The buzz around the Racecourse Ground isn’t just about Hollywood anymore. It’s about survival and the cold, hard reality of the English Football League hierarchy. When you look at Wrexham AFC vs Rotherham United FC, you’re looking at two clubs moving in completely opposite directions, though their paths crossed in a way that basically defined the 2024–25 League One season.
Honestly, people still talk about the "glamour" of the Red Dragons. But for Steve Evans and the Millers, Wrexham has become a bit of a nightmare scenario.
🔗 Read more: Bobby Orr: Why the Number 4 Still Matters More Than the Stats
The Match That Changed the Trajectory
Back in March 2025, everything felt like it was on the line. Wrexham was chasing that elusive third consecutive promotion—something no team had ever done in the EFL. Rotherham? They were just trying to find some semblance of consistency after falling out of the Championship.
It was Sam Smith. On his 27th birthday, no less.
The game itself was a bit of a slog until the 48th minute. Jay Rodriguez—whose experience has been massive for Phil Parkinson—flicked a header perfectly into Smith's path. Smith didn't blink. He slotted it past Dillon Phillips, and the STōK Cae Ras absolutely erupted. That 1-0 win wasn’t just three points; it was the moment Wrexham realized they actually belonged at the top of League One.
Rotherham pushed. They had 55% of the possession and more shots, but Arthur Okonkwo was a wall. His save against Mallik Wilks in the first half? Absolute world-class. It’s the kind of performance that makes you realize why Wrexham fought so hard to keep him.
Why the Gap is Widening in 2026
Fast forward to right now, January 2026. The landscape has shifted.
Wrexham is currently sitting 9th in the EFL Championship. Yeah, you read that right. They did it. They’re competing with the likes of Coventry and Middlesbrough while sitting on 40 points from 26 games. They aren't just "participating"; they are a genuine threat to the play-off spots.
Meanwhile, Rotherham United is struggling.
The Millers are currently 22nd in League One. It’s a tough pill to swallow for a club that used to be the ultimate "yo-yo" team between the top two tiers. They’ve only managed 24 points from 24 games this season. When you compare that to Wrexham’s rise, it’s a sobering look at how quickly momentum can vanish in English football.
Critical Stats Comparison (2025-26 Season)
Wrexham AFC (Championship):
✨ Don't miss: How Computer Picks College Football Actually Work (And Why They Still Miss)
- Record: 10 wins, 10 draws, 6 losses.
- Goals Scored: 38.
- Key Man: Kieffer Moore (10 goals already this season).
- Current Form: Recently drew 3-3 in a thriller against Nottingham Forest.
Rotherham United (League One):
- Record: 6 wins, 6 draws, 12 losses.
- Goals Scored: 22.
- Key Man: Joe Powell (Leading the creative stats, but lacks support).
- Current Form: Coming off a 2-0 loss to Peterborough.
The Tactical Headache
Phil Parkinson has built a squad that’s surprisingly balanced. People expected them to just buy their way up, but the recruitment has been smart. Bringing in guys like George Dobson and Matty James provided a spine that Rotherham just couldn't break down.
When these two teams met, Rotherham tried to play a 4-3-1-2, hoping to overwhelm the midfield. It didn't work. Wrexham’s 3-5-2 (or 5-3-2 when they’re under the cosh) is just too disciplined. Max Cleworth has grown into one of the best young defenders in the country, and he basically had Jonson Clarke-Harris in his pocket during their last encounter.
Rotherham’s problem is the "identity crisis." They have talent—players like Jonson Clarke-Harris and Sam Nombe are proven scorers—but the service isn't there. They look like a team playing with the weight of the world on their shoulders, while Wrexham plays like they have nothing to lose.
Misconceptions About the Rivalry
There's this idea that Wrexham is just a "rich" club bullying the league. Honestly, it’s more about the culture. If you look at the Rotherham match, Wrexham won because they were fitter and more clinical. They didn't outspend Rotherham by some crazy margin in that specific window; they just spent better.
Another thing people get wrong: Rotherham isn't a bad team. They are a "frozen" team. They are stuck in a cycle of managerial changes and tactical shifts that haven't quite clicked. Steve Evans has his work cut out for him if they want to avoid the drop to League Two, which would be a catastrophe for a club of their stature.
What to Watch for Next
If you're following these two, keep an eye on the January transfer window. Wrexham is likely looking for one more creative spark to push for the Championship play-offs. They've been linked with some serious talent, and with the "Deadpool" money still flowing, they can afford to be picky.
✨ Don't miss: Independiente del Valle vs Once Caldas: What Really Happened in the Sudamericana
Rotherham needs a miracle. Or at least a very good striker who can turn those 0-0 draws and 1-0 losses into wins. They are currently three points adrift of safety in League One.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Analysts:
- Watch the Wing-Backs: For Wrexham, Ryan Longman and Sebastian Revan are the engines. If they are shut down, Wrexham struggles to progress the ball.
- Rotherham's Defensive Lapses: The Millers have a habit of conceding early in the second half. If you're betting or analyzing, look at the 45-60 minute window.
- The Okonkwo Factor: If Wrexham ever loses Arthur Okonkwo to a Premier League side, their defensive stats will take a massive hit. He’s arguably their most important asset.
Wrexham’s rise is the story everyone knows, but Rotherham’s struggle is the story people should be paying attention to. It’s a warning of how thin the margins are in the EFL. One minute you're fighting for the Championship, the next you're staring at the basement of League One.
To stay ahead of the curve on Wrexham’s Championship push, track their expected goals (xG) against top-six opposition. They’ve been over-performing their xGA (Expected Goals Against), which suggests their defense—and Okonkwo—is doing some heavy lifting that might not be sustainable forever. For Rotherham, the focus must be on home form at the New York Stadium; without a win in their next three home fixtures, the drop to League Two becomes a statistical probability.