It was 1985. Rob Reiner was just beginning a directorial run that would eventually make him a legend. John Cusack was barely out of high school. Before When Harry Met Sally redefined the modern romantic comedy, there was this scrappy, road-trip movie that managed to capture lightning in a bottle. Honestly, the cast of The Sure Thing is why we still talk about this movie. Without the specific chemistry between the leads and a supporting roster of character actors who actually felt like real people, it would have just been another forgotten eighties teen flick. It wasn’t, though. It was something much better.
The movie isn't just about a guy trying to get laid in California. It's about that weird, friction-filled transition from adolescence to adulthood. You’ve probably seen the tropes a million times by now—the uptight girl and the lovable loser stuck in a car together—but this was one of the first times it felt authentic rather than manufactured.
📖 Related: Why The Guardians of the Galaxy Holiday Special Is Still The Best MCU Experiment
John Cusack and the Birth of the Relatable Everyman
John Cusack plays Walter "Gib" Gibson. At the time, Cusack was only 17 or 18 years old during filming. Think about that for a second. Most actors playing college students in the eighties were pushing thirty and looked like they had mortgages. Cusack looked like he hadn't slept because he was too busy cramming for a mid-term he was definitely going to fail. He brought this frantic, caffeinated energy to the role that made Gib more than just a horny teenager.
He’s cynical but somehow desperate for connection. It’s a hard balance to strike. If you play it too mean, the audience hates you. If you play it too goofy, you’re a cartoon. Cusack found the middle ground. His performance as part of the cast of The Sure Thing solidified his persona as the "thinking man's teen idol." He wasn't the quarterback; he was the guy in the back of the class making sarcastic comments under his breath.
Daphne Zuniga: More Than Just a Foil
Then there’s Daphne Zuniga. She plays Alison Bradbury. On paper, Alison is the "stuck-up" girl. She has her life planned out in a Day-Timer. She likes things orderly. In a lesser movie, she’d be the villain or a boring obstacle. But Zuniga gives her a soul. You can see the cracks in her armor long before she actually starts to like Gib.
The chemistry between Cusack and Zuniga is the engine of the film. It’s prickly. It’s annoying. It feels like two people who actually can't stand each other being forced to realize they have everything in common. When they are hitchhiking in the rain or stuck in a trailer park, their bickering doesn't feel like "movie dialogue." It feels like a real argument you’d have with someone who is driving you crazy on a long trip. Zuniga went on to Melrose Place and Spaceballs, but this might be her most grounded work.
The Supporting Players Who Stole the Show
You can't talk about the cast of The Sure Thing without mentioning Anthony Edwards. Long before he was Dr. Greene on ER or Goose in Top Gun, he was Lance, Gib’s best friend who has already moved out to California. Lance is the one who promises the "Sure Thing" in the first place. Edwards plays it with a breezy, West Coast confidence that perfectly contrasts with Cusack’s East Coast anxiety.
And then there's the "Sure Thing" herself, played by Nicollette Sheridan. It’s her film debut. While her character is technically an object of desire—the literal personification of a male fantasy—the movie eventually subverts that. Sheridan plays the role with a surprising amount of poise, even though she doesn't get nearly as much screen time as the leads.
✨ Don't miss: House of Cards Season 1: Why It Still Feels Like the Ultimate Political Nightmare
Check out the rest of the roster:
- Boyd Gaines plays Jason, Alison's "perfect" but incredibly dull boyfriend. He is the human equivalent of a beige wall.
- Tim Robbins shows up in a small but hilarious role as Gary Cooper, a guy in the singing group on the bus. Yes, that Tim Robbins. It’s a reminder of how much talent was packed into this production.
- Viveca Lindfors as the professor. She brings a brief moment of actual gravitas to Gib’s academic struggles.
Why the Casting Worked When Others Failed
Most eighties comedies relied on "types." You had the nerd, the jock, the prep. Rob Reiner and casting director Jane Jenkins (who is a legend in her own right) looked for something else. They looked for actors who could handle the rapid-fire dialogue. The script, written by Steven L. Bloom and Jonathan Roberts, required timing. If you miss a beat, the joke dies.
The cast of The Sure Thing succeeded because they treated the material like a play. There’s a scene where Gib and Alison are trying to hitch a hike and Gib starts pretending they are a married couple. It’s improvised-feeling and chaotic. It works because Cusack and Zuniga were willing to look ridiculous.
The Directorial Influence of Rob Reiner
We have to give credit to Reiner. This was only his second film after This Is Spinal Tap. Coming off a mockumentary, he knew how to let actors find the "truth" in a scene. He didn't over-direct. He let the camera linger on their faces. When Gib looks at Alison while she's sleeping, there’s a quietness there that you just didn't see in movies like Porky's or Revenge of the Nerds.
The Cultural Impact of the Ensemble
Looking back from 2026, the movie feels like a time capsule of a specific kind of American innocence. There were no cell phones. If you got stuck on the side of the road, you were actually stuck. You had to talk to people. The cast of The Sure Thing had to convey that isolation.
The film also avoided the mean-spiritedness that defined much of the era. It wasn't about "winning" or "conquering" a woman. By the end, the "Sure Thing" isn't the girl in California; it's the connection Gib and Alison built. That shift in perspective is entirely dependent on the actors. If Cusack didn't look genuinely remorseful or if Zuniga didn't show her vulnerability, the ending would feel unearned.
Practical Takeaways for Fans and Cinephiles
If you are revisiting the film or watching it for the first time, keep an eye on the background. The small roles are filled with faces that would become staples of television and film for the next thirty years.
💡 You might also like: Why Nothing Sacred Still Matters: The Controversial Drama That TV Was Too Scared to Save
- Watch for the Chemistry: Notice how Cusack and Zuniga rarely touch for the first hour. The tension is built entirely through verbal sparring. It's a masterclass in "slow burn."
- Appreciate the Age: Remember that these were actual teenagers/young adults. The "teen" genre today often uses 25-year-olds with six-packs. The raw, slightly awkward look of the cast of The Sure Thing adds a layer of honesty.
- The Soundtrack Connection: The music helps, but the actors' reactions to the environment—the cold, the bad food, the weird locals—make it a true road movie.
To really appreciate the work done here, compare John Cusack’s performance in this to his role in Say Anything... four years later. You can see the evolution of his craft. In The Sure Thing, he's still figuring out his voice. In Say Anything..., he’s mastered it. But the spark? That started here.
The enduring legacy of this film isn't the plot. Road trips are a dime a dozen. It’s the people. It’s the way the cast of The Sure Thing made us believe that two people who have absolutely nothing in common could actually be the only two people in the world who matter to each other. That’s not just good casting; that’s movie magic.
For those looking to dive deeper into 80s cinema, your next step should be comparing this film's structure to It Happened One Night. You'll see exactly how Reiner and his cast took a classic 1930s screwball comedy blueprint and updated it for the MTV generation without losing the heart.