure success or failure in the stock market. People obsess over these numbers. They should.
But here is the thing.
Most people get the math wrong because they forget about dividends or they ignore the "lost decades" where the returns felt like a flatline. You've probably heard that the market "always goes up." Well, tell that to someone who retired in 2000 and watched the next ten years eat their lunch.
The Reality of SPY Returns by Year Since Inception
SPY launched in January 1993. It was a game-changer. Before that, trading the whole index was a massive pain for the average person. Since then, we've seen everything from the Dot-com bubble to the Great Financial Crisis and the post-pandemic surge.
Let's talk about 2008. It was brutal. The return was roughly -37%. If you had $100,000 in, you suddenly had $63,000. That’s a lot of missed vacations. But then look at 2009—a 26% bounce back. This is why looking at spy returns by year in isolation is kinda dangerous. You need the context of the "bounce."
The Volatility Rollercoaster
In 1995, SPY returned over 37%. Imagine that. Just buying the index and waking up nearly 40% richer. Then compare that to 2022, where the return was somewhere around -18% to -19% depending on how you account for the exact close. It’s a wild ride.
The 1990s were basically a fever dream for investors.
1996: ~22%
1997: ~33%
1998: ~28%
You couldn't lose. Until you did.
The period from 2000 to 2002 was three straight years of red.
📖 Related: Hedge Fund Explained (Simply): Why They Aren't Just for Supervillains
- 2000: -9%
- 2001: -11%
- 2002: -21%
When you see those numbers stacked, you realize why people panic. It wasn't one bad year; it was a slow bleed that lasted a thousand days.
Understanding Total Return vs. Price Return
This is where the pros separate from the amateurs. If you just look at the price of SPY on a chart, you are missing the dividends. SPY pays out dividends quarterly. If you reinvest those, your spy returns by year look significantly better over time.
For example, in a year where the price return is 8%, the "total return" might be closer to 10% because of those payouts. Over thirty years, that 2% gap creates a massive difference in wealth. It’s the difference between retiring comfortably and working at a hardware store until you’re 80. Seriously.
Why 2023 and 2024 Changed the Conversation
Coming off the disaster of 2022, everyone was predicting a recession. The "experts" on TV were certain. Instead, 2023 delivered a total return of about 26%. It caught everyone off guard. Why? Big Tech. The "Magnificent Seven" companies—think Nvidia, Apple, Microsoft—basically carried the entire index on their backs.
If you weren't holding SPY, you likely missed that run. That’s the beauty of the ETF; it forces you to own the winners even when you’re too scared to buy them individually.
The Anomaly Years
Sometimes the market just acts weird.
Take 2017. The return was about 21%, but the "maximum drawdown" (the biggest drop from peak to trough during the year) was tiny. It was a smooth ride up. Then look at 2020. We had a massive crash in March because of the pandemic, yet the year finished up over 18%.
👉 See also: Calculate My Tax Return: Why the Online Estimators Always Feel a Little Off
If you had blinked in March 2020, you would have missed the fastest bear market and the fastest recovery in history. This highlights the biggest flaw in obsessing over annual returns: they hide the drama that happens in between January and December.
Does the "Average" Actually Exist?
People say the S&P 500 returns 10% a year on average.
That's a lie.
Well, it's a statistical truth but a practical lie.
In reality, the market almost never returns exactly 10% in a single year. It’s usually +25% or -10% or +15%. The "average" is just a midpoint of extreme volatility.
How to Actually Use This Data
If you’re tracking spy returns by year to time the market, stop.
History shows that the "best" years often follow the "worst" years. If you exited in December 2008 because you were scared, you missed the 2009 recovery. If you sold in 2022, you missed the AI-driven boom of 2023.
- Check the expense ratio. SPY is cheap (0.0945%), but there are even cheaper ones like VOO or IVV.
- Focus on rolling returns. Look at 5-year or 10-year blocks instead of just 12-month slices.
- Don't ignore inflation. A 10% return in a year with 8% inflation (like we saw recently) means you only gained 2% in actual purchasing power.
The data is clear: SPY is a bet on American capitalism. Over long stretches, that bet has paid off, but the year-to-year swings are enough to give anyone heartburn.
💡 You might also like: Finding an Example of a Great Cover Letter That Doesn't Sound Like a Robot Wrote It
Actionable Next Steps:
- Audit your "DRIP": Check your brokerage account to ensure "Dividend Reinvestment" is turned on for your SPY holdings. Without this, you're losing a massive chunk of the historical total return.
- Calculate your personal "Real Return": Take the SPY annual return and subtract the CPI (inflation) for that same year. This gives you the actual growth of your wealth, not just the "nominal" number.
- Diversify your entry points: Since annual returns are so volatile, use Dollar Cost Averaging (DCA) to buy every month. This ensures you aren't accidentally putting all your money in during a "1999" or "2007" peak year.
- Review your risk tolerance: If seeing a -20% year in your spy returns by year spreadsheet makes you want to vomit, you need to rebalance into bonds or cash before the next inevitable downturn.
Investing isn't about being right every year. It's about staying in the game long enough for the math to work in your favor.