Horror is a fickle beast. Most of the time, you get cheap jump scares and actors who look like they’re waiting for their paycheck to clear. But then something like The Blackcoat’s Daughter (originally titled February) comes along. It's cold. It's mean. It's quiet. Released widely in 2017 after a long festival run, the film didn't just rely on its bleak atmosphere; it leaned entirely on a trio of performances that felt way too real for a supernatural thriller. Honestly, if you haven't seen it, the The Blackcoat's Daughter cast manages to pull off a narrative shell game that shouldn't work, but it does because the acting is so grounded in grief and isolation.
Osgood Perkins—son of Psycho legend Anthony Perkins—directed this slow burn. He knew exactly what he was doing when he hired Kiernan Shipka, Emma Roberts, and Lucy Boynton. This isn't your typical "final girl" setup. It’s a triptych of misery.
The Haunting Precision of Kiernan Shipka as Kat
Kat is the heart of the movie, even if that heart is freezing over. Most people knew Kiernan Shipka as Sally Draper from Mad Men when this was filmed. She was the precocious kid. Here? She’s something else entirely. Kat is a freshman at Bramford Academy, left behind during winter break because her parents haven't shown up to get her.
Shipka plays Kat with this eerie, stiff-necked detachment. It’s not just "creepy kid" tropes. It’s the way she stares at the boiler in the basement. It’s the way she eats. You’ve probably seen horror movies where the possessed person screams and contorts. Shipka doesn't do that. She stays small. She looks lonely. That’s why it’s so much worse when she starts doing things that suggest something—or someone—else is in the room with her.
Her performance anchors the entire first act. If she didn't sell that specific brand of "hollowed out" sadness, the rest of the film would just be a moody exercise in cinematography. Instead, you feel for her, which makes the eventual descent into violence genuinely upsetting.
Emma Roberts and the Joan Mystery
Then you have Emma Roberts. She plays Joan. When we first see her, she’s shivering at a bus station, looking like she’s escaped from a hospital or a bad situation. She’s picked up by a grieving couple played by James Remar and Lauren Holly.
Roberts has built a career on being the "mean girl" or the "scream queen." In Scream Queens or American Horror Story, she’s usually sharp, witty, and loud. In the The Blackcoat's Daughter cast, she goes the opposite direction. She’s muted. She’s terrified. She’s hiding something so heavy it looks like it’s physically dragging her down.
The chemistry between Roberts and James Remar is fascinating because it’s built on shared silence. Remar plays Bill, a man who lost his daughter years ago. He sees a stray girl and wants to help. Roberts plays it with a twitchy, nervous energy that keeps you guessing. Is she a victim? Is she a predator? The way she handles a knife in the third act is a masterclass in physical acting—no dialogue needed, just the weight of the steel and the look in her eyes.
Lucy Boynton: The Reluctant Protector
Lucy Boynton plays Rose, the older student who stays behind with Kat. Rose is "rebellious." She’s worried she might be pregnant. She wants to see her boyfriend. She thinks Kat is just a weird kid she has to babysit.
Boynton brings a necessary friction to the film. While Kat is drifting into the supernatural, Rose is grounded in very human, very messy problems. Her skepticism provides the lens through which the audience views the school’s mounting dread. When Rose finally realizes that something is deeply wrong with Kat, the shift in Boynton’s performance—from annoyed teenager to primal fear—is visceral.
She’s the one who has to walk down into that basement. We’ve all seen that scene a thousand times in horror movies. Usually, we're shouting at the screen, "Don't go down there!" But Boynton makes you understand why she does. She's responsible. She's scared, but she's the adult in the room, even if she's only eighteen.
Supporting Players Who Fill the Silence
The The Blackcoat's Daughter cast isn't just the three leads. The peripheral characters are essential for building the world of Bramford Academy.
- James Remar (Bill): He brings a weary, broken-down fatherhood to the role. He’s the emotional bridge between the two timelines of the movie.
- Lauren Holly (Linda): She’s much more skeptical than her husband. Her performance is brittle. You can see the cracks in her composure every time she looks at Joan.
- Greg Terrence and Peter J. Gray: They fill out the edges, but the focus remains tight on the central women.
Why This Ensemble Works Better Than Other Slasher Casts
Most horror movies treat characters like cattle. They exist to be slaughtered. Perkins treats them like portraits.
The nuance here is that the film deals with "satanic possession" but plays it as a metaphor for the crushing weight of being alone. When Kat says she doesn't want her "friend" to leave, she isn't just talking about a demon. She's talking about the only thing that's been there for her. The actors have to play that duality—the horror of the act and the sadness of the motivation.
✨ Don't miss: Why Movie Watch Your Back Still Keeps Us Looking Over Our Shoulders
Shipka, Roberts, and Boynton don't feel like they're in the same movie for a lot of the runtime. That’s intentional. The film is split into chapters named after them. Yet, there’s a tonal consistency in their performances that makes the eventual convergence feel earned rather than forced.
The Legacy of the Performances
Looking back from 2026, it’s clear this film was a turning point for everyone involved.
Kiernan Shipka used this as a springboard to show she could lead a dark franchise (Sabrina). Emma Roberts proved she had range beyond the "bitchy" roles that defined her early twenties. Lucy Boynton went on to do massive projects like Bohemian Rhapsody, but many critics still point to her work here as some of her most controlled and effective.
The film didn't make $100 million at the box office. It didn't need to. It found its life on streaming and through word-of-mouth because of how unsettling the The Blackcoat's Daughter cast managed to be. They didn't rely on CGI or loud bangs. They used their faces. They used the way they breathed.
Actionable Insights for Horror Fans
If you're planning to watch or re-watch this, keep a few things in mind to truly appreciate what the cast is doing:
- Watch the timelines: Pay close attention to the way Joan (Emma Roberts) reacts when she hears the name "Rose" or "Kat." The acting is in the micro-expressions.
- Listen to the voices: The way Kat's voice slightly changes throughout the film is a subtle hint at her transformation. Shipka doesn't go full "demon voice," she just loses the inflection of a child.
- Observe the backgrounds: Often, the most important acting is happening when a character is just a blurry figure in the back of the frame.
- Contrast the endings: Compare the final shots of Kat and Joan. The symmetry is where the real horror of the movie lies.
The movie ends on a note of profound, soul-crushing loneliness. It's one of the few horror films that actually makes you feel bad for the "villain." That doesn't happen without a cast that is willing to go to some very dark, very quiet places.
If you want to dive deeper into this type of atmospheric horror, your best bet is to look into Osgood Perkins' other work, like I Am the Pretty Thing That Lives in the House or Longlegs. You'll see the same pattern: he picks actors who can hold a stare long enough to make the audience uncomfortable. It’s a specific skill, and the cast of The Blackcoat's Daughter mastered it.
To get the most out of the experience, watch it in a dark room, alone, and pay attention to the silence. The performances are buried in the quiet moments between the lines. Once you see the connection between the three women, the movie changes entirely on a second viewing. You realize you weren't watching a ghost story; you were watching a tragedy.