You know that feeling when a movie just feels like a warm hug? That’s 1949’s In the Good Old Summertime. It’s a musical remake of The Shop Around the Corner, and honestly, it’s one of those rare cases where a remake actually holds its own against a masterpiece. People mostly search for the In the Good Old Summertime movie cast because they want to see Judy Garland at her peak, but there is so much more happening in this ensemble than just one superstar.
It’s a Technicolor dream of turn-of-the-century Chicago.
🔗 Read more: Where Can I Stream Portlandia: Why the Dream of the 90s Is Suddenly Everywhere Again
The story follows two bickering music store clerks who are unknowingly falling in love as anonymous pen pals. If that sounds familiar, it’s because the story (originally a Hungarian play called Parfumerie) eventually became You’ve Got Mail. But forget Tom Hanks and Meg Ryan for a second. We’re talking about Judy Garland and Van Johnson.
The Powerhouse Duo: Judy Garland and Van Johnson
Judy Garland plays Veronica Fisher. By 1949, Judy was going through it. Everyone knows the stories about her struggles with the studio system, but when the camera rolled on this film, you’d never know. She’s funny. She’s sharp. Her voice in "The Merry Kindergarten" or the title track is just… pure gold. She had this way of being vulnerable and a total "boss" at the same time.
Then you have Van Johnson as Andrew Delby Larkin. Van was MGM’s "boy next door." He wasn't the deepest actor in the world, let's be real, but he had this easygoing charm that balanced Judy’s high-wire energy. He plays the slightly arrogant, slightly bumbling manager perfectly. Their chemistry isn't explosive like a modern rom-com; it’s more of a slow simmer that feels earned by the time they’re sharing a soda at the end.
Interestingly, Van Johnson wasn't the first choice. They actually thought about Peter Lawford for the role. Can you imagine? Lawford was great, but he didn't have that "midwestern earnestness" that Van brought to the table. Van’s chemistry with Judy worked because he wasn't trying to out-act her. He just let her shine.
✨ Don't miss: Why the City of Angels Cast Still Breaks Our Hearts Decades Later
The Supporting Cast: The Secret Sauce of the Film
A movie like this lives or dies on its character actors. If the In the Good Old Summertime movie cast was just the two leads, it would be boring.
S.Z. "Cuddles" Sakall plays Otto Oberkugen, the owner of the music shop. If you’ve seen Casablanca, you know him as Carl the waiter. He’s the guy who always looks like he’s about to sneeze or cry, and he’s constantly flustered. He brings this frantic, European energy to a very American film. His obsession with his "Stradivarius" violin—which is actually a cheap fiddle—is one of the best running gags in the movie.
Then there’s Buster Keaton.
Yes, that Buster Keaton. The silent film legend.
By 1949, Keaton’s career as a leading man was over, and he was working at MGM as a gag writer. He actually wasn't supposed to be in the movie. He was hired to help choreograph a scene where Van Johnson accidentally breaks a violin. But he was so good at the physical comedy that they put him in the movie as Hickey. Watching a master of silent film do physical bits in a Judy Garland musical is like a fever dream in the best way possible. There’s a scene where he’s trying to walk through a crowded room with a bass viol that is masterclass-level physical acting.
Spring Byington plays Nelly Burke. She’s the steady hand, the veteran clerk who sees everything coming a mile away. Byington was the "queen of the character actresses" back then. She provides the emotional groundedness that keeps the movie from floating away into pure fluff.
A Very Special Debut
We have to talk about the finale. If you blink, you’ll miss it, but the very last scene features a tiny three-year-old girl.
That’s Liza Minnelli.
📖 Related: Aunt Phoebe Handmaid’s Tale Actress: Why D’Arcy Carden Was the Perfect Final Twist
It was her film debut. She’s walking between Judy Garland and Van Johnson in a snowy park. It’s a bittersweet moment looking back, knowing the trajectory of Liza’s life and her own legendary career. But in that moment, she’s just a kid in a cute hat. It adds this weird, beautiful layer of reality to a film that is otherwise a very polished Hollywood product.
Why This Version Hits Different
Most people compare this to the 1940 James Stewart version, The Shop Around the Corner. While the 1940 version is "better" cinema—it’s directed by Ernst Lubitsch, after all—the 1949 musical has a specific warmth. It’s the difference between a high-end restaurant and a home-cooked meal.
The musical numbers aren't "showstoppers" in the way Singin' in the Rain numbers are. They are diegetic—meaning they happen naturally within the world of the music shop. When Judy sings "I Don't Care," she’s literally trying out a piece of sheet music. It feels intimate.
The production was actually remarkably smooth given Judy’s health at the time. Director Robert Z. Leonard was a "reliable" studio hand. He wasn't an auteur, but he knew how to move a camera and keep the lighting bright. That’s what this movie needed. It’s a celebration of the "good old days," even if those days never really existed quite like that.
Technical Details and Trivia
- Studio: Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer (MGM)
- Release Date: July 1949 (An odd choice for a movie with a Christmas finale, but it worked)
- Box Office: It was a massive hit, earning over $3 million in its initial run.
- Color: Shot in vivid Technicolor. The reds and greens in the music shop are incredibly saturated.
One thing people get wrong is thinking this was a direct remake. It actually changed the setting from Budapest to Chicago. This change allowed for the inclusion of barbershop quartets and turn-of-the-century Americana songs that fit the "Summertime" vibe of the title.
Actionable Insights for Classic Film Fans
If you’re diving into the In the Good Old Summertime movie cast and want to get the most out of your viewing experience, here are a few things to do:
- Watch it as a Double Feature: Pair it with The Shop Around the Corner. It is fascinating to see how the exact same script beats are handled with music versus without.
- Look for the Keaton Gags: Pay close attention to any scene involving Buster Keaton and a physical object. He wasn't just "acting"; he was essentially directing those specific moments of physical comedy.
- Listen to the Arrangements: The musical director was Georgie Stoll. He was a master at taking old turn-of-the-century tunes and making them sound lush and modern for 1949. The orchestration on "Play That Barbershop Chord" is top-tier.
- Check Out the Fashion: The costume design by Irene is stunning. Look at the transition of Veronica’s (Judy) hats throughout the film. They reflect her changing mood and social status within the shop.
- Spot the "Little Liza": Wait for the final 30 seconds. It’s a piece of Hollywood history that still feels poignant.
This movie isn't trying to change the world. It’s trying to make you feel better for 102 minutes. Sometimes, that's exactly what you need. Whether you're a Garland fanatic or just someone who loves a good "enemies to lovers" trope, this cast delivers a masterclass in Golden Age charm.
Take the time to find a high-definition restoration. The Technicolor in this film is notoriously difficult to get right on old DVDs, but the newer digital transfers really make the "Good Old Summertime" pop.