If you’ve spent any time on BookTok lately, you’ve probably seen those moody, purple-and-black covers. You know the ones. Holly Renee’s A Kingdom of Stars and Shadows series has become one of those "if you know, you know" pillars of the indie fantasy romance world. It’s gritty. It’s spicy. Honestly, it’s a lot more emotional than some of the more mainstream "fast-food" fantasy books hitting the shelves these days.
People are obsessed.
But why? Is it just the tropes, or is there something actually deeper going on with Adara and Evren? When you dig into the mechanics of this world—a place where the stars literally dictate your fate and shadows aren’t just a lack of light—you start to see why readers are ditching traditional high fantasy for this specific brand of "Romantasy."
What Most People Get Wrong About the A Kingdom of Stars and Shadows Series
A lot of critics look at the A Kingdom of Stars and Shadows series and dismiss it as just another "fated mates" story. That’s a mistake. While Holly Renee definitely leans into the soul-bond stuff, she treats the concept like a curse as much as a gift.
In this world, being "Star Blessed" isn’t some sparkly Disney tier of existence. It’s heavy.
Adara, our protagonist, starts out trapped in a life she didn't choose, caught between a kingdom that treats her like a political pawn and a mysterious shadow-wielding fae who looks at her like she’s the only thing that matters in a dying world. The tension isn't just "will they or won't they." It's "if they do, will the world literally end?"
That stakes-heavy writing is what separates Renee from authors who just throw a dragon and a leather-clad dude into a room and call it a day.
The Evren Factor: Why This Hero Hits Different
Let's talk about Evren. Every series like this needs a "shadow daddy," right? It's a tired term, sure, but Evren fits the archetype while also subverting it. He isn't just brooding for the sake of looking cool in a fan-cast edit on Instagram. He’s a Prince of Shadows who has been sidelined and vilified.
What’s interesting is how Renee handles the power dynamic. In many fantasy romances, the male lead is an all-powerful god-tier warrior who rescues the "feisty" but ultimately helpless girl.
Evren is powerful, yeah. But Adara’s growth across the books—moving from A Kingdom of Stars and Shadows into A Kingdom of Blood and Betrayal—shows a woman learning to wield her own light. It’s a partnership of equals, or at least, a partnership of two people who are equally broken.
The World-Building Isn't Just Window Dressing
The setting of this series feels tactile. You can almost smell the cold mountain air and the iron of the blades. The Starblessed are people born with specific celestial marks, and the way this magic system interacts with the "Shadow" realm is actually quite clever.
👉 See also: 2022 Billboard Top 100: Why the Charts Felt So Weird That Year
It’s not some 50-page lore dump at the beginning of chapter one.
Instead, we learn about the history of the divided kingdoms through the scars and the politics. The Star Kingdom is a place of rigid rules and fake smiles. Contrast that with the Shadow Kingdom, which, despite the scary name, feels a lot more honest. It’s a classic trope—the "civilized" world being the true villain—but Holly Renee executes it with enough grit to make it feel fresh.
Breaking Down the Reading Order
If you're looking to jump in, you can't just pick a random book. The narrative is a tight, chronological arc. Most readers start with the core trilogy, but the world has expanded.
- A Kingdom of Stars and Shadows: This is the hook. It sets up the marriage of convenience, the betrayal, and that first electric meeting with Evren.
- A Kingdom of Blood and Betrayal: This is where things get messy. The political stakes ramp up, and the spice level definitely increases.
- A Kingdom of Venoms and Vows: The conclusion of the primary arc. It's high-octane and surprisingly emotional.
There are also spin-offs and novellas that flesh out the secondary characters. Honestly, the side characters often steal the show. Fans have been vocal about wanting more of the supporting cast's stories because the world Renee built is too big to just stay focused on one couple forever.
Why the "Indie" Label Matters Here
Holly Renee is a powerhouse in the self-publishing and "hybrid" publishing space. This matters because the A Kingdom of Stars and Shadows series doesn't feel like it’s been put through a corporate blender.
Traditional publishers often try to sand down the edges of "dark" romance to make it more palatable for big-box bookstores. Renee keeps the edges sharp. The dialogue is snappy—sometimes even a bit modern for a fantasy setting—but it works because it feels authentic to the characters' emotions.
✨ Don't miss: The Tick Animated Series: Why This 90s Satire Still Beats Modern Superhero Shows
When Adara is angry, she doesn't use flowery, 18th-century prose. She sounds like someone who is genuinely ticked off.
Navigating the "Spice" and the Story
Let’s be real for a second: people read these books for the romance.
The "spice" level is high. But if you strip away the intimate scenes, you still have a functioning plot about a girl trying to reclaim her agency in a world that wants to use her as a battery for celestial magic. That’s the secret sauce of the A Kingdom of Stars and Shadows series. It treats the physical attraction between the leads as a natural extension of their emotional bond, not just a way to fill pages between fight scenes.
Common Misconceptions About Adara's Journey
Some readers find Adara frustrating in the first half of the first book. "Why doesn't she just leave?" or "Why is she so naive?"
Think about it though. If you were raised in a gilded cage where every person you ever loved told you that you were a literal holy object, you wouldn't be a girlboss on day one. Her character arc is a slow burn. She has to unlearn an entire lifetime of indoctrination. Watching her realize that the "Stars" she was taught to worship are actually kind of oppressive is one of the best parts of the series.
It’s a story about deconstruction.
Actionable Insights for New Readers
If you're ready to dive into the A Kingdom of Stars and Shadows series, here’s how to get the most out of it without hitting "reader burnout."
👉 See also: Why Amy Brown is the Soul of The Bobby Bones Show
- Check the Content Warnings: Renee doesn't hold back. There’s violence, betrayal, and some heavy themes. If you're looking for "cozy fantasy," this isn't it.
- Don't Rush the First 50 Pages: The world-building takes a second to click. Once the first major "inciting incident" happens (you'll know it when Adara leaves the safety of her home), the pace becomes relentless.
- Pay Attention to the Side Characters: Many of the threads woven into the background of the first book become massive plot points in the sequels.
- Join the Community: Part of the fun of this series is the fandom. Whether it's the official Facebook groups or the TikTok hashtags, there is a massive community of people theorizing about the magic system.
The A Kingdom of Stars and Shadows series represents a shift in how we consume fantasy. It’s fast-paced, emotionally raw, and unapologetically romantic. It doesn't apologize for being "tropey" because it uses those tropes as tools to tell a story about finding freedom in the shadows.
If you want to start, grab the first book and clear your weekend. You're going to need it.
The next logical step for any fan is to track the release of Renee's newest works in the same universe, as she frequently updates her reading order and expands the lore through "interconnected standalones" that provide deeper context into the warring factions of her world. Keep an eye on her social channels for maps and character art that help visualize the complex geography of the kingdoms.