It was 2009. E4 was already the home of Skins, a show that felt like a punch to the gut for anyone over the age of twenty. Then came Misfits. It wasn't just another teen drama; it was a foul-mouthed, orange-jumpsuited subversion of every superhero trope we’d ever been fed by Marvel or DC. Looking back, the misfits cast season 1 was lightning in a bottle. You had five kids who basically hated each other, stuck in a community center in Wertham, suddenly gifted with powers they didn't want and definitely didn't know how to use. Honestly, it was a mess. A beautiful, chaotic, British mess.
The genius of that first year wasn't the special effects. Let's be real—the CGI was "low budget" even by 2009 standards. No, the magic was the chemistry. You had Robert Sheehan playing Nathan Young, a character so irritatingly charismatic that he basically redefined the "lovable rogue" archetype for a whole generation. Then there was Iwan Rheon as Simon, long before he became the most hated man in Westeros. Seeing him play a shy, invisible "creepy" kid is still jarring if you’ve only ever seen him as Ramsay Bolton.
The Raw Energy of the Misfits Cast Season 1
What people forget is how grounded those early episodes felt despite the lightning storms and the time travel. Howard Overman, the creator, didn't want capes. He wanted ASBOs. The misfits cast season 1 represented a very specific slice of British youth culture that felt authentic, even when they were accidentally killing their probation officers.
Let's break down the core five because their dynamics were everything.
📖 Related: I, Worst of All: What Most People Get Wrong About Sor Juana Inés de la Cruz
Nathan was the engine. Without Robert Sheehan’s frantic, ad-libbed energy, the show might have collapsed under its own cynicism. He was the one who didn't even get a power in the first season—or so we thought. That "big reveal" in the finale is still one of the best-executed twists in TV history. Then you had Kelly, played by Lauren Socha. She was the "chav" with a heart of gold, whose power was hearing thoughts. It was perfect irony; someone who usually shouted over everyone was suddenly forced to listen to the internal insecurities of the world around her.
Alisha (Antonia Thomas) and Curtis (Nathan Stewart-Jarrett) rounded out the group. Alisha’s power—making anyone she touched fall into a frenzied sexual trance—was genuinely dark when you actually think about the implications of consent and isolation. Curtis, the fallen star athlete, could turn back time, but only when he felt intense regret. It was a cast of characters built on their flaws, not their strengths.
Why We Still Talk About These Characters
The show worked because it understood that having superpowers wouldn't make your life better. It would make it significantly worse. If you're a nineteen-year-old on community service, gaining the ability to turn invisible just reinforces your feeling of being ignored by society. The misfits cast season 1 leaned into that nihilism.
- Simon Bellamy (Iwan Rheon): He was the voyeur. His arc across the first six episodes is a masterclass in subtle acting. He starts as the guy everyone mocks and ends as the guy who actually has the stomach to do what needs to be done.
- Nathan Young (Robert Sheehan): Constant talking. Non-stop. Sheehan’s performance was so high-octane that it allegedly influenced how writers wrote for the show in later years, trying to capture that specific brand of Irish charm and utter depravity.
- Kelly Bailey (Lauren Socha): She grounded the show. While Nathan was being absurd, Kelly’s reactions were often the "audience surrogate" moments of "Are you lot seeing this?"
Honestly, the chemistry was so tight that when the cast started changing in later seasons, the show never quite recovered that same "us against the world" vibe. It became more about the "power of the week" and less about the shared trauma of being a young adult in a bleak urban landscape.
The Impact of the Wertham Setting
Environment matters. The brutalist architecture of the Thamesmead estate (the real-world stand-in for Wertham) was as much a character as the actors themselves. It was cold. It was gray. It was the absolute opposite of the shiny towers in The Avengers. This backdrop forced the misfits cast season 1 to feel small. They weren't saving the world; they were trying to finish their community service hours without getting arrested for the bodies they kept burying in the local park.
✨ Don't miss: Why the Cast of the Lords of Flatbush Still Defines Cool 50 Years Later
It’s easy to look back with rose-tinted glasses, but the show was gritty. It dealt with suicide, isolation, and classism in ways that felt revolutionary for a "superhero" show. When we talk about the misfits cast season 1, we aren't just talking about actors; we're talking about a cultural shift in how the UK exported its television. It was the "anti-Skins" and the "anti-Heroes" all at once.
The Problem With Reboots and Remakes
There have been countless rumors of a US remake for over a decade. It never quite works. Why? Because you can’t easily replicate the specific alchemy of this specific group. The American sensibility often struggles with the "loser" aspect of the characters. In the original, they aren't misunderstood geniuses. They’re just kids who messed up.
If you try to polish the misfits cast season 1, you lose the soul of the show. You need the grime. You need the swearing. You need the sense that these people might actually be terrible for each other, even as they’re the only ones who understand what’s happening.
Moving Beyond the First Season
While the show ran for five seasons, the first six episodes are the purest distillation of the concept. It’s where the stakes felt highest because we didn't know the rules yet. We didn't know if anyone could die (spoiler: they could).
The legacy of the misfits cast season 1 is visible in shows like The Umbrella Academy or The Boys. It paved the way for "deconstructionist" superhero media. It proved that you don't need a hundred-million-dollar budget if you have a script that treats its characters like humans instead of icons.
📖 Related: Why the Cover of the Magazine Still Dictates Who Wins the Culture War
If you’re looking to revisit the series or watching for the first time, pay attention to the silence. For all the shouting Nathan does, the best moments are the quiet ones—the looks between Simon and Alisha, or the way Kelly defends the group against outsiders. That’s where the real power was.
What to do next:
- Watch the original pilot: Go back and look at the first ten minutes. Notice how the camera lingers on the mundane details of the community center before the storm hits. It sets the tone perfectly.
- Track the careers: Follow the trajectories of the main five. Seeing Antonia Thomas in The Good Doctor or Iwan Rheon in Game of Thrones gives you a real appreciation for the range they displayed back in 2009.
- Avoid the spoilers: If you haven't finished Season 1, stay off the wikis. The reveal regarding Nathan’s power is best experienced without knowing it's coming.
- Listen to the soundtrack: The music selection for the first season—featuring The Rapture, LCD Soundsystem, and Justice—is a perfect time capsule of late-2000s indie and electro-dance that defined the era's energy.
The misfits cast season 1 remains a benchmark for ensemble television. It was bold, it was rude, and it was undeniably British. Whether you’re a fan of the genre or just someone who appreciates good character writing, it’s a masterclass in how to start a story with a bang—and a few dead bodies.