Honestly, it feels like forever since 2010, yet we still can't stop talking about the massive ensemble Garry Marshall put together. It was a gamble. A big one. The idea was simple: cram every A-lister in Hollywood into one movie, weave their lives together over twenty-four hours in Los Angeles, and hope the sheer star power would distract people from the fact that L.A. traffic is never that light. It worked. The actors in Valentine's Day didn't just make a movie; they created a blueprint for the "holiday ensemble" sub-genre that we’ve seen copied—mostly unsuccessfully—ever since.
You've got Julia Roberts, Anne Hathaway, Bradley Cooper, and even Taylor Swift in her acting debut. It’s a time capsule. If you look back at the casting calls and the way the schedules were managed, it’s a logistical miracle. Most of these stars only worked for a few days. Some never even met their "co-stars" in other storylines.
The Weird Logic Behind the Casting
Casting a movie like this isn't about finding the best actor for a role. It’s about finding the biggest name available for a three-day window in October. Garry Marshall, the legendary director behind Pretty Woman, had a specific kind of pull. He didn't just ask; he charmed.
Take Julia Roberts. She played Captain Kate Hazeltine. Did you know she was paid roughly $3 million for only six minutes of screen time? That breaks down to about $8,333 per word. It sounds insane, but from a marketing perspective, having her face on the poster was worth every cent. She was the anchor. Her storyline—the soldier traveling home to see her "son"—is the emotional gut-punch that keeps the movie from being too sugary. Except, of course, the twist is that she’s actually going home to see her daughter (played by a very young Emma Roberts, her real-life niece).
Then there’s the Taylor Swift factor. Back in 2009, when this was filming, she was just starting her transition from country darling to global titan. She played Felicia, a high schooler obsessed with her boyfriend, played by Taylor Lautner. The "Taylor Squared" romance was a PR dream. People weren't just watching the movie; they were watching the tabloids.
Bradley Cooper and the Twist Everyone Missed
One of the most nuanced performances came from Bradley Cooper and Julia Roberts on that airplane. For most of the film, you assume they are a potential romantic match. They have chemistry. They talk about life.
But the movie pulls a fast one.
The actors in Valentine's Day often had to play against type. Cooper’s character, Holden, eventually reveals he’s heading home to his partner, Sean Jackson (played by Eric Dane). In 2010, mainstream rom-coms weren't always that inclusive in their primary marketing, so burying that "twist" until the end was a calculated move by New Line Cinema. It added a layer of actual human stakes to a movie that often felt like a series of Greeting Cards come to life.
The Anne Hathaway "Adult" Storyline
Anne Hathaway played Liz, a mailroom assistant who moonlights as a phone-sex operator to pay off her student loans. It’s a weird subplot. Topher Grace plays her love interest, and the comedy mostly comes from her trying to juggle a "naughty" phone call while being on a date. It’s probably the most dated part of the film, but Hathaway’s earnestness saves it. She’s too good for the material, frankly. But that’s the charm of the ensemble—you get Oscar-level talent doing "silly" things because they wanted to work with Marshall.
Why the Movie Still Ranks on Streaming
Every February, the search volume for the actors in Valentine's Day spikes. Why? Because we don't make these anymore. The "ensemble rom-com" has largely moved to Netflix, but the budgets are smaller. You don't see Jennifer Garner, Ashton Kutcher, Jessica Alba, and Jamie Foxx in the same frame anymore. It’s too expensive.
Garner and Kutcher, in particular, carry the "best friend" trope to its logical conclusion. Their storyline is the heart of the film. Kutcher plays Reed, a florist—which is the most "movie" job ever—who proposes to the wrong girl (Jessica Alba) only to realize he’s in love with his best friend. It’s predictable. It’s cheesy. But because Garner is so likable, you find yourself rooting for it anyway.
The Logistics of a Mega-Ensemble
How do you actually film this? You don't. You piece it together like a quilt.
- Shooting Windows: Most actors were on set for 3 to 5 days.
- The Flower Shop: This served as the central hub where many characters crossed paths, allowing the production to film multiple cameos in a single location.
- The Script: Written by Katherine Fugate, it had to be modular. If one actor dropped out, that entire "branch" of the story could be replaced without collapsing the whole film.
Jamie Foxx played Kelvin Moore, a sports reporter who hates Valentine's Day. His chemistry with Jessica Biel is underrated. Biel plays a publicist who throws an "I Hate Valentine's Day" party, which is honestly the most relatable part of the whole movie. They represent the cynical side of the holiday, which balances out the "Taylor Squared" teenage fluff.
The Ghost of Garry Marshall
Critics hated this movie. They called it a "commercial for Hallmark." They weren't entirely wrong. But audiences loved it. It made over $216 million worldwide.
💡 You might also like: Why Adina Howard Freak Like Me Lyrics Still Matter
The actors in Valentine's Day were essentially used as human SEO. If you liked Grey's Anatomy, you watched for Patrick Dempsey and Eric Dane. If you liked The Office, you watched for Kathy Bates. If you liked Valentine's Day... well, you probably just liked seeing beautiful people be miserable for 90 minutes before getting a happy ending.
Marshall understood something about the American public: we like familiarity. We like seeing "McDreamy" (Dempsey) play a cheating heart surgeon because it feels like an inside joke. We like seeing Queen Latifah run a high-end talent agency because she commands the screen.
What We Can Learn from the Casting
If you're looking at this from a film history perspective, this movie marked the end of an era. Shortly after, the "star system" began to fade, replaced by franchises and IP. Nowadays, the character is the star (like Spider-Man or Batman). In 2010, the actor was still the draw.
The movie also featured Shirley MacLaine and Hector Elizondo. Their storyline involves a long-married couple dealing with a past infidelity. It’s heavy. It’s slow. It feels like it belongs in a different movie. Yet, it provides the "gravitas" that allows the younger stars to be as flighty as they want.
Common Misconceptions
- Was it filmed in one day? No, the story takes place in one day, but filming took months.
- Did Taylor Swift write the soundtrack? She contributed "Today Was a Fairytale," which became a massive hit, but the score was by John Debney.
- Is it a sequel to Love Actually? No relation, though it clearly stole the "interwoven stories" homework and changed a few answers.
Actionable Insights for Your Next Rewatch
If you’re planning to revisit this classic, or if you’re a film buff studying ensemble structures, keep these things in mind:
- Watch the Backgrounds: Many of the lead actors in Valentine's Day appear as extras in other scenes. It’s a fun "Where's Waldo" game.
- The Wardrobe Theory: Notice how almost every character wears at least one item of red or pink clothing. It’s subtle (and sometimes not-so-subtle) visual branding that keeps the theme cohesive.
- The "Bridge" Characters: Pay attention to the characters who connect the most stories. Ashton Kutcher’s florist and the news crew (Foxx and Hathaway’s boyfriend) are the glue. Without them, the movie is just a collection of short films.
- Check the Credits: The blooper reel during the credits is arguably more famous than the movie itself, particularly the "Julia Roberts" joke where she references Pretty Woman.
The legacy of these actors isn't just in this one film. It’s in how they proved that you could sell a movie based on a guest list alone. It’s a strategy that led to New Year's Eve and Mother's Day, though neither quite captured the lightning-in-a-bottle moment of the original.
📖 Related: Riley Inside Out 2 Hockey: Why That High-Stakes Camp Felt So Real
To truly appreciate the film today, you have to view it as a cultural artifact. It’s a glimpse into who Hollywood thought was "it" in 2010. Some stayed stars (Cooper, Hathaway, Swift), while others faded into the background of prestige TV. Either way, for one weekend in February, they were all in the same universe, struggling with the same pink-colored problems.
Next Steps for the Rom-Com Fan:
Start by mapping out the "connection web" of the characters during your next viewing. You’ll find that the writing is actually tighter than it gets credit for, specifically in how the "Old Hollywood" stars (MacLaine) anchor the "New Hollywood" energy of the 2010s. If you’re a student of screenwriting, analyze Katherine Fugate’s structure—it’s a masterclass in modular storytelling that allows for maximum star power with minimum scheduling conflict.