You've probably been told the same thing since second grade: eat less, move more. It sounds so logical. If you treat your body like a simple ledger, you just need to balance the "calories in" against the "calories out" to stay thin. But then you look at the actual data, or maybe your own bathroom scale, and things start to get messy. Gary Taubes wrote the Why We Get Fat book specifically because that "logic" wasn't working for a huge portion of the population. He didn't just want to offer another diet plan; he wanted to dismantle the entire way we think about human metabolism.
It's a heavy lift.
Most doctors will tell you that obesity is a choice, or at least a failure of willpower. Taubes argues the exact opposite. He suggests that we don't get fat because we overeat; we overeat because our fat tissue is being signaled to grow. It’s a subtle shift in perspective, but it changes everything. Think about a teenager hitting a growth spurt. They eat like a horse because they are growing. They aren't growing because they eat like a horse. The hormone signals come first.
The Calorie Myth and the Why We Get Fat Book
The central villain in Taubes’ narrative isn't the person eating the donut. It’s the hormone insulin. For decades, the nutritional establishment has leaned on the First Law of Thermodynamics—energy cannot be created or destroyed—to explain weight gain. If you eat 3,000 calories and burn 2,500, those 500 calories have to go somewhere. Right? Well, sure. But that doesn't tell us why it happens.
In the Why We Get Fat book, Taubes points out that telling someone they are fat because they eat too much is like telling someone a room is crowded because more people entered than left. It’s technically true, but it explains nothing about why the people are there in the first place. Are they there for a party? A meeting? Is the exit door locked?
The "exit door" for our fat cells is regulated by insulin. When insulin levels are high, fat is trapped in the cells. It can't get out to be used for fuel. So, your brain thinks you’re starving even though you have 30 pounds of energy sitting on your hips. You get hungry. You eat. The cycle repeats.
Why some people stay thin naturally
We all know that one person. The one who eats pizza and beer every night and looks like a distance runner. If calories were the only thing that mattered, they should be gaining weight. But their internal chemistry is different. Their insulin sensitivity is high. Their body knows exactly what to do with a surge of glucose. For the rest of us, even a small amount of refined carbohydrates can trigger a hormonal cascade that screams "STORE ENERGY NOW."
Taubes leans heavily on historical research, citing studies from the early 20th century that modern nutritionists mostly forgot. He looks at populations like the Pima Indians or various cultures in the 1960s where obesity skyrocketed despite a lack of "processed" junk food. What changed? Usually, the introduction of white flour and sugar.
The Insulin Hypothesis Explained Simply
Basically, carbs make you fat.
That’s the blunt version. But specifically, it's the refined stuff. Think white bread, pasta, sugary cereal, and fruit juice. These foods have a high glycemic index, meaning they spike your blood sugar almost instantly. Your pancreas sees this spike and floods your system with insulin to keep your blood from becoming toxic.
Now, here is the kicker: insulin is the primary fat-storage hormone.
As long as insulin is circulating in your blood, you cannot burn body fat. It’s biochemically impossible. Your body is in storage mode, not burning mode. If you eat six small "balanced" meals a day, all containing some carbs, your insulin stays elevated from breakfast until you go to sleep. You never give your body a chance to tap into its reserves.
Honestly, it's kinda frustrating. You're doing what the "experts" say—eating frequently, choosing "low fat" options—but you're actually keeping yourself in a metabolic cage.
The role of the "Fat-Soluble" internal environment
It isn't just about what you eat today. It’s about how your fat cells have been "programmed" over years. Taubes talks about Adiposity. This is the idea that some people are just more predisposed to store fat because of their genetics or their history of carbohydrate intake.
- Your body's set point is governed by the brain (specifically the hypothalamus).
- Leptin, the "I'm full" hormone, usually tells the brain to stop eating.
- High insulin can actually cause "leptin resistance."
- Your brain never gets the message that you have enough fat stored.
- You feel lethargic because your energy is being diverted to fat cells instead of your muscles.
What the Critics Say (Because Nuance Matters)
Taubes isn't without his detractors. The "Why We Get Fat" book caused a massive stir in the scientific community. Researchers like Kevin Hall have conducted metabolic ward studies suggesting that, at the end of the day, if you strictly control calories, people lose weight regardless of the carb-to-fat ratio.
But there’s a massive difference between a locked metabolic ward and real life.
In real life, hunger matters. Satiety matters. If a low-carb diet allows you to naturally eat 500 fewer calories without feeling like you're starving, then the "hormonal" approach has won the practical battle, even if the "calorie" approach wins the laboratory battle.
Many critics also point out that some cultures, like the Okinawans or the pre-industrialized Chinese, ate very high-carb diets (mostly rice and sweet potatoes) and stayed incredibly lean. This suggests that "carbs" aren't a monolith. Fiber matters. The presence of sugar—specifically fructose—matters a lot more than the presence of starch.
The Fructose Factor
Taubes spends a good amount of time looking at sugar. Not just any sugar, but sucrose and high-fructose corn syrup. Fructose is metabolized almost entirely in the liver. It doesn't raise insulin immediately, but it leads to fatty liver disease and insulin resistance over time.
🔗 Read more: San Antonio Air Quality Today: Why the "Good" Rating Isn't the Whole Story
It’s the long-term poison.
If you want to understand why obesity rates started to climb in the late 1970s, look at the "low fat" craze. When food companies took the fat out of crackers, yogurt, and salad dressing, it tasted like cardboard. To fix the flavor, they added sugar. Tons of it. We traded healthy fats for metabolic triggers.
Why exercise won't save you
This is the most controversial part of the Why We Get Fat book. Taubes argues that exercise doesn't actually help you lose weight.
Wait. What?
He doesn't say exercise is bad for you. It's great for your heart, your mood, and your muscle tone. But he argues that "working up an appetite" is a real thing. If you burn 300 calories on a treadmill, your body's homeostatic mechanisms will likely drive you to eat 300 more calories later that day. You can't outrun a bad diet because your biology won't let you.
Practical Steps Based on the Taubes Philosophy
If you're reading this and thinking, "Okay, so what do I actually do?" the advice is pretty straightforward, even if it's hard to follow in a world filled with bagels.
The goal is to lower your insulin levels. Period.
- Cut the "White" Carbs: Eliminate flour, sugar, and potatoes. These are the biggest insulin triggers.
- Don't Fear Fat: Replace those carb calories with healthy fats like avocado, olive oil, butter, and fatty cuts of meat. Fat doesn't stimulate insulin.
- Ignore the "Low Fat" Labels: Usually, "low fat" means "high sugar." Look at the back of the box, not the front.
- Limit Fruit: Modern fruit has been bred to be much sweeter than what our ancestors ate. Treat it like a dessert, not a health food staple.
- Eat until you're full: Don't count calories. If you're eating the right things (protein and fat), your body's natural satiety signals will eventually kick back in.
It takes time. Your body has to switch from being a "sugar burner" to a "fat burner." This transition—often called fat-adaptation—can take a few weeks and might leave you feeling a bit "keto-flu" sluggish at first.
The Bottom Line on Why We Get Fat
The Why We Get Fat book by Gary Taubes is essentially a call for a paradigm shift. It asks us to stop blaming the victim. Obesity isn't a character flaw or a result of sloth. It's a hormonal disorder. Specifically, it's a disorder of fat accumulation triggered by the quality of the carbohydrates we eat.
Whether you agree with every single scientific claim he makes, the core message is hard to ignore: our current nutritional advice has failed. We are fatter and sicker than ever. Moving away from the "calorie" obsession and toward a "hormonal" understanding of food might be the only way out of the epidemic.
Actionable Takeaways
If you want to apply these insights today, start by tracking how you feel after meals. Do you get a "food coma" after a big bowl of pasta? That’s an insulin spike. Are you hungry again two hours after eating a "healthy" bowl of oatmeal? That’s your blood sugar crashing.
Switch your breakfast to eggs and bacon (no toast) and see how long you stay full. Most people find they can go until 2:00 PM without even thinking about food. That is the power of keeping insulin low. It unlocks your own body fat to be used as fuel.
💡 You might also like: 170 Pounds to kg: Why This Specific Number Pops Up Everywhere
- Audit your pantry. Toss anything where sugar (or any "-ose" word) is in the first five ingredients.
- Focus on "Whole" Foods. If it doesn't have a label (like a piece of steak or a head of broccoli), it's probably safe.
- Prioritize Protein. It’s the most satiating macronutrient and has a minimal effect on insulin compared to carbs.
- Experiment with Fasting. Once you are fat-adapted, skipping a meal becomes easy. This gives your insulin levels a massive break and allows for deeper fat burning.
Understanding the "why" behind weight gain is the first step to reversing it. It isn't about eating less; it's about eating right for your unique biology.