Why The Great Gatsby the movie 2013 is still the most divisive adaptation in Hollywood history

Why The Great Gatsby the movie 2013 is still the most divisive adaptation in Hollywood history

Baz Luhrmann doesn’t do subtle. If you walked into a theater expecting a quiet, dusty period piece when The Great Gatsby the movie 2013 premiered, you were probably in for a massive shock. It’s loud. It’s colorful. Honestly, it’s kind of a fever dream of 3D glitter and hip-hop beats that F. Scott Fitzgerald definitely didn't imagine back in 1925. But here’s the thing: after over a decade, we’re still talking about it. That’s because Luhrmann understood something essential about the "Jazz Age" that most stuffy biographers miss. It was never meant to feel like a museum. It was meant to feel like a riot.

Critics absolutely tore this film apart at first. They hated the Jay-Z soundtrack and the dizzying camera work. Yet, audiences showed up in droves, turning it into a massive box office hit that pulled in over $350 million worldwide. It captures that specific brand of American longing—the kind that feels desperate and shiny all at once. Leonardo DiCaprio’s portrayal of Jay Gatsby isn't just acting; it’s a masterclass in the "fake it 'til you make it" ethos that defines our modern era just as much as it did the 1920s.

The controversy of the 21st-century soundtrack

Music is usually where people draw the line with The Great Gatsby the movie 2013. Why use rap in a movie set in the age of Duke Ellington? Luhrmann’s logic was actually pretty solid, even if it felt jarring to purists. He argued that jazz in the 1920s wasn't "polite" background music for dinner parties; it was the edgy, dangerous, street-level pop music of its time. By swapping out Dixieland for Kanye West and Lana Del Rey, he forced a modern audience to feel the same energy that a 1922 partygoer would have felt.

It’s about the vibe.

If you listen to the way "100$ Bill" thumps during the drive into Manhattan, you get that sense of frantic, illegal wealth. It’s visceral. You aren’t looking at history through a sepia-toned lens; you’re living in it. This choice by executive producer Jay-Z remains one of the boldest creative risks in recent cinema. Some people still find it distracting, sure. But for others, it’s the only reason the movie works at all. It bridges the gap between the "Lost Generation" and the "TikTok Generation" effortlessly.

🔗 Read more: Choi Seung-hyun: What Most People Get Wrong About T.O.P

Leonardo DiCaprio and the weight of the green light

DiCaprio was born to play this role. Period. Before The Great Gatsby the movie 2013, we had Robert Redford’s 1974 version, which was beautiful but arguably a bit too stiff. Redford’s Gatsby was a statue. Leo’s Gatsby is a vibrating wire. He captures that specific, manic insecurity—the way Gatsby stares at the green light on Daisy’s dock like it’s the only thing keeping him alive.

There is this one scene—the first time we see him—where he turns around to the sound of Rhapsody in Blue and fireworks explode behind him. It’s ridiculous. It’s over the top. It’s also exactly how Gatsby sees himself. The film leans into the artifice. It reminds us that "Jay Gatsby" is a character invented by James Gatz, a poor kid from North Dakota. DiCaprio plays the man playing the man. It’s layered, nuanced, and honestly, he deserves more credit for the subtle ways his "Old Sport" catchphrase starts to sound more desperate as his dream falls apart.

Carey Mulligan’s Daisy Buchanan is another highlight that people tend to overlook. She isn't just a shallow flapper. In this version, you see the "beautiful little fool" logic as a survival mechanism. She knows the world is cruel to women, so she retreats into her money and her silence. It makes the tragedy hit harder because you realize she isn't worth the pedestal Gatsby put her on, but she’s also a victim of her own status.

Visuals that redefined the "Roaring Twenties"

The production design by Catherine Martin is basically the gold standard for maximalism. Every single frame of The Great Gatsby the movie 2013 is packed with detail. From the Miu Miu and Prada collaborations on the costumes to the Brooks Brothers suits, the fashion was so influential it actually triggered a massive 1920s revival in real-world retail.

  • The Tiffany & Co. jewelry wasn't costume jewelry; it was the real deal.
  • The yellow Duesenberg (well, the replica of the 1929 model, even though the book is set in '22) became an iconic symbol of Gatsby’s "new money" gaudiness.
  • The Valley of Ashes was depicted with a haunting, CGI-heavy gloom that contrasted perfectly with the neon glow of the parties.

Some say the CGI makes the movie look "fake." But isn't that the point? Gatsby’s entire life was a fake construction. The saturated colors and impossible camera swoops reflect the distorted reality of someone who thinks they can repeat the past. When Nick Carraway (played with a sort of wide-eyed twitchiness by Tobey Maguire) looks at this world, he’s seeing it through the lens of a man who is "within and without." The artifice is a narrative choice, not a technical flaw.

Why the movie still matters in 2026

We are living in a new Gilded Age. The themes of wealth inequality, the obsession with persona, and the tragic pursuit of an unattainable past are more relevant now than they were when the movie dropped in 2013. We see "Gatsbys" every day on social media—people crafting perfect lives out of thin air, hoping no one looks too closely at the basement.

The film serves as a cautionary tale that looks like a celebration. That’s the trick. It lures you in with the party, then hits you with the hollowed-out silence of Gatsby’s funeral. It’s a movie that demands to be seen on the biggest screen possible because its emotions are just as oversized as its budget.

If you haven't revisited it lately, it's worth a rewatch. You’ll notice things you missed the first time—like the recurring motif of the Eyes of Doctor T.J. Eckleburg or the way the weather mimics the rising tension in the Plaza Hotel scene. It’s a dense, messy, beautiful piece of filmmaking that refuses to be ignored.


How to experience the Gatsby world today

To truly appreciate the layers of this adaptation, you should look beyond just the 143-minute runtime. There’s a whole ecosystem of craft and history behind the scenes that makes the experience richer.

💡 You might also like: Batman and Robin: Why Tim Drake is Actually the Best Version

  • Watch the "Behind the Scenes" on Catherine Martin’s Costume Design: Understanding the historical research that went into the Prada collaborations changes how you see the characters' social standing.
  • Listen to the soundtrack as a standalone album: Strip away the visuals and listen to how the lyrics of "Young and Beautiful" or "Over the Love" actually mirror the plot of the novel.
  • Compare the "Plaza Hotel" scene to the text: Read Chapter 7 of the book and then watch the movie scene. It is one of the most faithful word-for-word adaptations of a climax in modern cinema.
  • Look into the 3D filming techniques: Luhrmann used 3D not for "action," but to create a sense of theater and intimacy. Pay attention to the depth of field in the quiet scenes between Gatsby and Nick.

The real takeaway from The Great Gatsby the movie 2013 is that the American Dream is a beautiful, dangerous hallucination. Whether you love the glitter or hate the noise, the film forces you to confront the fact that we are all, in some way, beating on, boats against the current. It’s a wild ride that proves some stories are too big to be told in black and white.