Kate Beckinsale in a PVC catsuit. That was basically the entire marketing budget for the first decade of this series. But by the time 2012 rolled around, things had to change. People were getting a bit tired of the same old Lycan versus Vampire feud that felt stuck in the early 2000s Matrix-clone era. When we look back at the cast for Underworld Awakening, it’s actually wild how much of a pivot it was. They didn't just bring back Selene; they blew up the world-building by adding humans to the mix and introducing a "hybrid" daughter that actually had some narrative weight.
It’s been over a decade, and honestly, this specific ensemble is why the movie still gets decent rotation on cable and streaming. It wasn’t just a mindless sequel. It was a soft reboot.
Selene’s Return and the Risk of Going Solo
Scott Speedman was gone. That’s the first thing everyone noticed. Michael Corvin, the heart of the first two films, was relegated to a CGI stand-in and a few blurry shots. This put an immense amount of pressure on Kate Beckinsale. She had skipped Underworld: Rise of the Lycans, and there was a legitimate question of whether audiences still cared about Selene without her hybrid boyfriend.
Beckinsale didn't just phone it in, though. She played a version of Selene that was colder, more displaced, and eventually, maternal in a very "Sarah Connor" kind of way. It's a nuanced performance for a movie about monsters. She wakes up after twelve years in cryo-sleep to find a world where humans have conducted "The Purge"—a systematic genocide of both species.
The New Blood: India Eisley and Theo James
The real heavy lifting in the cast for Underworld Awakening came from the newcomers. India Eisley was cast as Eve, the daughter Selene didn't know she had. Eisley has this naturally ethereal, slightly creepy vibe that worked perfectly for a girl who had spent her entire life in a lab. She’s the daughter of Selene and Michael, making her the first natural-born Hybrid.
📖 Related: Jesse Plemons New Movie Explained: Why Everyone is Talking About Digger
Then you have Theo James. Before he was the heartthrob in Divergent or the chaotic husband in The White Lotus, he was David.
David was a turning point for the franchise’s lore. He represented a younger generation of vampires who were tired of hiding in holes and waiting to be slaughtered by humans. Theo James brought a certain "pretty boy with a blade" energy that balanced out Beckinsale’s stoicism. It’s actually funny seeing him here now, knowing he’d eventually become a massive star. He’s charming, a bit reckless, and provides the necessary link to the old vampire covens that were falling apart.
The Human Element: Stephen Rea and Michael Ealy
Most Underworld movies treat humans like cattle. They are just there to be eaten or turned. Awakening changed the recipe. By casting Stephen Rea as Dr. Jacob Lane, the production secured a high-caliber character actor who could make "corporate evil" feel legitimate. Rea doesn't chew the scenery. He plays it quiet. He’s the head of Antigen, the biotech firm supposedly trying to find a "cure" for vampirism, but he’s obviously a Lycan in a lab coat.
Michael Ealy plays Detective Sebastian. Ealy is one of those actors who can do a lot with a little. His character is the only human who actually helps Selene. Why? Because his wife was a vampire who was killed during the Purge. It’s a small bit of backstory, but it gives the movie a soul. It’s not just bullets and biting; it’s a story about grief in a world that has gone completely insane.
Why the Villains Felt Different
In the original films, the villains were Shakespearean. Think Bill Nighy as Viktor—all capes and booming monologues. In the cast for Underworld Awakening, the villainy is much more industrial.
Kris Holden-Ried plays the "Uber-Lycan." He doesn't have a lot of lines, mostly because he spends half the movie as a twelve-foot-tall wall of muscle. But as Quint, the son of Stephen Rea’s character, he represents the Lycans' desperate attempt to win through science rather than destiny. It’s a bit of a departure from the "Lucian" days of leather vests and revolutionary speeches. This was about genetic dominance.
🔗 Read more: Why the Cast of Age of Ultron Was the MCU's Hardest Puzzle to Piece Together
Charles Dance: A Small Role with Huge Implications
We have to talk about Thomas. Charles Dance, the man who would go on to define "menacing father figure" as Tywin Lannister, appears here as David’s father. He’s a vampire Elder who has lost his spine. He wants to hide. He wants to survive by being invisible.
Dance is only in a few scenes, but he commands the screen so effortlessly that you forget you’re watching a movie about people in rubber suits. His presence gave the film a sense of history. It bridged the gap between the ancient, dusty world of the first movies and the sleek, sterile, blue-tinted world of the fourth.
The Missing Pieces: Where was Michael Corvin?
The biggest controversy regarding the cast for Underworld Awakening was the absence of Scott Speedman. Fans were annoyed. I get it. The central romance was the anchor of the series. Rumor has it Speedman just wasn't interested in returning to the leather and contacts. The production used a body double and some clever editing to keep Michael Corvin "present" without actually having the actor on set.
Honestly? It worked for the story. It made Selene feel more isolated. It made the stakes for finding her daughter feel higher because she was truly all alone in a world that hated her. If Michael had been there, it might have felt too much like a domestic drama with fangs.
Behind the Scenes: The Directors’ Vision
Måns Mårlind and Björn Stein directed this one. They brought a very European, clinical aesthetic. This influenced how the cast was directed. Everything is faster. The action is punchier. The performances are less operatic and more "survivalist."
✨ Don't miss: Why Black Comedy Actors Still Rule the Box Office (and Our Feeds)
They pushed for a 3D release, which was the big gimmick in 2012. This meant the actors had to deal with massive camera rigs that made traditional stunts harder. You can see it in the choreography; there’s a lot of "straight-at-the-camera" action. Beckinsale has mentioned in interviews that the physicality of this specific shoot was some of the toughest she'd done because of how the technology dictated the movement.
Impact on the Franchise
Without this specific cast, the series probably would have died in 2012. The introduction of David (Theo James) was so successful that he became a lead in the next installment, Underworld: Blood Wars. The dynamic between the "old guard" and the "new blood" allowed the franchise to escape the corner it had written itself into with the prequel.
It’s also worth noting how well the film handled the transition to a world where "monsters" are common knowledge. The actors had to play their roles with a level of paranoia that wasn't there in the first three films. In the earlier movies, they were the hunters. In Awakening, the cast had to play the hunted.
What to Watch Next if You Liked This Cast
If you’re a fan of the people involved in this movie, there are some deep cuts you should check out.
- India Eisley: Check her out in I Am the Night. She’s incredible in it and proves that her performance in Underworld wasn't just a fluke of casting.
- Michael Ealy: If you liked his grounded, detective vibe, Almost Human (the short-lived sci-fi series) is right up your alley.
- Theo James: Obviously The White Lotus season 2. It's a complete 180 from his role as David.
- Kate Beckinsale: For something different, watch Jolt. It carries that same high-octane energy but with a much more comedic, stylized tone.
The cast for Underworld Awakening succeeded because they didn't try to recreate the original film. They leaned into the cold, clinical, and desperate reality of a world that had moved on from ancient blood feuds and into the era of biological warfare. It’s a gritty, fast-paced entry that proved Selene could carry a movie on her own, provided she had a solid supporting group to bounce off of.
When you rewatch it, pay attention to the smaller characters. The lab technicians, the dying vampires in the coven, the frantic humans. They all contribute to a sense of scale that the previous movies lacked. It’s not just a story about two families; it’s a story about a planet that decided it was done with both of them.
If you are planning a marathon, watch this one back-to-back with Blood Wars. You can really see the evolution of Theo James’ character and how the chemistry with Beckinsale anchors the later half of the series. Check the credits for the stunt doubles too—many of them worked on the John Wick and Marvel films later on, which explains why the hand-to-hand combat took such a leap forward in this specific sequel.