Video games lie to you. They promise that "your choices matter," but honestly, most of the time they just lead to the same boss fight with a different colored explosion at the end. It’s a trick. But when Stoic Studio finally released The Banner Saga 3, they didn't play those games. They actually stayed true to the messy, punishing, and often heartbreaking consequences they'd been building since 2014. It’s brutal.
If you haven't played the first two, you're basically jumping into the third act of a play where the theater is already on fire. The world is literally ending. A giant, oily darkness is swallowing the land, turning everything it touches into warped, "warped" versions of themselves. You're juggling two perspectives: the desperate defense of Arberrang, the last human/Varl city standing, and a suicide mission into the heart of the darkness led by Juno, Iver, and Eyvind. It’s bleak. Like, "maybe-I-shouldn't-have-gotten-out-of-bed" bleak.
The Logistics of the End of the World
Most tactical RPGs focus on the stats. You want higher strength, better armor, the usual. While The Banner Saga 3 has that—the new "Heroic Titles" system adds some much-needed depth to leveling up—the real "stat" that matters is time.
The game operates on a countdown. Every day you waste on the road or in camp is a day closer to Arberrang falling. It’s a pressure cooker. I remember my first run through the game; I spent too much time trying to keep everyone happy and ended up losing half my roster because I didn't move fast enough. The game doesn't apologize for this. It expects you to understand that in a world-ending event, you can't save everyone. You just can't.
Why the combat feels different this time
The combat system hasn't fundamentally changed—it’s still the "Armor vs. Strength" dance that fans either love or find incredibly frustrating—but the stakes have shifted. In the darkness segments, you face "Waves."
Instead of the battle just ending, you get a choice: flee with what you have or stay and fight a second or third wave of enemies for a chance at a powerful item. It’s gambling with lives. If your best warrior gets downed in wave one, staying for wave two is basically a death sentence. But you need those items. You're desperate. This loop perfectly mirrors the narrative desperation.
✨ Don't miss: Sims FreePlay House Ideas: What Most People Get Wrong
The introduction of the "Dredge" as playable allies is another masterstroke. Seeing characters like the Stonesinger fighting alongside your Varl feels earned because you've spent three games learning that the Dredge are just as terrified of the darkness as you are. They aren't just monsters; they're refugees.
Arberrang: A Lesson in Narrative Anxiety
While the Iver/Juno side of the story is all about cosmic horror and weird magic, the Arberrang side is basically Game of Thrones on ice. It’s ugly. People are starving. The walls are crumbling. Rugga, the populist villain you've likely wanted to punch since the second game, continues to be a thorn in your side.
Here is where The Banner Saga 3 really flexes its writing muscles. Most games would make Rugga a cartoon villain. Here? He’s a guy who knows exactly how to manipulate a terrified crowd. You have to decide whether to play politics or rule with an iron fist. Neither choice feels "good."
If you’ve been carrying over your save file since the first game—which you absolutely should do—the weight of your past decisions is staggering. Characters you saved in the first game show up to help. People you accidentally got killed leave gaps in your defense that you can't fill. It’s a tapestry of grief.
👉 See also: Oblivion: A Rat Problem and Why This Early Quest Still Frustrates Players
Dealing with the "Warped" enemies
The new enemy types, the Warped, change the tactical layer. When a Warped enemy dies, they often leave behind "ashes" or "darkness" on the tiles. Step on those, and you take willpower damage.
Willpower is the lifeblood of this game. Without it, you can't move extra spaces, you can't use special abilities, and you can't hit harder. By making the battlefield itself a hazard, Stoic forces you to be much more careful about positioning than in the previous entries. You aren't just fighting an army; you're fighting the environment.
The Controversy of the Ending
Let's talk about the elephant in the room. Some people hated the ending of The Banner Saga 3. They felt it was too sudden or that it relied too much on a specific set of choices made in the final ten minutes.
I disagree.
The ending works because it’s a reflection of Eyvind’s mental state. Without spoiling the specifics, the final confrontation isn't a traditional boss fight. It’s a test of your understanding of the characters. If you haven't been paying attention to the lore—the stuff about the Loom-mother, the sun stopping, the nature of the Valka—you're going to struggle.
It’s an intellectual and emotional payoff rather than a mechanical one. It reminds me of the ending of Fallout: New Vegas or Planescape: Torment, where your ability to talk and reason is just as important as your ability to swing an axe.
A Masterclass in Art and Sound
We can't talk about this game without mentioning Austin Wintory’s score. The man is a genius. The music in the third game is much more discordant and brass-heavy than the folk-inspired melodies of the first. It sounds like the world is breaking because it is.
And the art? The hand-drawn aesthetic by Eyvind Earle-inspired artists remains the gold standard for the genre. Even though the color palette shifted toward purples and blacks for the darkness, the detail in the backgrounds is still breathtaking. Seeing the ruined vistas of a world being unmade is haunting.
Technical Realities and Platforms
If you're looking to jump in, The Banner Saga 3 is available on almost everything: PC (Windows/Mac), PS4, Xbox One, and Nintendo Switch. It even made its way to mobile, though I’d argue the screen size of a phone does a disservice to the art.
Performance-wise, it’s a 2D game, so you don't need a NASA supercomputer to run it. However, I will say that the loading times on the Switch version can be a bit sluggish compared to the PC version. If you have the choice, go PC for the smoothest experience and the easiest way to import your save files across the trilogy.
Common Misconceptions
One thing people get wrong is thinking they can play this as a standalone. You can... but why would you? You'll be lost. The game gives you a brief "recap" video, but it’s like reading the sparknotes of War and Peace. You miss the nuance.
Another misconception is that the "Easy" mode makes the game a visual novel. It doesn't. Even on easy, the tactical combat requires some thought. If you ignore the armor system, you will lose. Period.
Actionable Steps for New and Returning Players
If you're ready to finish the trek, here’s how to actually survive the end of the world without losing your mind.
- Import your saves. If you played the first two on different platforms, use a tool like "Banner Saga Save Editor" on PC to recreate your choices. It matters for the character roster.
- Prioritize Willpower in the Darkness. When playing as Iver’s group, items and titles that grant "Willpower per turn" are literal lifesavers. The darkness tiles will drain you fast.
- Don't ignore the "Mender" abilities. In the final game, Eyvind and other menders are your most powerful assets. Their ability to mend armor from a distance is the only thing that keeps your Varl tanks alive against high-damage Warped enemies.
- Keep multiple save slots during Arberrang segments. The game can "lock" you into a bad ending if your "Days Remaining" counter hits zero and your defenses are too low. Give yourself a fallback point.
- Invest in "Heroic Titles" early. Don't hoard your renown. Titles like "The Deathless" or "The Foolhardy" can turn a mediocre unit into a god-tier defender.
The trilogy is a rare bird in the gaming world. It’s a complete story, told with a singular vision, that doesn't blink when things get ugly. It’s about the fact that even if the world is ending, the way we treat each other on the way down matters. It’s a heavy, beautiful, and deeply satisfying conclusion to one of the best RPG sagas ever made.