You know the feeling. You're walking down a side street in a city you barely know, and you spot it. It’s a door that looks like it hasn’t been painted since the Reagan administration. There’s no neon sign. No velvet rope. Just a flickering fluorescent light and the smell of something frying that makes your stomach do a happy little flip. You’ve found a hole in the wall.
But wait. What does that actually mean?
Most people use the term as a backhanded compliment for a restaurant that looks like a dump but serves elite tacos. But if you’re in London, you might be looking for an ATM. If you’re a historian, you’re thinking about literal cavities in medieval fortifications. Language is messy like that. Honestly, the term has evolved from a literal architectural description into a badge of honor for the "un-Instagrammable" gems of the world. It’s about the soul of a place over its aesthetic.
The unexpected history of the hole in the wall
The phrase didn’t start with food. It started with necessity. Back in the day—we’re talking 19th-century England—the "hole in the wall" was often a literal opening in a building where goods were traded or sold without the customer ever actually entering the premises. Think of it as the great-great-grandfather of the drive-thru window, minus the car and the crackly intercom.
One of the most famous historical references involves the Hole in the Wall pub in London, located near Waterloo. Legend has it the name came from a hole literally knocked through the wall of the neighboring Debtors' Prison so that people could pass food and booze to the inmates. It wasn’t a marketing slogan. It was a lifeline.
Then you have the financial side of things. If you grew up in the UK or Commonwealth countries, a "hole in the wall" is simply an Automated Teller Machine (ATM). Barclays installed the first one in Enfield in 1967. It was quite literally a machine embedded in the wall of the bank. To this day, if a Brit tells you they need to find a hole in the wall, they aren't looking for dim sum. They’re looking for twenty quid.
But for most of us, the term has become synonymous with a specific type of hospitality. It’s the business that ignores the "curb appeal" rulebook.
Why we’re obsessed with these hidden spots
There is a psychological thrill in finding a place that feels like a secret. In a world of corporate chains where every Starbucks looks exactly like the one three miles down the road, the hole in the wall offers something rare: unpredictability.
✨ Don't miss: Is It Safe to Eat Raw Salmon? What You Need to Know Before Your Next Sushi Night
These places don't have PR teams. They don't have "vibes" curated by an interior design firm in Brooklyn. Usually, the decor consists of a faded calendar, some mismatched chairs, and a menu that’s been photocopied so many times the letters are starting to blur.
And that’s exactly why we love them.
There’s a perceived authenticity there. We assume that if a business can survive while looking that rough, the product must be incredible. It’s a survival of the fittest situation. If your storefront is ugly and your food is mediocre, you go out of business in six months. If your storefront is ugly but you’ve been there for thirty years? You’re probably serving the best pho in the tri-state area.
Spotting a true hole in the wall (The Checklist)
Not every small business qualifies. A tiny boutique in a high-rent district isn't a hole in the wall—it's just a small shop. To hit the criteria, you usually need a few specific "red flags" that are actually green flags:
- Location, Location, Nowhere: They are usually tucked away. Basements, alleys, or those weird strips between a dry cleaner and an auto body shop.
- The "One Thing" Rule: True gems usually do one thing perfectly. They don't have a ten-page menu. They have one specific dish that everyone orders.
- Cash is King (Usually): While this is changing in 2026, many of these spots still prefer cash or have a "card machine is broken" sign that has been there since 2019.
- Zero Marketing: If they have a TikTok manager, they aren't a hole in the wall. They’re a concept. A real hole in the wall is found via word-of-mouth or a very specific type of Yelp review that mentions the "grumpy but efficient" service.
The gentrification of the "Hole in the Wall" aesthetic
Here is the irony: the aesthetic of the "hidden gem" has become so popular that developers are now paying millions to make new restaurants look old and cramped. You’ll see "speakeasies" located behind fake refrigerator doors in posh neighborhoods.
Is a $25 cocktail served in a basement a hole in the wall? Probably not.
The distinction lies in the intent. A real hole in the wall is small because that’s all the owners could afford, or all they needed. It’s functional. The moment the "rundown" look becomes a conscious design choice, the magic sort of evaporates. It becomes a theme park version of authenticity.
Why the term is actually a bit controversial
We should probably talk about the "middle-class gaze" for a second. Sometimes, calling a family-owned immigrant business a "hole in the wall" can feel a little patronizing. To the person who owns it, it’s not a "hole"—it’s their livelihood, their kitchen, and their community hub.
Food critics like the late Anthony Bourdain were masters at navigating this. Bourdain didn't look down on these places; he elevated them. He understood that the best food in the world rarely happens under a chandelier. It happens where the heat is high and the margins are thin. When you call a place a hole in the wall, make sure it’s with respect for the hustle, not a commentary on the neighborhood.
Global variations: What to look for abroad
If you’re traveling, the "hole" looks different depending on where you land. In Japan, you might look for Yokocho—narrow alleys packed with tiny izakayas that barely seat five people. In Mexico, it’s the puesto on a street corner where the pastor meat is carved with surgical precision.
In every culture, there is a version of the "under the radar" spot. These are the places that keep a city’s culture alive when the main streets get taken over by global brands. They are the friction that makes a city interesting.
How to find your next favorite spot
Finding these places requires a bit of "un-learning" how we use the internet. If you sort by "top rated" on a major travel app, you’re going to find the places that are good at gaming the algorithm. To find the real stuff, you have to dig deeper.
- Watch the workers. At 11:00 AM or 3:00 PM, where are the local taxi drivers or construction crews eating? They know where the value is. They don't have time for fluff.
- Look for the "ghost" presence. Sometimes the best spots have a 3.5-star rating. Why? Because some people complain about the lack of parking or the fact that the waiter didn't smile enough. Ignore those people. Look for the reviews that say, "The place looks sketchy, but the carnitas changed my life."
- Walk without a map. Pick a direction and go three blocks off the main drag. Look for the signs that aren't in English (or whatever the primary tourist language is).
Ultimately, a hole in the wall isn't about the physical structure. It’s about a refusal to compromise on the product for the sake of the presentation. It’s a reminder that some of the best things in life don't come in pretty packaging.
Next time you see a door that looks like it's seen better days and a window that hasn't been washed lately, don't keep walking. Pull the handle. You might just find the best meal of your life.
Practical Steps for Your Next Outing:
- Check the Health Rating: In many US cities, an "A" in the window is non-negotiable, even for the grittiest-looking spots. Authenticity shouldn't mean food poisoning.
- Bring Small Bills: Don't be the person trying to pay for a $4 taco with a $100 bill at a place that clearly doesn't have a safe.
- Lower Your Expectations for "Service": You aren't paying for someone to fold your napkin. You're paying for the food. Be polite, be quick, and stay out of the way of the regulars.
- Share the Love (Quietly): If you find a true gem, tell your friends, but maybe don't blast it to 50,000 people on TikTok if you want to be able to get a seat there next week.