Walk into the Palazzo Pubblico in Siena, Italy, and you’ll feel it immediately. The air is different in the Sala dei Nove. It’s where the "Nine" used to rule, and they didn’t just want to look at pretty wallpaper. They commissioned Ambrogio Lorenzetti in 1338 to paint something that would haunt them every time they made a law. The result? The Allegory of Good and Bad Government. It’s not just a dusty fresco. It is, quite literally, the world's first infographic on how to not ruin a civilization.
Most people think of medieval art as flat or boring. This isn't. It’s a massive, sprawling warning. Lorenzetti was living through a time of intense political chaos, and he decided to map out exactly what happens when leaders care about the public and what happens when they only care about themselves. Honestly, it’s kind of terrifying how little has changed in 700 years. If you look at the news today and feel like things are falling apart, Lorenzetti basically said, "Yeah, I told you so."
The Scary Side: What Bad Government Actually Looks Like
Let's talk about the nightmare first. The Allegory of Bad Government is dominated by a figure called Tyranny. He looks like a demon. He’s got horns, fangs, and a squint that suggests he’s only looking out for his own bank account. He doesn’t sit alone, though. Around him are his "advisors": Cruelty, Deceit, Fraud, Fury, Division, and War. It’s a heavy-handed list, but look at the details. Avarice is floating above him, clutching money bags.
In this world, Justice is bound. She’s literally tied up on the floor, her scales broken. When justice is a captive, the city dies. Lorenzetti paints the "Bad City" as a place of ruin. Houses are crumbling. Soldiers are dragging people out of their homes. There is no trade. No one is dancing. The only industry left is the forge making weapons. It’s a visceral depiction of a society where the social contract has been shredded. You’ve probably seen modern versions of this in failed states or neighborhoods where the infrastructure has been ignored for decades while the elites get richer.
Corruption isn't just a buzzword here. It's a physical rot. Lorenzetti shows that when a leader ignores the common good, the very stone of the city starts to crack. It’s a psychological landscape as much as a political one.
👉 See also: The German Shepherd 100 Years Ago: Why They Looked So Different
The Anatomy of the Good City
Flip the script. On the opposite wall, you have the Allegory of Good and Bad Government showing the "Good" side. Here, the central figure is a majestic old man representing the Common Good (Ben Comune). He’s surrounded by virtues like Peace, Fortitude, and Prudence.
Peace is the one everyone remembers. She’s reclining on a pile of armor, looking totally relaxed, almost bored. Why? Because when government works, life is supposed to be a little bit boring. You shouldn't have to wake up every day wondering if the currency will collapse or if a riot will break out. Peace is the absence of that anxiety.
Below the Common Good, you see the citizens. They are holding a cord that is attached to the scales of Justice. This is a huge detail. It means the people are literally "tied" to the concept of fairness. If they let go of the cord, the whole system tips over. It’s not just the leader’s job to be good; it’s the citizens’ job to stay connected to the law.
Why the "Effects" Matter More Than the Symbols
The middle part of the fresco is where things get real. It’s called the Effects of Good Government in the City and the Country. This is basically a 14th-century version of a high-resolution drone shot.
Siena looks beautiful. You see masons building new houses. You see a cobbler selling shoes. Most famously, there are young women dancing in the street. This was actually a bit controversial back then because dancing in public was sometimes seen as "loose" behavior, but Lorenzetti used it to show total safety. If you can dance in the street without fear, the government is doing its job.
✨ Don't miss: Fact and Opinion: Why Most People Still Get It Wrong
Outside the walls, the countryside is lush. Grain is being harvested. People are riding out to hunt. There is a figure hovering in the sky called "Securitas" (Security). She holds a tiny gallows with a man hanging from it. It’s a grim reminder: the city is safe because the law is actually enforced.
- Trade is flowing: Merchants move through the gates without being robbed.
- Infrastructure is growing: Scaffolding is everywhere because people are investing in the future.
- Agriculture is stable: The fields are organized, showing that someone is planning for the winter.
Contrast this with the "Bad" countryside. It’s on fire. Fields are barren. People are fleeing. It’s the difference between a society that thinks about the next ten years and one that only thinks about the next ten minutes.
The Virtue of Prudence and the Long Game
We need to talk about Prudence. In the Allegory of Good and Bad Government, she is often seen pointing to the past, present, and future. This is the "secret sauce" of stable societies.
Bad governments are impulsive. They react. They grab. They tweet—well, if they had phones back then, they would have. Good government is slow. It looks at what happened in the past (history), understands what is happening now (data), and plans for what might happen (strategy).
When we see modern political cycles that only focus on the next election or the next fiscal quarter, we are seeing a departure from the "Good Government" model. Lorenzetti was arguing that a ruler who doesn't look at the "Future" part of Prudence's gaze is basically just a tyrant in waiting. It’s a sobering thought when you look at climate policy or national debt today.
👉 See also: Hillside Memorial Chapel and Gardens Obituaries: What Most People Get Wrong
Misconceptions About Lorenzetti’s Message
Some people think this painting is just pro-Siena propaganda. It kind of is, but it’s more complicated. Siena was a republic, but it was a fragile one. The "Nine" who ran the city were under constant pressure from wealthy families and angry mobs.
This fresco wasn't just to brag to visitors. It was a mirror for the rulers themselves. Imagine sitting in a meeting to decide whether to raise taxes or go to war, and you have a 40-foot tall demon of Tyranny staring you in the face. It’s meant to create a sense of "holy fear."
Another misconception is that the "Good Government" is a utopia. It’s not. It’s a functional reality. Lorenzetti doesn't paint angels; he paints bankers, farmers, and builders. He’s saying that "Good" isn't a magical state of perfection. It’s just the result of people following the rules and leaders not being greedy. It’s actually quite a cynical, or maybe just practical, view of humanity.
How to Apply These 700-Year-Old Lessons Today
So, what do we do with this? We don't live in medieval Tuscany. But the Allegory of Good and Bad Government offers a blueprint for evaluating our own communities.
If you want to know if your local or national government is "Good" by Lorenzetti’s standards, stop listening to the speeches. Look at the "Effects." Are the "houses" (infrastructure) being maintained? Are the "dancers" (cultural life and personal freedom) thriving? Is "Justice" bound or free?
One of the most profound takeaways is the role of the "Cord." In the painting, the citizens hold a physical rope that connects them to Justice and the Common Good. When citizens become indifferent—when they stop holding the rope—the "Common Good" loses its power. A government can only be as good as the people who are willing to participate in it.
Actionable Insights for the Modern Citizen
- Audit your "Effects": Look past the rhetoric. Check the actual state of your local "countryside" (economy) and "city" (public services). If the physical environment is degrading, the "Tyranny" of neglect is likely present.
- Support "Prudence": Favor policies and leaders that prioritize long-term stability over short-term "wins." If a plan doesn't account for the "Future" part of the triad, it's a Bad Government trap.
- Identify the "Advisors": When you see a political movement, ask which of Lorenzetti's demons are present. Is it fueled by Division? Is it using Fraud or Deceit? If the advisors are toxic, the leader will be too.
- Hold the Cord: Engagement isn't just voting every four years. It’s the daily maintenance of the social fabric—supporting local businesses, participating in community boards, and insisting on transparent justice.
The frescoes in Siena are fading. Moisture and time are eating away at the pigment. But the logic behind them is indestructible. We are either building a city where people can dance, or we are forging weapons for a city in flames. There isn't really a middle ground.