Everyone thought they knew what a US Open was supposed to look like. You know the drill: narrow fairways, rough so thick it swallows your ankles, and winning scores that hover somewhere around par if the USGA is feeling particularly cruel. Then came the 2017 US Open at Erin Hills. It basically flipped the script. Instead of a claustrophobic test of survival, we got a sprawling, fescue-covered monster in the middle of Wisconsin that let the big hitters absolutely unload.
Brooks Koepka won that year. It wasn't just a win; it was a demolition job. He finished at 16-under par, tying the record Rory McIlroy set at Congressional. People lost their minds. Traditionalists argued the course was too easy, while others pointed out that if you missed the fairway by a yard, you were basically playing out of a hayfield. Honestly, it was one of the most polarizing majors in recent memory.
The Erin Hills Gamble: A Different Kind of Brutality
The USGA took a massive risk going to Erin Hills. It was the first time the 2017 US Open—or any US Open for that matter—was held in Wisconsin. The course is massive. It covers over 650 acres of rolling Kettle Moraine topography. Unlike the tight, tree-lined corridors of Oakmont or Winged Foot, Erin Hills looked like a slice of Ireland dropped into the American Midwest.
The fairways were wide. Like, "you could land a jumbo jet on them" wide. But that was by design. The defense wasn't supposed to be the width; it was supposed to be the wind and that nasty, waist-high fescue. If the wind didn't blow, these guys were going to tear it apart. And guess what? The wind stayed home for most of the week.
📖 Related: Why the Weather for Jets Game Might Actually Save the Season
Rain softened the greens early on, and suddenly, the best players in the world were throwing darts. Justin Thomas shot a 9-under 63 in the third round. A 63! In a US Open! That's the kind of thing that makes the blue-blazer crowd at the USGA break out in a cold sweat. It was the first time in history a player finished 9-under in a single round of this tournament.
How Brooks Koepka Found His Blueprint
Before June 2017, Brooks Koepka was "that guy who played in Europe." He was talented, sure, but he wasn't the "Big Game Hunter" yet. The 2017 US Open changed his entire career trajectory. He realized that his physical advantages—ball speed, strength, and a weirdly calm temperament—were perfectly suited for modern major setups.
Koepka didn't just overpower the course; he out-smarted it. While others were complaining about the fescue (the USGA actually mowed some of it down before the tournament started because players were whining), Brooks just kept hitting fairways. He hit 88% of them. When you combine that kind of accuracy with 320-yard drives, the field doesn't have a chance.
He closed with a 67 on Sunday. It was clinical. He made three straight birdies on the back nine to pull away from Brian Harman and Hideki Matsuyama. It felt less like a struggle and more like a coronation.
The Stars Who Stumbled
It wasn't all sunshine and birdies for everyone. Some of the biggest names in the sport looked totally lost.
- Dustin Johnson: The defending champ. He missed the cut.
- Rory McIlroy: Another missed cut. He famously said, "If you can't hit these fairways, you might as well pack your bags."
- Jason Day: Shot 79 in the opening round.
It was a weird week for the elite. Usually, the "big three" or whatever we were calling them back then dominate the conversation. Instead, we had a leaderboard filled with names like Tommy Fleetwood, Rickie Fowler, and Xander Schauffele (who was a total underdog at the time).
The Fescue Controversy and the "Trim Job"
You can't talk about the 2017 US Open without mentioning the weeds. The fescue was the main talking point on Tuesday and Wednesday. Kevin Na posted a video showing how impossible it was to find a ball, let alone hit it. The internet exploded.
Under pressure, the USGA decided to mow down the fescue on four holes—4, 12, 14, and 18. This moved sparked a massive debate. Is it a US Open if the officials make it easier mid-week? Some players, like Lee Westwood, thought it was a joke. Others were relieved. Ultimately, it didn't matter as much as people thought because the real danger was the greens, which were rolling like glass.
Why 2017 Still Matters Today
The legacy of the 2017 US Open is actually pretty significant for how golf is moving. It was the moment we realized that "Distance is King" wasn't just a trend; it was the new reality. Erin Hills proved that even at 7,741 yards—the longest course in major history at the time—the modern pro can still go low if the conditions are soft.
It also changed how the USGA thinks about course setup. Since 2017, they've been much more careful about "protecting par." They saw what happened when a course was "defenseless" against the bomb-and-gouge style. We’ve seen a return to more traditional, punishing setups in the years following, almost as a reaction to the 16-under winning score in Wisconsin.
Key Takeaways for Your Next Round
You probably aren't hitting it 330 yards like Brooks, but there are things we can learn from how that week unfolded:
- Fairway over everything: Koepka won because he didn't miss. Even on wide fairways, his discipline to hit the "fat" part of the landing area gave him the best angles.
- Ignore the noise: The players who complained about the fescue mostly played poorly. The players who just dealt with it—like Koepka and Harman—thrived. Mental toughness is a real stat.
- Capitalize on soft conditions: If it rains before your Saturday morning tee time, be aggressive. Soft greens are a green light to hunt pins.
If you ever find yourself in Hartford, Wisconsin, go play Erin Hills. It’s a public course. It’s expensive, and it will probably beat you up, but you'll get a sense of just how insane it was for Koepka to shoot 16-under there. Take a caddie, stay out of the fescue, and don't expect to shoot anywhere near a 63.
For those looking to dive deeper into the stats of that week, check out the official USGA archive for a hole-by-hole breakdown of how the scoring records were shattered. Understanding the "Strokes Gained" data from that specific week is a masterclass in modern power golf.
Next Steps for Golf History Buffs
- Study the swing: Look up Brooks Koepka’s 2017 highlights on YouTube. Pay attention to his stable lower body; it’s the secret to his accuracy at high speeds.
- Check the gear: Research the "Titleist 917D2" driver and "Mizuno JPX 900 Tour" irons Koepka used. It was one of the few times a major was won by a "free agent" without a full bag equipment contract.
- Analyze the layout: Use Google Earth to look at the routing of Erin Hills. Seeing the scale of the bunkers and the distance between holes explains why it was such a brutal walk for the players and caddies.