It is the most famous movie song in history. Period. You know the melody before the first three notes even finish. But here is the thing: the somewhere over the rainbow original song was nearly cut from The Wizard of Oz because some studio executive thought it was too slow. Imagine that. One of the most culturally significant pieces of music ever written almost ended up on a cutting room floor in 1939 because it "slowed down the pace" of the Kansas scenes.
Music is weird like that.
The song wasn't just a lucky hit. It was a calculated, desperate attempt by songwriters Harold Arlen and Yip Harburg to ground a technicolor fantasy in something deeply human. If you look at the sheet music, the first interval is an octave jump. That’s a huge leap for a singer. It represents the literal distance between a gray, dusty farm and a world where "troubles melt like lemon drops." It’s yearning set to a frequency.
💡 You might also like: Alltel Pavilion at Walnut Creek: What Really Happened to Raleigh’s Iconic Venue
The Day the Rainbow Almost Died
MGM executives were notoriously picky. After a preview screening, Louis B. Mayer and others felt the Kansas sequence was dragging. They wanted to get to the Munchkins. They wanted the color. To them, Judy Garland standing next to a tractor singing a ballad felt unnecessary.
Arthur Freed, the associate producer, had to basically go to war to keep it in. He reportedly told the studio heads that the song stayed or he walked. He knew instinctively what they didn't: without that song, Dorothy has no motivation. You need to see her heart before you see her ruby slippers.
Honestly, it’s terrifying how close we came to a version of The Wizard of Oz that was just a wacky road trip without a soul.
The Arlen and Harburg Dynamic
Harold Arlen wrote the tune, but Yip Harburg gave it the social conscience. People forget that Harburg was a staunch socialist who was later blacklisted during the McCarthy era. When he wrote the lyrics for the somewhere over the rainbow original song, he wasn't just thinking about a magical land. He was thinking about the Great Depression. He was thinking about people who had lost their homes and were looking for a "place behind the sun."
Arlen actually struggled with the melody at first. He was driving his car in Los Angeles, passing Grauman's Chinese Theatre, when the broad, sweeping bridge of the song hit him. He pulled over and scribbled it down. Harburg initially hated the melody because he thought it was too "grand" for a little girl in Kansas. He thought it sounded like a symphony, not a folk song. But after some coaxing and a slower tempo adjustment, they found the sweet spot.
Recording the 1939 Magic
When Judy Garland stepped into the recording booth, she was only 16 years old. You can hear it in the original 1939 track—there is a slight tremble, a bit of vulnerability that she lost in later years as her voice grew more powerful and, frankly, more tired.
The arrangement by Herbert Stothart and George Stoll used a full orchestra, but they kept the opening sparse. The woodwinds mimic the wind of the plains. It’s haunting.
🔗 Read more: The Last of Us Season 2 Episode 6 Recap: Why That Ending Changes Everything
Interestingly, there is a verse that most people don't know exists. It’s called the "introductory verse," and it starts with: "When all the world is a hopeless jumble / And the raindrops tumble all around..." In the film, they cut this intro to get straight to the iconic melody. It was a smart move. Starting with the high octave jump creates an immediate emotional hook that defines the entire experience.
Why It Hits Different During a Crisis
The song was released right as the world was teetering on the edge of World War II. It became an anthem for soldiers. Why? Because "home" is a universal concept that becomes most valuable when it feels unreachable.
It’s not just a kids' song. It’s a song about longing.
- It topped the charts in 1939.
- It won the Academy Award for Best Original Song.
- The American Film Institute ranked it as the #1 movie song of all time.
But beyond the stats, it survives because it’s technically perfect. The AABA structure is a masterclass in songwriting. It builds tension and then releases it exactly when the ear expects it.
The Technical Brilliance of the Composition
Let's get nerdy for a second.
The song is in the key of A-flat major (at least in the original film version). The opening "Some-where" is an octave jump from $Ab3$ to $Ab4$. This is difficult to hit cleanly. If you’re too sharp, it sounds aggressive. Too flat, and the whole song feels depressing. Garland nailed it with a slight "scoop" that felt natural.
The bridge—the "Where troubles melt like lemon drops" part—shifts the rhythm. It becomes more staccato, more playful. This provides the "relief" from the heavy emotional weight of the main theme. If the whole song stayed as slow as the beginning, it would be a dirge. Arlen was a genius at using jazz-influenced structures to keep pop songs from becoming boring.
Comparing the Original to the Covers
Everyone has covered this. From Israel Kamakawiwoʻole to Ariana Grande.
But the somewhere over the rainbow original song remains the benchmark because it lacks the "performative" element of later versions. When Israel (IZ) did his version on the ukulele, he turned it into a peaceful, tropical meditation. It’s beautiful, but it's a different animal. He combined it with "What a Wonderful World," which shifts the meaning from "I wish I were somewhere else" to "I am happy where I am."
Garland’s original is about the ache of not being there yet.
Then you have the 1961 Carnegie Hall version. By then, Garland’s life had been through the ringer. When she sang it then, it wasn't a song about a girl on a farm; it was a song about a woman who had seen the "rainbow" and realized it wasn't all it was cracked up to be. The 1939 original is pure. It’s the only version that actually belongs to Dorothy Gale.
The Lost Outtakes
There was a reprise of the song that was filmed but cut. It happened while Dorothy was locked in the Wicked Witch’s castle. She was crying, singing a much slower, sadder version. It was deemed too depressing for the final cut, which was probably a good call for the film's pacing. However, you can find the audio on various deluxe soundtrack releases.
Hearing a terrified girl sing those lyrics while a sand-timer runs out on her life adds a dark, gritty layer to the song that most people never experience.
The Cultural Legacy That Won't Quit
You see this song everywhere. It’s in Schindler's List (ironically and devastatingly). It’s in The Wizard of Oz (obviously). It has been played at funerals, weddings, and protests.
The Library of Congress put it in the National Recording Registry for a reason. It is the "Star-Spangled Banner" of the human heart.
- Authenticity: It doesn't try to be cool.
- Simplicity: A child can hum the main hook.
- Complexity: A professional singer can spend a lifetime mastering the breathing required for the long phrases.
The song is basically a Rorschach test. What you hear in it depends on where you are in your life. If you're a kid, it’s about magic. If you’re an adult, it’s about the realization that "over the rainbow" might just be a metaphor for a peace of mind that is hard to find.
💡 You might also like: James Purefoy Movies and Shows: Why He is the Best Actor You Almost Missed
How to Properly Appreciate the 1939 Original
To really "get" this song, you have to stop listening to it as a cliché. We’ve heard it so many times it’s become background noise.
Try this: Put on high-quality headphones. Find the remastered 1939 soundtrack. Close your eyes. Don't think about the memes or the lunchboxes or the Ruby Slipper exhibits at the Smithsonian.
Listen to the breath Garland takes right before the final "Why, oh why can't I?"
That tiny gasp for air is more human than 99% of the music produced today. It’s the sound of a person actually feeling the words. That is why the somewhere over the rainbow original song will still be played 100 years from now.
Actionable Insights for Music Lovers
If you want to dive deeper into the history of this masterpiece, start by tracking down the "Jolson" version. Al Jolson was one of the first to record it outside the film, and it’s a wild contrast to Garland’s delivery.
Next, look up the "introductory verse" lyrics and try to read them as a poem. It changes the context of the song from a fantasy to a survival tactic for someone living through a "hopeless jumble."
Finally, check out the sheet music. Even if you don't play an instrument, seeing the physical "jump" of the notes on the page gives you a visual representation of the hope Arlen was trying to bake into the melody. Understanding the architecture makes the emotional impact even stronger.
Stay away from the over-processed, "pop" radio edits if you want the real experience. The hiss and crackle of the 1939 recording isn't a flaw; it's part of the story. It’s a transmission from a different world, sent by a 16-year-old girl who had no idea she was about to change music forever.