It is a simple number. Usually out of 100. For over two decades, the HRC Corporate Equality Index (CEI) has acted as the de facto yardstick for LGBTQ+ inclusion in the American workplace. If you work for a Fortune 500 company, there is a very high probability your HR department obsesses over this score. They track it. They budget for it. They celebrate it on LinkedIn.
But what actually happens behind that "100" rating?
Honestly, the reality is a mix of high-level policy shifts and granular, sometimes frustrating, administrative checklists. The Human Rights Campaign (HRC) didn't just wake up one day and decide to rank companies for fun. They realized that if you want to change culture, you have to follow the money. By benchmarking how corporations treat their queer and transgender employees, they created a competitive environment where being "inclusive" became a business necessity rather than just a moral suggestion.
The HRC Corporate Equality Index: More Than a Sticker
You’ve probably seen the "Best Places to Work for LGBTQ+ Equality" logo. It’s everywhere.
To get that logo, companies have to submit to a rigorous survey. It’s not just a "vibes" check. The HRC looks at specific, documented policies. They want to see your non-discrimination statements. They want to see if your healthcare covers gender-affirming care. They want to know if you have an ERG (Employee Resource Group) that actually has a budget and isn't just a monthly pizza party.
The scoring criteria evolve. This is where people get tripped up. A company that scored 100 in 2020 might have dropped to an 80 in 2024 without changing a single internal policy. Why? Because the HRC raises the bar. They’ve moved from basic non-discrimination to requiring inclusive benefits for domestic partners, and more recently, to demanding that companies take a public stand on equity issues.
It’s a moving target.
What the 2023-2024 Criteria Actually Demanded
The most recent shifts in the HRC Corporate Equality Index focused heavily on the "Total Rewards" package. It wasn't enough to just say "we don't fire gay people." That’s the bare minimum. The 2023 criteria pushed hard on transgender-inclusive healthcare. Specifically, the HRC looks for at least one health plan option that covers things like hormone therapy, gender-reassignment surgery, and mental health services without "blanket exclusions."
Then there’s the "Public Commitment" pillar. This is the part that gets the most pushback in the current political climate. To get full points, a company often has to demonstrate "public engagement" with the LGBTQ+ community. This might mean sponsoring a Pride event, but it could also mean a company's legal department filing an amicus brief against discriminatory legislation.
The Backlash and the "Quiet" Pivot
It hasn't all been smooth sailing lately. You’ve likely heard about the "anti-woke" movement affecting corporate boardrooms. Brands like Target and Bud Light faced massive blowbacks, which put a spotlight on the HRC Corporate Equality Index.
Some companies are getting nervous.
In late 2024, we saw a few high-profile companies like John Deere and Tractor Supply Co. explicitly state they would no longer participate in the HRC’s ranking system. They didn't necessarily scrap their internal diversity programs, but they stepped away from the public benchmarking. They felt the "social" part of ESG (Environmental, Social, and Governance) had become too much of a lightning rod.
This creates a weird tension. On one hand, the CEI has successfully normalized LGBTQ+ protections in the workplace. On the other, the public-facing nature of the score is now seen by some executives as a liability.
Is the index losing its teeth? Not really. Even if a handful of rural-focused brands pull out, the vast majority of the Fortune 500—think Google, Apple, JP Morgan, and Walmart—still treat the CEI as a critical KPI. Because at the end of the day, talent follows the score. Gen Z and Millennial workers, who make up the bulk of the workforce, check these ratings before they sign an offer letter.
How the Scoring Actually Breaks Down
The HRC doesn't make it easy. They use a point system that is basically broken into four main categories.
- Workforce Protections (20 points): This is the "legal" stuff. Does your policy explicitly include "sexual orientation" and "gender identity"? If you miss one, you lose points.
- Inclusive Benefits (30 points): This is the meat of the survey. It covers parity between same-sex and different-sex spouses. It also covers the aforementioned transgender-inclusive healthcare.
- Supporting an Inclusive Culture (25 points): This is about the ERGs. Do you have a diversity council? Do you do internal training?
- Corporate Social Responsibility (25 points): This is the public-facing part. It includes marketing to the LGBTQ+ community and supplier diversity programs.
Wait. There’s a catch. You can actually get negative points.
If a company takes an action that the HRC deems "detrimental" to LGBTQ+ equality—like donating to a politician who is the lead sponsor of an anti-trans bill—they can lose 25 points instantly. This is the "official" reason why some companies have seen their scores tank despite having great internal HR policies.
Real World Impact: It's About the Healthcare
Let’s talk about the tangible stuff. Forget the politics for a second.
Before the HRC Corporate Equality Index gained widespread adoption, finding a job that covered PrEP or gender-affirming surgery was like finding a needle in a haystack. Today, because of the CEI’s pressure, over 90% of CEI-rated companies offer at least one transgender-inclusive health insurance plan.
That is a massive shift in how corporate America functions.
👉 See also: Why a 90 day plan template is the only thing keeping your new job from becoming a disaster
It’s also changed how companies handle family leave. If a gay couple adopts a child, they now get the same "parental leave" as a straight couple at almost any major firm. Twenty years ago, that was a radical concept. Today, it’s just HR 101. The CEI turned radical ideas into standard operating procedures.
The "Check-the-Box" Criticism
Now, let's be real. Some critics argue the CEI is just a "check-the-box" exercise. They aren't entirely wrong.
You can have a company with a 100 rating where the actual daily experience of a queer employee is miserable. A perfect score doesn't mean your middle manager isn't a jerk. It doesn't mean the culture in a satellite office in a conservative area is welcoming. It just means the corporate headquarters in New York or San Francisco has the right paperwork on file.
Nuance matters. A score of 100 is a floor, not a ceiling.
Navigating the Future of Corporate Equality
As we move deeper into 2026, the HRC Corporate Equality Index is facing its biggest test. The "S" in ESG is being redefined.
We are seeing a shift toward "inclusive professionalism." Companies are moving away from loud, rainbow-washed marketing and toward quiet, structural support. The HRC is likely to adapt by focusing more on outcomes and less on public statements. They may start looking at retention rates for LGBTQ+ staff or the diversity of the C-suite itself.
👉 See also: VWUAX Stock Price Today: Why This Vanguard Giant is Moving
If you’re a business leader, you can’t ignore the index, even if you’re worried about the political optics. The data shows that inclusive companies have higher employee engagement and lower turnover. It’s not just "woke" politics; it’s good math.
Actionable Steps for Your Workplace
If you're looking to improve your standing or just make your workplace better for your team, don't just chase the 100. Focus on these specific areas that actually move the needle:
- Audit Your Healthcare: Don't just trust your broker. Look at the "Summary of Benefits and Coverage" (SBC). Search for exclusions related to "gender identity" or "transition-related care." If they exist, ask your provider to remove them. Many providers will do this for a negligible cost if the client asks.
- Formalize Your ERG: If you have an LGBTQ+ group, give them a budget. Give them a seat at the table with the executive team. An ERG without a budget is just a social club; an ERG with a budget is a business resource.
- Update Your Supplier Diversity: Most companies focus on minority-owned or women-owned businesses. The CEI looks at whether you also track and include LGBTQ-owned businesses in your supply chain.
- Policy vs. Practice: Conduct an anonymous internal survey. Ask your LGBTQ+ employees if they feel comfortable being "out" to their direct supervisor. If the answer is "no," your 100 rating doesn't mean much.
The HRC Corporate Equality Index remains the most influential tool for driving change in the private sector. It isn't perfect, and it isn't a substitute for a genuine culture of belonging. But it provides the framework that has, quite literally, changed the lives of millions of workers by ensuring their identities don't disqualify them from a fair paycheck and decent healthcare.
Staying informed means watching how the HRC updates its "voter guide" for corporations and understanding that the criteria will only get more specific. The goal is no longer just "tolerance." It is "equity," and that requires a lot more than just a sticker on the front door.
To stay ahead, companies should begin reviewing their current 2025-2026 benefit cycles now. Waiting for the survey to land in your inbox is too late. High-performing organizations treat the CEI like an annual audit—prep early, document everything, and use the gaps as a roadmap for the next fiscal year.