Pottery isn't supposed to make you cry. Yet, there we were in early 2020, watching a middle-aged man weep over the "bone-dry" state of a clay jug. If you haven't seen The Great Pottery Throw Down Season 3, you might think that sounds ridiculous. It’s not. Honestly, it’s some of the most human television ever produced.
When the show moved to More4 after a long hiatus following its stint on BBC Two, fans were nervous. Changes in networks usually spell disaster for niche reality competitions. They get "glossy." They lose their soul. But the third outing of the pottery battle did the opposite. It leaned into the grit of the Gladstone Pottery Museum in Stoke-on-Trent. It felt colder, damper, and somehow more intimate.
The New Guard and the Kiln God
Most people remember the transition because of the hosting swap. Siobhan McSweeney stepped in, and frankly, her chaotic energy was exactly what the kiln room needed. She brought a sharp, Irish wit that balanced out the heavy emotional stakes. You’ve got these potters pouring their literal sweat into a Raku firing, and then Siobhan wanders by with a dry comment that reminds everyone it’s just mud, even if it’s very important mud.
Then there was the judging. Keith Brymer Jones remained the emotional heart. If Keith doesn't cry, did the pot even happen? Probably not. But Season 3 introduced Sue Pryke. Her perspective was different. While Keith looks for the "soul" and the technical heft, Sue brought a designer’s eye for contemporary utility. She wasn't just looking for a nice bowl; she was looking for a piece that could sit on a high-end gallery shelf or a minimalist’s dinner table. This friction between "feeling" and "function" defined the season.
The contestants were a wild mix of backgrounds. We had Matt, the professional cycling manager, who approached clay with the precision of a mechanic. Then there was Rosa, whose library background seemed to inform her meticulous attention to detail. It wasn't just about who could throw the biggest pot. It was about who could survive the "Main Make" without their work exploding in the kiln.
👉 See also: Richard Strauss Four Last Songs: Why They Still Break Our Hearts
Kilns are cruel. You can spend twenty hours carving a delicate floral motif into a ginger jar, but if there's one tiny air bubble? Pop. Game over.
Why The Great Pottery Throw Down Season 3 Felt Different
The pacing changed. In the first two seasons, things felt a bit rushed, a bit like they were trying to mimic the "Bake Off" formula too closely. By the time we got to the third series, the editors realized that watching clay spin is meditative. It's ASMR before ASMR was a mainstream thing.
The challenges in Season 3 were also notoriously difficult. Remember the Greek amphorae? Or the Raku animal sculptures? Raku is a terrifying process for a beginner. You’re pulling red-hot ceramics out of a kiln at 1000°C and shoving them into bins of sawdust. The smoke, the flames, the sudden thermal shock—it’s high drama.
Rain. It always seemed to be raining in Stoke-on-Trent that year. The grey light coming through the windows of the old Victorian factory gave the whole season a moody, artistic atmosphere. It made the warmth of the kiln room feel like a sanctuary.
The Breakout Stars of the Wheel
Rosa was a powerhouse. Her consistency was frightening. But the beauty of this specific season was that the underdog narrative actually felt real. Claire, who eventually took the win, had this incredible trajectory. She wasn't always the loudest in the room, but her technical growth was massive.
Jacob was another one. Only 19 at the time, he showed a level of maturity in his work that baffled the judges. It proved that pottery isn't just a "retirement hobby." It’s a craft that's being reclaimed by a younger generation who are tired of digital everything. They want to touch dirt. They want to make something that lasts longer than a social media post.
🔗 Read more: Until the End of Time: Why This Justin Timberlake Classic Still Hits Different
Pottery is slow. You can't rush it. If you try to dry a handle too fast with a hairdryer, it cracks. If you're too aggressive on the wheel, the walls collapse. This season taught the audience about patience in a way that felt authentic, not lectured.
Technical Hurdles That Broke the Potters
The "Spot Test" remained the most stressful part of the show. Imagine being told you have fifteen minutes to make a perfect teapot spout when you've never made one in that specific style before. It’s a nightmare.
In Season 3, the technicals focused heavily on precision.
- Hand-building versus throwing.
- The chemistry of glazes.
- Managing the shrinkage rate of different clay bodies.
A lot of viewers don't realize that clay shrinks about 10% to 12% as it dries and fires. If you’re making a lid for a jar, you have to calculate that shrinkage perfectly, or it won't fit. Seeing the potters struggle with the math was a great reminder that art is often just hidden science.
The Legacy of the 2020 Series
Why does this season still rank so highly for fans? It was the bridge. It bridged the gap between the "old" version of the show and the global phenomenon it became on streaming platforms like HBO Max (now Max). It proved the format had legs outside of the BBC.
It also solidified Keith Brymer Jones as a legitimate cultural icon. His vulnerability—his willingness to be moved to tears by a well-turned foot ring—offered a version of masculinity that was refreshing. He wasn't judging them on their "effort"; he was judging them on the honesty of their work.
📖 Related: Why Let’s Get Together Youngbloods is the Most Misunderstood Peace Anthem in History
If you're looking to get into pottery because of this show, don't start by trying to throw a 5kg vase. Start with a pinch pot. That’s the secret the show whispers but doesn't always shout: everything starts with a small, simple lump of earth.
Practical Steps for Aspiring Potters Inspired by Season 3
If you've just finished rewatching the season and feel the urge to get your hands dirty, don't go out and buy a £1,500 Shimpo wheel immediately. Pottery has a steep learning curve and an even steeper equipment cost.
First, find a local "taster" session. Most cities have community studios that offer two-hour workshops. You’ll probably make a wonky bowl, and that’s fine. Second, understand that "greenware"—clay that hasn't been fired—is incredibly fragile. You will break things. You will lose pieces in the kiln. Season 3 showed us that even the best potters fail. Embrace the "reclaim" bucket.
Third, study the chemistry. If you want to understand why Claire's glazes looked so professional, look into how oxides like cobalt or copper react to heat. The beauty is in the physics.
Finally, watch the "foot" of your pots. As Keith says, it's the part that lifts the piece off the table. It gives it grace. Whether you're making a mug or a sculpture, the details you think no one will see are actually the ones that matter most.
Stop scrolling and go find some clay. Even if it's just air-dry stuff from a craft store to practice your hand-building, the tactile feedback of shaping a 3D object is something our brains are wired to crave. The Great Pottery Throw Down Season 3 wasn't just a competition; it was a call to return to making things with our hands. It’s messy, it’s frustrating, and occasionally, it’s beautiful enough to make a grown man cry.