Honestly, it shouldn't have worked. Remaking an iconic 1980s film franchise for network television usually smells like a desperate cash grab. Yet, when the Lethal Weapon television show premiered on Fox in 2016, it defied every cynical expectation. It was fast. It was funny. Most importantly, the chemistry between Clayne Crawford and Damon Wayans felt electric, almost dangerously so.
But then it all fell apart.
If you ask a fan today about the show, they don't usually start by talking about the explosive stunts or the clever writing. They talk about the drama behind the scenes—the leaked audio tapes, the firing of a lead actor, and the eventual quiet cancellation that left a sour taste in everyone's mouth. It’s a fascinating case study in how a hit series can be its own worst enemy.
📖 Related: The Summer I Turned Pretty Season 3 Episode 5: Why This Turning Point Changes Everything
The Impossible Task: Replacing Mel Gibson and Danny Glover
The shadow of the original films is massive. When Matt Miller (the show's creator) announced the project, the internet rolled its collective eyes. How do you find a new Riggs and Murtaugh?
Clayne Crawford was a relatively deep-cut choice. He wasn't a household name, but he brought a certain "indie film" grit to Martin Riggs that felt grounded rather than cartoonish. He didn't try to play Mel Gibson. He played a man drowning in grief who just happened to be good at kicking doors down. On the other side, Damon Wayans brought the veteran comedic timing required for Roger Murtaugh.
The pilot episode, directed by McG, set the tone perfectly. It looked expensive. The action sequences weren't just "good for TV"—they were genuinely cinematic. For two seasons, the Lethal Weapon television show was a ratings juggernaut for Fox, often pulling in over seven million viewers an episode. People loved the "buddy cop" dynamic because it felt earned.
The show succeeded because it leaned into the trauma. Unlike the later sequels of the film franchise, which became almost pure comedy, the series spent a lot of time in Riggs’ dilapidated trailer on the beach. It explored his suicidal ideation and his inability to process the death of his wife, Miranda. It gave the show a heartbeat that separated it from the standard procedural fluff of the mid-2010s.
When the "Lethal Weapon Television Show" Became Too Real
By the end of Season 2, the wheels weren't just coming off; the whole car was on fire.
Reports began surfacing about extreme tension on set. It wasn't just "creative differences." It was full-blown hostility. Variety and The Hollywood Reporter eventually published accounts of a toxic work environment, specifically highlighting outbursts from Crawford. One particular incident involved an episode Crawford was directing, where an actor—reportedly Wayans—was struck by a piece of shrapnel during a stunt.
The audio leaks were devastating. Hearing the two leads trade insults during a scene was jarring for fans who tuned in every week to see them play best friends.
Crawford was eventually fired. It was a move that shocked the industry because, usually, the "number one" on the call sheet is untouchable. Not this time. The producers were in a corner. They had a hit show but a leading man they could no longer work with.
✨ Don't miss: Erika Jayne Masked Singer Reveal: Why the Yorkie Unmasking Was So Relatable
The Seann William Scott Era
Enter Seann William Scott. Known forever as Stifler from American Pie, Scott was brought in for Season 3 to play Wesley Cole, a former CIA operative.
It was a bold move. They didn't recast Riggs; they killed him off. This was a narrative choice that many fans found unforgivable. While Scott gave a surprisingly nuanced and physical performance, the DNA of the show had mutated. The "Riggs and Murtaugh" brand was the entire reason the Lethal Weapon television show existed in the first place.
Without that specific friction, the show felt like a different series wearing a dead man's suit. Ratings dipped. The magic was gone. By the time Season 3 wrapped, the writing was on the wall. Wayans had already publicly stated he was "too old for this" and wanted to leave the show to deal with health issues and spend time with family. Fox pulled the plug in May 2019.
What People Get Wrong About the Cancellation
There is a common misconception that the show was canceled because it stopped being good. That's not entirely true. Even in the third season, the writing remained sharp, and the action was top-tier.
The real reason was logistical and financial. When your main star wants out (Wayans) and your other star has been fired (Crawford), the cost of rebuilding the brand a second time is simply too high. Network television is a business of margins. The international distribution rights for the Lethal Weapon television show were valuable, but not enough to sustain a production that had become a public relations nightmare.
The Legacy of the Series
Looking back, the show remains a high-water mark for the "film-to-TV" adaptation trend. It proved that you can take a 30-year-old property and make it relevant to a modern audience by focusing on character depth rather than just nostalgia.
It also served as a cautionary tale for Hollywood. It highlighted the importance of "set culture." You can have the best scripts and the highest production values, but if the two people at the top of the pyramid can't stand each other, the foundation will eventually crumble.
If you're looking to revisit the series, here is the best way to approach it:
🔗 Read more: LL Cool J 90s: Why the Greatest Comeback in Rap History Still Matters
- Watch Season 1 as a standalone piece. It is arguably one of the best debut seasons of a police procedural in the last twenty years. The balance of humor and genuine pathos is nearly perfect.
- Acknowledge the shift in Season 3. If you go in expecting the same vibe as the first two years, you'll be disappointed. If you treat it as a spin-off about a lonely CIA vet trying to reconnect with his daughter, it’s actually decent television.
- Look for the stunt work. The show employed some of the best stunt coordinators in the business, and many of the practical effects used in the chase sequences are still impressive by today's standards.
The Lethal Weapon television show shouldn't be remembered only for the drama. It should be remembered for the 40-odd episodes where it actually captured lightning in a bottle. It reminded us why we liked these characters in the first place: they were broken, they were loud, and they were always just one bad day away from total chaos.
To truly understand the impact of the show, compare it to other reboots of the era like MacGyver or Magnum P.I. Most of those shows played it safe. Lethal Weapon took risks. It dealt with grief, aging, and police corruption with a level of honesty that most network shows avoid.
Next Steps for Fans and Viewers
- Check the Streaming Status: As of now, the series often rotates through platforms like Hulu or Max depending on licensing deals with Warner Bros. Television.
- Compare the Pilots: Watch the first 20 minutes of the 1987 film and the 2016 pilot back-to-back. It’s a masterclass in how to modernize a character's "origin story" without losing their soul.
- Explore the Supporting Cast: Don't sleep on Kevin Rahm as Captain Brooks Avery or Keesha Sharp as Trish Murtaugh. They provided the emotional ballast that kept the show from drifting too far into the absurd.
- Dive into the "Behind the Scenes" context: If you're a student of television production, research the 2018 industry reports regarding the show's set environment. It offers a rare, unvarnished look at the pressures of high-stakes TV filming.