Man, baseball rumors are a wild ride. Remember back in late 2024 and early 2025? People were practically ordering custom Boston jerseys with "Guerrero Jr." on the back. There were reports flying everywhere that if the Toronto Blue Jays didn't extend their cornerstone first baseman by Spring Training, he was basically a lock to head to Fenway Park in 2026.
It made sense on paper, kinda. The Red Sox had the cash. Vladdy has friends in Boston. The Dominican connection with Rafael Devers was a dream scenario for Sox fans. But if you’re still holding onto the idea that the Blue Jays could trade Vladimir Guerrero Jr to Red Sox, I’ve got some news that might sting: that ship hasn't just sailed; it’s been dismantled and turned into a luxury yacht in Toronto.
The Half-Billion Dollar Reality Check
Here is the thing. The "trade Vladdy" talk died a very expensive death in April 2025.
While the internet was busy photoshopping him into Red Sox socks, the Blue Jays front office was quietly writing a check with a lot of zeros. Like, fourteen-year-long zeros. They ended up locking him down with a 14-year, $500 million contract extension.
📖 Related: Chiefs and Saints Game: Why It’s Still the Hardest Matchup to Predict
Honestly, it’s one of the biggest deals in the history of the sport. It officially kicks in for the 2026 season and runs all the way through 2039. So, unless the Red Sox want to trade for a guy who’s technically under contract until he’s basically 40 years old—and somehow convince Toronto to give up their franchise face—it's just not happening.
What about that "Red Sox interest" though?
Look, Bob Nightengale and a few other insiders weren't necessarily lying when they said the Red Sox were looming. Boston was absolutely waiting in the weeds. If Vladdy had hit free agency after the 2025 season, the Red Sox would’ve been the primary aggressors.
But the Blue Jays learned their lesson from the whole Shohei Ohtani "plane to Toronto" debacle. They weren't going to let their own superstar walk away. By giving him that massive signing bonus—roughly $325 million of that $500 million was a bonus—they made him a Blue Jay for life.
Plus, there's a full no-trade clause.
You read that right. Even if the Blue Jays wanted to move him to a division rival like Boston, Vladdy has the final say. And after coming just one win away from a World Series ring in 2025, why would he leave?
Why Toronto Doubled Down Instead of Trading
The 2025 season changed everything for this team. They didn't just play well; they went on a tear. Toronto made it all the way to Game 7 of the World Series against the Dodgers. It was a heartbreaker—losing 5-4 in the 11th inning at the Rogers Centre—but it proved that this core could win.
If the Blue Jays could trade Vladimir Guerrero Jr to Red Sox, they would have done it when his value was high and the team was struggling. Instead, Vladdy turned into a postseason monster. He hit eight home runs in that 2025 playoff run. Eight! That’s a franchise record. He was the ALCS MVP.
Basically, he became "untouchable" in the literal sense of the word.
- Contract Status: Signed through 2039.
- No-Trade Clause: Full protection.
- 2025 Stats: .292 AVG, 23 HR, 84 RBI (and a massive .397 AVG in the playoffs).
- Team Outlook: Still in "win-now" mode despite losing Bo Bichette to the Mets.
The Bo Bichette Factor
Speaking of Bo, that’s the real story right now. While everyone was worried about Vladdy going to Boston, Bo Bichette actually did leave. He signed a three-year, $126 million deal with the New York Mets recently.
✨ Don't miss: Finding Your Broad St Run Results: What the Numbers Actually Mean for Your Training
Losing Bo was a gut punch for Vladdy. They came up through the minors together. They were supposed to be the "twins" of the franchise. Guerrero even told Sportsnet’s Hazel Mae that he was "sad" to see his friend go.
But here is the logic: if the Blue Jays just lost their star shortstop, there is zero percent chance they trade their superstar first baseman. If anything, the Bichette departure makes Vladdy even more vital to Toronto. He’s the last man standing from that original "sons of legends" hype train.
What Most People Get Wrong About MLB Trades
People often think trades happen just because a player "fits" another team. Sure, Vladdy hitting bombs over the Green Monster at Fenway sounds cool. But the Blue Jays and Red Sox are in the same division.
Trading a generational talent to the team you have to play 13 times a year? That’s how GMs get fired.
Toronto isn't in a rebuild. Even with some roster turnover in 2026—bringing in guys like Kazuma Okamoto to help cover the corners—the goal is another World Series run. You don't get closer to a trophy by giving your best hitter to the Red Sox.
The Financials are Just Too Heavy
Let’s talk money for a second because $500 million is a lot of baggage. For the Blue Jays could trade Vladimir Guerrero Jr to Red Sox scenario to work, Boston would have to:
👉 See also: Casey Martin: Why the Most Famous Cart in Golf Still Matters
- Absorb a $35.7 million average annual value (AAV).
- Give up a haul of prospects that would likely gut their farm system.
- Convince Toronto fans not to burn down the stadium.
Boston is smart. They’re looking for value. They’d rather wait for the next crop of free agents or develop their own talent than pay the "intra-division tax" that Toronto would demand in a trade for a guy they just gave a half-billion dollars to.
What's Next for Vladdy and the Jays?
So, if he's not going to Boston, what is he doing?
Vladdy is currently gearing up for the 2026 World Baseball Classic. He’s playing for the Dominican Republic under Albert Pujols. It’s a huge deal for him, especially since he had to miss the last one with a knee injury.
Back in Toronto, the team is trying to surround him with enough talent to finish what they started in '25. They’ve added Dylan Cease to the rotation and are looking at some heavy-hitting outfielders to replace the production lost from Bichette.
If you’re a Red Sox fan, you’re better off looking at the 2026 free-agent market. Kyle Tucker is out there. There are other bats. But Vladdy? He’s a Blue Jay for the foreseeable future.
The rumors were fun while they lasted, but reality—and a $500 million contract—has a way of ending the speculation.
Actionable Takeaways for Fans
- Ignore the Old Rumors: Any article you see about Vladdy to the Red Sox that doesn't mention his 14-year extension is out of date.
- Watch the WBC: If you want to see Vladdy play in a "new" environment, the World Baseball Classic this spring is your best bet.
- Check the No-Trade Clause: In modern MLB, a "full no-trade" is the ultimate career anchor. Vladdy holds all the cards.
- Focus on 1B Depth: Toronto is actually looking for a backup first baseman for 2026, not a replacement.
The dream of Guerrero Jr. in a Red Sox uniform is officially over. He’s the king of Toronto now, and he’s got the contract to prove it.