You know that feeling when a song just stops you in your tracks? It’s not just the melody. It’s the weight behind it. When you hear It Is Well With My Soul by Wintley Phipps, you aren't just hearing a hymn. You’re hearing a masterclass in vocal resonance and spiritual conviction that feels like it’s vibrating right in your chest.
Most people know the song. It’s a funeral staple, a Sunday morning go-to, and a literal lifeline for people going through the absolute worst moments of their lives. But Phipps does something to it. He has this bass-baritone voice that feels like old mahogany—rich, deep, and incredibly sturdy. Honestly, in a world of over-produced, pitch-corrected tracks, there’s something raw about his delivery that makes the 19th-century lyrics feel like they were written yesterday.
It’s heavy. It’s hopeful. It’s a bit haunting.
The Story Most People Miss
Before we talk about Wintley’s pipes, we have to talk about Horatio Spafford. You can’t separate the performance from the pain that birthed the lyrics. Spafford was a wealthy Chicago lawyer who lost basically everything. First, the Great Chicago Fire of 1871 wiped out his real estate investments. Then, a couple of years later, he sent his wife and four daughters ahead of him on a ship to Europe.
The ship sank.
His wife, Anna, survived and sent that famous telegram: "Saved alone." Spafford hopped on the next boat to find her. As they passed the spot where his daughters drowned, he didn’t write a song about anger. He wrote "It Is Well With My Soul."
When Wintley Phipps performs this, he isn't just singing notes. He understands that specific gravity. Phipps has spent decades performing for Presidents—every single one from Jimmy Carter to Barack Obama—and he brings that same level of "state-of-the-soul" importance to this hymn. He’s not trying to show off his range, even though his range is massive. He’s trying to tell you that peace is possible when your life is a literal shipwreck.
Why the Wintley Phipps Version is the Gold Standard
If you go on YouTube right now and search for this song, Phipps’ performances always have millions of views. Why? Because he doesn't rush. He lets the silence breathe.
Most singers try to make hymns "poppy" or overly operatic. Phipps keeps it grounded in the Black spiritual tradition while honoring the classical roots of the composition. His vibrato is controlled. It’s not shaky; it’s resonant. Scientists actually talk about the "singer’s formant," which is a specific frequency range that allows a voice to be heard over a full orchestra. Phipps has that naturally. When he hits those low notes on "it is well," you don't just hear the sound; you feel the air in the room change.
It’s kinda crazy how one voice can do that.
He often prefaces his performances by explaining the "Black notes" or the pentatonic scale. He’s a scholar of music history as much as he is a singer. He argues that the spirituals and the blues—and even the way he interprets hymns like this—carry the DNA of African slaves who used music to survive. So, when he sings a song written by a white lawyer from Chicago, he’s blending these two powerful histories of suffering and resilience.
The Technical Magic of a Bass-Baritone
Let's get nerdy for a second. Phipps is a bass-baritone. This is a specific vocal type that sits between a true bass and a lyrical baritone. It means he has the floor-shaking lows but can still reach those emotive middle-high notes without sounding strained.
👉 See also: Venture Bros When to Watch Specials: The Only Order That Actually Makes Sense
In his famous renditions, he often starts almost in a whisper.
Then he builds.
By the time he gets to the "And Lord, haste the day when the faith shall be sight" verse, the power is overwhelming.
He uses a technique called chest voice for almost the entire duration. This isn't that airy, "heady" sound you hear in modern worship music. This is grounded. It’s foundational. It’s the difference between a sapling and an oak tree.
A Performance That Transcends Religion
You don't even have to be religious to get chills from It Is Well With My Soul by Wintley Phipps. That’s the mark of true art. It taps into a universal human experience: the need for composure in the face of chaos.
Phipps has founded the U.S. Dream Academy, working with children of incarcerated parents. He sees trauma every day. When he stands on a stage—whether it’s at a Billy Graham crusade or a small church—he’s singing to people who are currently in their own "Chicago Fire."
One thing that’s really interesting is how he handles the tempo. Most choirs sing this song like a march. One, two, three, four. It’s brisk. Phipps treats it like a prayer. He stretches the vowels. He lingers on the word "soul." It makes the listener sit with the words rather than just humming along to a familiar tune.
Common Misconceptions About the Song
- "It’s a sad song." Not really. It’s a song about transcending sadness. If you listen to Phipps’ inflection, there’s a triumph in the lower registers.
- "Wintley Phipps wrote it." Nope. He’s just arguably the best to ever do it. The music was actually composed by Philip Bliss, who named the tune "Ville du Havre" after the ship that sank.
- "He only sings it one way." If you watch recordings from the 1980s versus the 2020s, his voice has aged like fine wine. It’s darker now. More textured. There’s more "life" in the gravel of his tone.
How to Truly Appreciate the Track
To get the full effect of It Is Well With My Soul by Wintley Phipps, you can't listen to it through tiny phone speakers. You just can't. The low-end frequencies of his voice get totally cut off.
You need a decent pair of headphones or a speaker with a bit of a sub.
Close your eyes. Listen to the way he breathes before the phrase "Thou hast taught me to say." That breath is intentional. It’s the sound of someone gathering their strength.
He’s also a master of the "slur," but not in a messy way. He slides into notes from below, a hallmark of the gospel tradition, which adds an emotional "tug" to the melody. It feels like he’s pulling the notes up from the ground.
The Impact on Modern Culture
It’s weird to think a hymn from the 1800s could go viral in the 2020s, but Phipps makes it happen. His version is a mainstay on "Calm" or "Peaceful" playlists. In an era where everyone is anxious and the world feels like it’s constantly on fire, this specific performance acts as a sort of sonic weighted blanket.
People are tired.
People are stressed.
Wintley’s voice says, "Hey, it’s gonna be okay."
He doesn't ignore the "billows" or the "trials." He acknowledges them. That’s the key. AI-generated music or overly polished pop stars often try to bypass the pain to get to the "happy" part. Phipps sits in the pain with you, and then he leads you out of it.
Actionable Ways to Experience This Music
If you're looking to dive deeper into this specific vibe, don't just stop at one YouTube clip.
- Listen to the Carnegie Hall Recording: There is a specific resonance in that hall that captures the overtones of his voice better than any studio booth ever could.
- Compare it to his "Amazing Grace" lecture: To understand how he sings "It Is Well," you have to hear him explain the pentatonic scale (the "black notes" on the piano). It explains the soulful, mourning quality he brings to traditional hymns.
- Read the Spafford Biography: While listening, keep the image of the Atlantic Ocean in your mind. It changes the way you hear the "rolling sea" metaphors in the second verse.
- Check out the Gaither Homecoming versions: Phipps often performed with the Gaithers. These versions are a bit more "produced," but the chemistry between him and the live audience adds a different layer of energy.
Ultimately, It Is Well With My Soul by Wintley Phipps isn't just a song you hear; it's a song you endure and then emerge from. It’s a reminder that your internal state doesn't have to be a victim of your external circumstances.
Next time you’re feeling completely overwhelmed, put on some headphones, find the highest-quality version of Phipps you can, and just let that bass-baritone voice do the heavy lifting for a few minutes. You’ll find that even if the world isn't well, for those five minutes, your soul might be.