If you grew up watching Jessica Fletcher cycle through the streets of Cabot Cove, you probably remember the cozy vibes. The bicycles. The fisherman sweaters. The polite local sheriff. But then there’s The Big Kill Murder She Wrote—an episode from Season 3 that honestly feels like it belongs in a different show entirely. It’s grittier. It's darker. It treats the Maine coastline not like a postcard, but like a place where dreams go to die under the weight of debt and desperation.
Most people think of Murder, She Wrote as "comfort food" television. You know the drill: someone dies, Jessica finds a stray button, and the killer confesses within forty-eight minutes. But "The Big Kill" (Season 3, Episode 17) messes with that formula in a way that makes it one of the most rewatchable entries in the entire series. It’s basically a masterclass in how to do a "bottle episode" within a town we thought we already knew.
What Actually Happens in The Big Kill Murder She Wrote
The plot is tight. It’s claustrophobic. We’re introduced to a struggling fisherman named Rick Rivers—played by a young, intense Chad Everett—who is drowning in financial trouble. He’s the classic noir protagonist: a good man pushed to the edge by a system that doesn’t care if he sinks or swims. When a wealthy, ruthless businessman named George Selby shows up in town, you just know things are going south.
Selby isn't just a victim; he’s a catalyst for the worst instincts in everyone around him.
The murder happens during a high-stakes meeting, and the "big kill" of the title refers to more than just the literal death. It’s about the death of the town's innocence. Cabot Cove is usually portrayed as this idyllic sanctuary, but here, the writers peel back the wallpaper to show the damp rot underneath. We see the economic anxiety of the 1980s reflected in a fishing village that’s losing its soul to corporate interests.
Why the Stakes Felt Different This Time
Usually, the victims in this show are distant relatives or obnoxious socialites. In The Big Kill Murder She Wrote, the conflict is personal to the community. When Jessica gets involved, she isn't just solving a puzzle for the fun of it. She’s trying to prevent a tragedy from compounding.
The episode features an incredible guest cast. You’ve got Hope Lange as Charlotte Hull, bringing a level of sophisticated melancholy that balances out the ruggedness of the docks. The interplay between the local "old guard" and the encroaching "new money" creates a friction that you don't always get in the more whimsical episodes involving magicians or international spies.
The Clues That Actually Mattered
Honestly, the mystery itself is one of the more logical ones.
✨ Don't miss: Why The Love Boat Season 1 Episode 1 Still Feels Like a Fever Dream
Sometimes Jessica finds a clue that feels like a massive reach—like a specific brand of tea leaf or a smudge of lipstick that only one person in the world wears. In "The Big Kill," the evidence is grounded. It’s about timing. It’s about the mechanics of the crime scene.
- The record player: A classic trope, but used effectively here to manipulate time.
- The ocean: It’s not just scenery; it’s a character that dictates the movement of people and evidence.
- The gun: The way the weapon is handled speaks to the desperation of the characters.
There’s a specific moment where Jessica realizes the discrepancy in the "suicide" note. It’s a classic Fletcher move, but it feels earned because the episode spends so much time establishing the victim's personality. We know he wouldn't have written those words. We know the rhythm of the town, so we know when something is off-beat.
A Departure from the "Cozy" Aesthetic
Let's talk about the lighting. Seriously.
Most episodes of Murder, She Wrote are lit like a sitcom—bright, flat, and cheerful. "The Big Kill" uses shadows. It uses the gray, misty atmosphere of the Maine coast to mirror the moral ambiguity of the suspects. It’s sort of a precursor to the "prestige TV" we see today, where the environment reflects the internal state of the characters. If you watch it back-to-back with a Season 1 episode, the difference is jarring.
The Social Commentary You Might Have Missed
If you look closely, this episode is a scathing critique of the "Greed is Good" era. George Selby represents the corporate raider archetype that was dominating the news cycles in 1987. He views Cabot Cove not as a home, but as an asset to be liquidated.
📖 Related: Why Yasiin Bey and the Legacy of Mos Def Still Matter in 2026
Rick Rivers, on the other hand, represents the working class. His struggle to keep his boat and his dignity is something that resonated deeply with audiences then, and honestly, it still resonates now. The show rarely gets this political, but when it does, it usually involves Jessica standing up for the "little guy" against a faceless, powerful entity.
Jessica Fletcher is often seen as a busybody, but in The Big Kill Murder She Wrote, she acts more like a social glue. She sees the fractures in her community and tries to mend them before they break entirely. She’s the only one who can navigate both the world of the wealthy elite and the world of the docks with equal ease.
Behind the Scenes: The Cast and Crew
The episode was directed by Seymour Robbie, a veteran of the procedural genre. He knew exactly how to pace a mystery so the audience feels like they're staying one step ahead, only to pull the rug out in the final act.
The chemistry between Angela Lansbury and Tom Bosley (Sheriff Amos Tupper) is at its peak here. This was Bosley's penultimate season, and you can tell the actors had developed a shorthand. Amos isn't just the "bumbling cop" trope here; he’s a man genuinely concerned about the peace of his town. The way he relies on Jessica feels less like incompetence and more like a deep-seated trust between friends.
Why We Keep Coming Back to Cabot Cove
There’s something hypnotic about the formula.
We know Jessica will win. We know the villain will be caught. But "The Big Kill" reminds us that even within a formula, there is room for nuance. It’s not just about the who-done-it; it’s about the why-they-did-it. This episode dives into the "why" with more empathy than usual.
The ending isn't a happy one. Sure, the killer is caught, but the lives of the people involved are still in tatters. The debt is still there. The grief is still there. It’s a rare moment of realism in a show that often ties everything up with a freeze-frame of Jessica laughing.
How to Watch It Today
If you're looking to revisit this specific episode, it’s readily available on most streaming platforms that carry the series, like Peacock or Prime Video.
- Look for Season 3, Episode 17. 2. Pay attention to the sound design. The wind and the waves are much more prominent than in other episodes.
- Watch the background actors. The "locals" in the diner and on the docks give a lot of texture to the world-building that makes the stakes feel real.
It’s also worth checking out the DVD commentaries if you can find them. The production team often talked about how the Maine-set episodes (which were mostly filmed on the Universal backlot and in Mendocino, California) required a specific "feel" to convince the audience of the cold, Atlantic setting. In "The Big Kill," they nailed it.
✨ Don't miss: Lil Uzi Vert Two Lyrics: Why This Intro Still Hits Different
Final Insights on the Legacy of the Episode
The reason The Big Kill Murder She Wrote stands out nearly forty years later is its willingness to be uncomfortable. It asks if a "good" person can do a "bad" thing when they're backed into a corner. It doesn't give us an easy answer, even if Jessica provides the solution to the crime.
If you’re a writer or a fan of mystery, analyze the dialogue in the scene between Rick and Selby. It’s lean. There isn't a wasted word. It sets up every single motivation that pays off in the final ten minutes. That's the hallmark of great television writing—making the inevitable feel surprising.
To get the most out of your rewatch:
- Compare the character of Rick Rivers to other "suspects" in the season; you'll notice he's given much more interiority.
- Note the lack of "humor" beats compared to the episodes set in New York or London.
- Observe how the "Big Kill" refers to the death of a dream as much as the death of a person.
The episode remains a high-water mark for the series because it proves that "cozy" doesn't have to mean "shallow." You can have your tea and your sweaters, but you can also have a serious conversation about poverty, greed, and the human cost of progress. That’s the real magic of Jessica Fletcher’s world.
Actionable Next Steps:
To truly appreciate the craft of this era, watch "The Big Kill" alongside the Season 4 premiere. You will see a massive shift in how the show handles tension versus humor. If you are analyzing the "small town noir" genre, take note of how the ocean acts as a physical barrier that heightens the "locked room" feel of the mystery. Finally, if you're a collector, look for the Hallmark "Cabot Cove" ornaments or memorabilia from this specific era (1987), as the aesthetic of this season defined the show's visual legacy.