It was January 23, 2017. The Cleveland Cavaliers were the defending champs, the kings of the NBA world, and they were rolling into New Orleans to face a Pelicans team that was, frankly, struggling. Most people expected a blowout. Instead, we got one of the weirdest, most frustrating nights of the LeBron James era in Cleveland. If you look back at the Cavs vs Pelicans January 2017 matchup, you aren't just looking at a box score; you're looking at the exact moment the wheels started to wobble on a championship defense.
Cleveland lost 124-122.
That sounds close. It wasn't. At one point, the Pelicans—playing without Anthony Davis, mind you—were up by 22 points. It was embarrassing. It was the kind of game that makes a superstar go nuclear, and that is exactly what LeBron did afterward.
The Night Terrence Jones Looked Like an All-Star
Usually, when you talk about the Pelicans in 2017, you talk about Anthony Davis. But AD was out with a bruised right quad. This should have been a cakewalk for Kyrie Irving, Kevin Love, and LeBron. But basketball is weird. Terrence Jones stepped into the void and played the game of his life, dropping 36 points and grabbing 11 rebounds. Junior Holiday was right there with him, carving up the Cavs' defense for 33 points and 10 assists.
The Cavs' defense was nonexistent. It was porous. They gave up 70 points in the first half. Think about that. Seventy. To a team missing their best player.
Kyrie Irving was trying, though. He was actually incredible, finishing with 49 points. He was hitting everything—absurd layups, deep threes, the whole repertoire. But it didn't matter because the rest of the roster looked like they were running in sand. Kevin Love had 22 and 16, which looks great on paper, but the defensive rotations were just slow. LeBron had a triple-double (26 points, 10 rebounds, 12 assists) but also had six turnovers and looked visually exhausted by the end of the third quarter.
Why Cavs vs Pelicans January 2017 Triggered the Rant
This specific game is famous—or infamous—not because of the score, but because of what happened in the locker room afterward. LeBron James was done. He was tired of the "top-heavy" roster. If you remember the headlines the next morning, they weren't about Terrence Jones. They were about LeBron calling out the front office.
He basically told reporters that the team wasn't satisfied with just one ring and that they needed a "f***ing playmaker."
It was raw. It was honest. It was also a little bit tactical. LeBron knew the team was thin. Beyond the Big Three, the bench was a rotating door of veterans who were perhaps a year or two past their prime. Kay Felder was the backup point guard. DeAndre Liggins was getting significant minutes. When you’re trying to repeat against a Golden State Warriors team that had just added Kevin Durant, "fine" isn't good enough.
The Cavs vs Pelicans January 2017 game exposed the reality that Cleveland was vulnerable. They were 30-13 at the time, which is a great record for most teams, but they had lost five of their last seven. The vibes were rancid.
Looking at the Numbers That Actually Mattered
If you dive into the play-by-play, the third quarter was where the soul of the game lived. Cleveland tried to make a run. They outscored New Orleans 36-24 in the fourth. But the hole they dug in the first half was just too deep.
The Pelicans shot 48.4% from the field. They were aggressive. They outscored Cleveland in the paint. They forced turnovers. It was a blueprint on how to beat the 2017 Cavs: run them into the ground and hope the bench can't keep up.
New Orleans was coached by Alvin Gentry at the time. His system was all about pace. Even without Davis, they pushed the ball relentlessly. Langston Galloway came off the bench and hit huge shots. Dante Cunningham was doing the dirty work. It was a "sum of the parts" victory that highlighted every single flaw in Tyronn Lue’s defensive schemes that month.
The Impact on the 2017 Trade Deadline
After this loss, the pressure on GM David Griffin was immense. You could feel it through the TV screen. LeBron wasn't just complaining to the media; he was setting a deadline.
Eventually, this led to the arrival of Deron Williams and Kyle Korver (though Korver was already there, the need for more became the mantra). The team was desperate to find guys who could handle the ball so LeBron didn't have to play 44 minutes a night just to keep the team competitive against sub-.500 squads.
Honestly, the January slump is a staple of LeBron-led teams. It happens almost every year. But 2017 felt different because the looming shadow of the Warriors was so huge. Losing to a shorthanded Pelicans team felt like an omen.
Breaking Down the Kyrie 49-Point Masterclass
We have to talk about Kyrie's 49 points for a second. It was one of those nights where he looked like the best floor general in the league. He went 8-of-14 from three-point range. He was the only reason the game was even remotely close in the final two minutes.
But it also highlighted the problem: the Cavs were becoming a team that relied on individual brilliance rather than a cohesive system. When Kyrie wasn't "on," they were lost. When LeBron sat, the lead evaporated. This game was the perfect microcosm of that struggle.
✨ Don't miss: Why the NBA Playoff Bracket 2003 Changed the League Forever
The Pelicans, meanwhile, were just having fun. When you're the underdog and you realize the champ is vulnerable, you smell blood. Terrence Jones was playing like he had something to prove to the entire league. He was finishing through contact, hitting mid-range jumpers, and basically outworking Kevin Love on the glass. It was his career high.
What We Learned Long-Term
Looking back at Cavs vs Pelicans January 2017, the lesson is pretty clear: regular-season chemistry matters, even for "Superteams." You can't just flip a switch in June if your habits in January are trash. The Cavs did eventually make it back to the Finals that year, but they were dismantled by the Warriors in five games.
Many analysts point back to this January stretch as the beginning of the end for that specific iteration of the Cavs. The internal friction started here. The "playmaker" comments rubbed some people the wrong way. The defensive lapses became a permanent feature rather than a temporary bug.
If you're a Pelicans fan, this was a top-five regular-season win in the post-CP3 era. Beating the defending champs without your franchise player is the stuff of legend. For Cavs fans, it’s a game they’d probably rather forget, buried under the weight of LeBron’s post-game explosion.
Actionable Insights for Basketball Historians and Analysts
To truly understand the weight of this game, you have to look at the context of the 2016-2017 season as a whole.
- Study the Minutes: Look at the minutes LeBron James was playing in January. He was leading the league or close to it. This game showed the physical toll that was taking.
- Defense Wins... Nothing in January: The Cavs' defensive rating took a massive dive during this month. Compare their rotations in this game to their championship run six months prior; the lack of urgency is staggering.
- The "LeBron Effect" on Media: This game is a masterclass in how a superstar can use a loss to force a front office's hand. If you're interested in the business or politics of the NBA, watch the post-game press conference from this night.
- Underrated Performances: Don't ignore Terrence Jones. His performance is a reminder that on any given night, an NBA player can look like a superstar if the scheme allows it.
The final score was 124-122, but the impact lasted the rest of the season. It wasn't just a loss in the standings; it was a loud, public wake-up call that the Cavaliers weren't as indestructible as they thought. If you want to understand why that era of Cleveland basketball ended the way it did, you have to start with nights like this one in New Orleans.