Ever feel like your concept of the divine is basically just a projection of your 10th-grade principal? Or maybe a celestial vending machine? It’s a common problem. Honestly, most of us carry around these mental "idols" without even realizing it. Back in 1952, a guy named J.B. Phillips—the same scholar who did the famous New Testament paraphrase—decided he’d had enough of people living with shriveled-up versions of faith. He wrote Your God is Too Small, and decades later, the book still feels like a bucket of ice water to the face.
It's short. It's punchy. It’s also deeply uncomfortable because it calls out the tiny, cramped boxes we try to fit the infinite into.
Phillips wasn't interested in dry theology. He was interested in the psychological baggage that makes people walk away from religion. He realized that most people don't actually reject "God" in the ultimate sense; they reject a caricature that’s too small to be worth believing in. If your version of the creator can’t handle a physics textbook or a personal tragedy, Phillips would argue that your god is too small to be real.
The Mental Idols We Carry
We all have them. Phillips identifies these "unreal gods" that we construct out of our own fears and social conditioning. One of the biggest ones he hits on is the "Resident Policeman." You know the type. This is the god who exists solely to make you feel guilty about having fun or to catch you in a mistake. It’s a conscience that’s been over-inflated until it looks like a deity.
Then there’s the "Grand Old Man." This is the sentimental, slightly out-of-touch grandfather figure who lives in the clouds and doesn't really understand the modern world. He’s nice, sure, but he’s utterly irrelevant to your career, your sex life, or the global economy. Phillips points out that if God is actually the creator of the universe, He can't be "out of touch" with anything. He’s the one who invented the laws of physics and the complexities of human emotion in the first place.
🔗 Read more: Mount Prospect IL Weather Explained (Simply)
It's kinda wild how many people still struggle with the "Pale Galilean" image—the idea that being spiritual means being weak, sickly, or devoid of any real "red-blooded" life. Phillips pushes back hard against this. He suggests that if we actually look at the historical Jesus, we don't find a frail, wispy figure. We find someone with immense strength and vitality.
Why We Build Small Gods
Why do we do this? It’s safer. A small god is manageable. A god who fits in your pocket doesn't ask much of you. You can predict what a "Resident Policeman" will say, and you can ignore a "Grand Old Man." But a God who is truly infinite? That’s terrifying. It means we aren't in control.
Phillips argues that our imagination is often the bottleneck. We use our limited human experiences to define something that is, by definition, beyond definition. When we do that, we end up with a "God in a Box." We take our cultural preferences, our political leanings, and our personal hang-ups, and we wrap them in a divine robe.
The Breakthrough of the "Big" God
So, what’s the alternative? Phillips doesn't just tear down our idols; he tries to point toward a bigger reality. He talks about God as the "Focused God." This is the idea that while we can’t grasp the totality of the infinite, we can see it clearly through the lens of Christ. It’s like trying to look at the sun—you can’t do it directly without going blind, but you can see the light reflected in the world around you.
The book suggests that a healthy view of the divine should be able to incorporate everything we know about science and the vastness of the cosmos. If the James Webb Telescope shows us galaxies millions of light-years away, and your theology can't handle that scale, then Your God is Too Small. Phillips wanted people to have a faith that was robust enough to sit at the table with modern intellectuals while remaining accessible to the "common man."
One of the most profound things Phillips mentions is the idea of "God-in-a-hurry." We often view time and urgency through our own frantic human lens. We expect God to act on our schedule. But a God who spans eternity isn't rushed. That shift in perspective changes how you handle stress, waiting, and unanswered prayers. It’s not that He’s ignoring you; it’s that His perspective is literally cosmic.
Real-World Impact and Criticisms
Does the book hold up? Mostly, yes. But it’s not perfect. Some modern readers find Phillips’ language a bit dated, and his focus is very much rooted in a mid-century Western context. He doesn't spend a lot of time on interfaith dialogue or the nuances of systematic theology. He’s a surgeon, not a philosopher. He’s there to cut away the dead tissue of bad ideas so the heart can beat again.
Critics sometimes argue that Phillips oversimplifies the "policeman" aspect of God. They suggest that moral accountability is a bigger part of the picture than he sometimes lets on. However, Phillips isn't saying God doesn't care about morality; he’s saying that God isn't defined by our petty, legalistic hang-ups. There’s a big difference between a judge who loves justice and a petty cop looking for a reason to write a ticket.
The Problem of "God as a Projection"
One of the heaviest hitters in the book is the section on "God as a Projection." This is where Phillips gets into the psychology of it all. He notes that many people’s "God" is just an idealized version of their own father. If you had a harsh, distant father, your god is probably harsh and distant. If your father was a pushover, your god is probably a cosmic doormat.
Breaking free from these projections requires a conscious effort to look at the "evidence" rather than just our feelings. Phillips points readers back to the Gospels. He wants us to see what God actually did and said in the person of Jesus, rather than what we think He should be doing.
Moving Past the Smallness
If you find yourself stuck in a rut where your faith feels boring or restrictive, you might be dealing with a "too small" god. It happens to the best of us. We get comfortable. we stop asking big questions. We start treating our religious traditions like a security blanket instead of a launchpad.
Phillips encourages a "constructive agnosticism" about the things we can't know. It’s okay to say "I don't know" about the mysteries of the universe. In fact, it’s more honest than pretending we have a 5-point plan for how the creator of the universe operates. Real faith, according to Phillips, is built on trust in a person, not a set of ironclad definitions.
Practical Steps to Expand Your View
Expanding your concept of God isn't something that happens overnight by reading a 120-page book. It’s a shift in how you process reality.
- Audit your "Inner Voice." Next time you feel a wave of religious guilt or a sense of "God is disappointed in me," ask yourself: Is this actually God, or is this the "Resident Policeman" Phillips talked about? Does this voice sound like the Jesus of the Gospels?
- Look at the Scale. Spend some time looking at images from deep space or learning about the complexity of microbiology. Remind yourself that the "God" you're talking to is responsible for all of that. It makes your daily anxieties look a bit different.
- Read the Gospels with Fresh Eyes. Try reading a modern translation (like the Phillips version or the NRSV) and pretend you’ve never heard of Jesus before. Ignore the stained-glass imagery and look at the gritty, disruptive, and often humorous person portrayed there.
- Embrace the Mystery. Stop trying to "solve" God. Allow for the fact that a being capable of creating time and space is going to be fundamentally different from a human being. It’s okay to be small in the presence of something truly big.
- Challenge Your Projections. Identify one trait you attribute to God and ask: "Where did I get this?" If the answer is "my childhood" or "my specific political party," it might be time to prune that branch.
J.B. Phillips wrote this book to set people free. He saw how many people were being crushed by the weight of a god who was too small to carry their burdens or answer their questions. By identifying these mental idols, we can start to clear the wreckage and find a faith that actually breathes. It’s not about making God bigger—He’s already infinite. It’s about making our understanding big enough to let Him in.
The next time you feel like your spiritual life is hitting a ceiling, remember that the ceiling is likely one you built yourself. It might be time to tear the roof off.
Next Steps for Readers
- Obtain a copy of the book: Whether it’s a vintage paperback or a modern reprint, read the original text of Your God is Too Small. It is remarkably fast-paced and remains one of the most accessible works of Christian apologetics ever written.
- Identify your primary "Idol": Reflect on the categories Phillips lists (the Resident Policeman, the Grand Old Man, the God-in-a-Box) and honestly identify which one most closely matches your default "gut feeling" about the divine.
- Cross-reference with the New Testament: Take one "attribute" of your current concept of God and see if it holds up against the actions and words of Jesus in the Gospel of Luke or Mark.