Ever wonder what happens when the cameras stop rolling on a "life-changing" reality show? If you binged the Roku series produced by John Cena, you’ve probably spent some time Googling the cast of wwe next gen to see who actually made it and who vanished into the indie wrestling void.
Honestly, the show felt different than your average "Tough Enough" reboot. It was raw. It focused on the WrestleMania 39 tryouts and the brutal transition to the WWE Performance Center (PC) in Orlando. But wrestling is a business that moves at a breakneck pace. By the time the show aired in April 2024, half the people you were rooting for were already fighting for their jobs—or out of them.
The Standouts and the Contracts
Watching Triple H hand out contracts in the "Contract Mania" episode felt like a peak behind the curtain we rarely get. It wasn't just about who could do a backflip; it was about who didn't crumble under the gaze of Matt Bloom and Shawn Michaels.
Jonah Niesenbaum was arguably the "main character" of the docuseries. He had that Ivy League background and a look that screamed "future world champion." He’s still in the mix, now wrestling under the name Cutler James. You’ll see him popping up on NXT Level Up, slowly finding his footing in a ring that’s a lot less forgiving than a TV set.
Then you have the powerhouse athletes like Darrell Mason. The guy was a DII National Champion wrestler. On the show, they called him "Deebo," and for good reason. He was one of the blue-chip prospects everyone expected to rocket to the top. However, in a move that shocked the Reddit sleuths, Darrell was part of a wave of releases in early 2024, right around the time the show was gaining steam. It’s a harsh reminder that being a great athlete doesn't always translate to the weird, specific world of sports entertainment.
The Women Who Stole the Show
The women's side of the cast of wwe next gen provided some of the most emotional beats of the series. Emma Diaz (real name Emma Halverson) came from a rugby background and had that "never say die" energy. She made her in-ring debut at an NXT live event during a Halloween Rumble, but like Darrell, she was released from her contract in May 2024.
Breanna Covington, or "Bree" as she was known on the show, dealt with a massive amount of family pressure and injury scares. She was a fan favorite because she felt the most "human." She survived the initial cuts and made the move to Orlando, proving that the coaches saw something in her beyond just a physical frame.
The Reality of the "Next Gen" Grind
Wrestling fans are used to seeing the finished product—the pyro, the entrance music, the scripted promos. This show forced us to look at the "bubble" athletes.
- Julian Baldi: The Italian-born football player who had the "it" factor. He was actually one of the lucky ones who got to debut in front of a live NXT audience during the series finale. Unfortunately, he was also released in the 2024 spring cleaning.
- Keyshawn Leflore: A former cheerleader with incredible explosiveness. His story was tragic, involving the loss of his father during filming. He stayed with the company for a while after the show, but ultimately parted ways.
- Olena Sadovska: The Ukrainian athlete whose story was framed by the conflict back home. She represented the international reach WWE is currently obsessed with.
It's kinda wild. You watch eight episodes of someone's life, you see them cry, you see them bleed, and then a year later, they're back at a regular 9-to-5 or working a high-school gym for fifty bucks. That’s the reality the show hinted at but couldn't fully capture.
Why Some Made It and Others Didn't
If you look at the cast of wwe next gen today, the success rate is actually pretty standard for a WWE tryout. Out of 50-plus recruits who started in Los Angeles, only a handful are still signed.
The ones who are still around, like Cutler James (Jonah Niesenbaum) and Ezekiel Balogun, share a common trait: adaptability. The coaches, especially Matt Bloom, were looking for "coachability." If you talked back—like Brayden Ray sometimes did—you were on a one-way flight home.
Brayden was the guy everyone loved to hate. He had the size, but his attitude in the Los Angeles segments was a textbook example of how not to act at a WWE tryout. He eventually showed a "new character" at The Comedy Store promo session, but the damage was mostly done.
The Coaches and Legends
We can't talk about the cast without mentioning the "judges."
💡 You might also like: Brian Eno An Ending (Ascent) Explained: Why This 4-Minute Track Still Haunts Us
- Shawn Michaels: The "Heartbreak Kid" was surprisingly blunt. He didn't sugarcoat the fact that most of these people wouldn't make a dime in this business.
- Matt Bloom: As the head of the PC, he played the "bad cop" role perfectly. He’s the one who has to break these athletes down to see if they’re worth the investment.
- Big E and Bianca Belair: They served as the "inspiration" cast, showing the recruits what life looks like at the top of the mountain.
What’s Next for the WWE Next Gen Stars?
If you're still following the cast of wwe next gen, your best bet is to keep an eye on the independent circuit. Released talents like Emma Diaz and Julian Baldi have the name recognition from the Roku show to command decent bookings on the indies.
For the ones still in the WWE system, the road is even harder. They are competing with the newest NIL (Next In Line) recruits—Olympic gold medalists and top-tier college stars—who are coming in every few months.
Basically, the "Next Gen" was just the first hurdle. The real show happens every day at 8:00 AM at the Performance Center when the cameras are off and John Cena isn't there to give a motivational speech.
Actionable Insights for Fans:
- Follow the Socials: Most of the released cast members are active on Instagram and X (Twitter). If you liked their story, that’s where you’ll find where they are wrestling next.
- Watch NXT Level Up: This is the "B-show" for NXT where the Next Gen survivors like Cutler James get their reps. It’s the best place to see their actual wrestling progress.
- Check Indie Results: Keep an eye on promotions like GCW or TNA, as WWE often keeps a "soft" door open for talent they liked but didn't have room for at the time.