You’ve probably seen them sitting in those little plastic cups at the gas station or ignored them while they turned green in your cup holder. Pennies. They’re basically the junk mail of currency. Every few years, a rumor catches fire that pennies stop being made, and people either panic or cheer. Honestly, most of us just want to know if we can still use the ones under our couch cushions.
The reality is a bit more complicated than a simple "yes" or "no." While the U.S. Mint hasn't officially pulled the plug yet, the math behind the copper-plated zinc disc is getting pretty ugly.
The Ridiculous Cost of a Cent
It’s expensive to be cheap. That’s the irony of the American penny. Right now, it costs the U.S. Mint about three cents to produce a single one-cent coin. Think about that for a second. We are literally losing money on every single penny that rolls off the press. In 2023, the Mint lost nearly $90 million just making pennies.
💡 You might also like: Why the Legacy Self Serve Car Wash is Refusing to Die
Why is it so pricey? Metal prices. Zinc and copper aren't getting any cheaper, and the manufacturing process involves a ton of energy and logistics. It’s not just the materials; it’s the shipping, the security, and the labor. For decades, groups like Citizens for Retiring the Penny have pointed out that we’re essentially throwing tax dollars into a furnace to maintain a coin that most people won't even bend over to pick up off the sidewalk.
The Canada Precedent
If you want to see what happens when pennies stop being made, just look North. Canada killed their penny in 2013. They didn't seize everyone’s change or make it illegal to own; they just stopped distributing it.
The world didn't end.
Cash transactions are simply rounded to the nearest five cents. If your coffee is $2.02, you pay $2.00. If it’s $2.03, you pay $2.05. Interestingly, digital transactions—like using your debit card or phone—stay exactly the same down to the cent. It’s a hybrid system that has saved the Canadian government millions every year. Many other countries, including Australia, New Zealand, and Brazil, have done the exact same thing with their lowest-denomination coins.
The Politics of Change
So, if it’s such a money-loser, why hasn't the U.S. followed suit? It’s not because of logic. It’s mostly because of lobbying and a weird sort of nostalgia.
The zinc industry has a huge stake in this. Jarden Zinc Products, based in Tennessee, provides the blanks for the penny. Naturally, they spend a decent amount of money making sure the penny stays in production. They argue that getting rid of it would lead to "rounding inflation," where businesses would always round up, hurting the poorest consumers. However, most economic studies—including those by Robert Whaples, an economics professor at Wake Forest University—suggest that rounding actually balances out over time and has a negligible impact on inflation.
💡 You might also like: Samsung Electronics Stock Price in Dollars: Why the Smart Money is Hitting Buy
Then there’s the Lincoln factor. Abraham Lincoln is an icon. People feel a strange emotional attachment to seeing his face on the coin, even if that coin is mostly a nuisance in their pockets. Illinois politicians, in particular, have historically been very protective of the penny for this reason. It’s a symbol. But is a symbol worth a $90 million annual loss?
The Hidden Waste of Time
Beyond the cost of the metal, there’s the cost of time. Have you ever been stuck behind someone at a checkout counter who is digging through their purse to find three pennies so they don't get 97 cents in change back?
- Store clerks spend hours counting pennies.
- Banks have to process them.
- Armored trucks haul heavy bags of them across the country.
When you add up the seconds wasted at every cash register in America, the "opportunity cost" is staggering. We’re talking about billions of dollars in lost productivity every year just so we can keep using a coin that can’t actually buy anything on its own. Not even a single piece of gum.
What Happens When Production Actually Ceases?
If the day finally comes when pennies stop being made in the U.S., your life won't change as much as you might think. Here is the likely roadmap based on how other countries handled it:
First, the Mint will stop shipping new pennies to banks. They won't "expire." You will still be able to take your jars of coins to the bank and deposit them. Merchants will likely still accept them for a while, but eventually, they will become a rarity.
👉 See also: State Employee Salaries New York: What Most People Get Wrong
The biggest shift will be at the register. We will see the "Rounding Rule" become standard.
- Prices ending in .01, .02, .06, and .07 round down.
- Prices ending in .03, .04, .08, and .09 round up.
- Prices ending in .00 and .05 stay the same.
It’s fair. It’s fast. And honestly, most of us are already paying with Apple Pay or credit cards anyway, where this wouldn't even apply. Digital payments are the real "penny killer." As we move closer to a cashless society, the physical penny becomes even more of an evolutionary leftover, like a tailbone for our economy.
Real-World Resistance
Not everyone is on board with the "death of the cent." Some charities rely heavily on penny drives. "Check out" donations, where you drop your spare change into a bucket for a local hospital, are a significant source of revenue. If the penny disappears, these organizations worry that people won't be as willing to drop nickels or quarters into the jar.
There is also the "0.99" psychological pricing. Retailers love prices that end in 99 cents because it feels significantly cheaper than a dollar. If the penny goes away, does everything become $1.00? Probably. But again, that only affects the cash-paying customer.
The Collector’s View
If the U.S. announced tomorrow that pennies stop being made, the secondary market would go nuts. Common pennies wouldn't suddenly be worth a fortune, but "uncirculated" rolls from the final year of production would become instant collector's items. We’ve seen this before with the transition of the wheat penny or the 1943 steel cent. People love a "final edition."
But let’s be clear: the 2024 penny sitting in your cup holder right now will likely never be worth more than one cent. There are just too many of them in existence—billions and billions.
Moving Toward a Penny-Free Future
Is it inevitable? Probably. The U.S. has retired coins before. We used to have a half-penny. In 1857, it was discontinued because its purchasing power had dropped too low. Adjusted for inflation, that half-penny was worth about 15 cents in today’s money when we killed it.
Think about that. We got rid of a coin that was worth 15 times what a penny is worth today because it was "useless." By that logic, the penny should have been retired decades ago.
Actionable Steps for Your Change
Don't wait for a government decree to deal with your copper hoard. If you’ve got piles of pennies, here’s how to handle them before they become even more of a hassle:
- Coinstar and Gift Cards: Most Coinstar machines take a percentage if you want cash, but if you choose a gift card (like Amazon or Starbucks), they usually waive the fee. It’s the easiest way to turn "trash" into actual buying power.
- The Bank Routine: Some banks still offer free coin counting for members. Don't wrap them in paper rolls if you don't have to; it's a waste of time. Call ahead and see if they have a machine.
- Charity Apps: Many nonprofits now have "round-up" apps that link to your debit card. They do the work of a penny jar without the physical mess.
- Check Your Dates: Before you dump them, keep an eye out for pennies made before 1982. Those are 95% copper and actually have a "melt value" of about 2.5 cents. It’s technically illegal to melt them down right now, but they’re a better store of value than the zinc ones.
The end of the penny isn't something to fear. It’s just an update to a system that’s been running on outdated software for too long. Whether it happens this year or five years from now, the transition to a penny-free economy is a matter of "when," not "if."
Keep an eye on the U.S. Mint's annual reports. When the "cost to distribute" finally crosses a certain threshold of political embarrassment, the penny will join the half-penny in the history books. Until then, keep an eye on your change—not because it's valuable, but because it's still taking up space in your life.
Next Steps for You
- Audit your change: Check if your local bank offers a free coin-counting service for account holders.
- Exchange for digital value: Use a kiosk to convert your pennies into a fee-free digital gift card for a retailer you use frequently.
- Monitor metal prices: Keep an eye on zinc and copper market trends, as these are the primary drivers of the legislative push to end penny production.