If you haven’t been keeping up with the Shazam! star lately, you’ve missed a massive pivot. Honestly, the internet spent years trying to figure out if Zachary Levi and girlfriend Caroline Tyler were still a thing after that 2021 ESPYs red carpet debut. They weren’t. While the rumor mill was busy recycling old paparazzi photos from New York, Levi was actually undergoing what he calls a total "life shift."
Everything changed in late 2024.
Out of nowhere, Levi dropped a sonogram on Instagram and introduced the world to Maggie Keating. It wasn’t just a "we’re dating" post. It was a "we’re having a baby" post.
The Maggie Keating Era: Who Is She?
Maggie Keating isn’t your typical Hollywood socialite. She’s a photographer and digital creator who first popped up on the public radar back in the day on America's Next Top Model (Cycle 24). She was the first one sent home that season, but clearly, that didn't stop her. She's been busy shooting for brands like Ghost Golf and Talentless.
📖 Related: Did Taylor Swift Break Up? What Really Happened With Travis Kelce
Basically, she and Levi seem to have connected on this deep, spiritual level that he’s been shouting from the rooftops about recently.
Levi has been super vocal about his mental health journey. He’s talked about "loving and valuing" himself more, and he credits this personal work with "manifesting" Keating into his life. He calls her an "angelic form." It’s pretty heavy stuff for a celebrity relationship announcement, but that’s just how Zak rolls these days.
The couple didn't wait long to start their family. On April 2, 2025, they welcomed their first child, a son named Henson Ezra Levi Pugh.
Why the Fans Are Actually Confused
You might see headlines still linking him to Missy Peregrym. That marriage was a decade ago. It lasted about ten months back in 2014-2015. People still bring it up because it was such a "blink and you'll miss it" Hollywood wedding in Maui.
Then there was the Caroline Tyler era. That was the last time we saw him "public" before Maggie. They were spotted holding hands in NYC, but it fizzled out without much of a peep.
What's different now?
- The Fatherhood Factor: Levi has said he’s wanted to be a dad since he was a kid. This isn't just a casual dating situation; it's a family unit.
- The Politics: Levi’s move to the right and his public support for Donald Trump has definitely colored how fans view his personal life. Maggie has been right there by his side through the shift.
- The Privacy: Despite the big announcement, they aren't exactly posting "get ready with me" videos every morning. They keep the day-to-day fairly locked down.
Breaking Down the "Pugh" Mystery
Wait, why is the baby’s last name Pugh?
👉 See also: Megan Fox and Machine Gun Kelly: What Really Happened With Their Relationship
If you're a casual fan, you probably didn't know that Zachary Levi is actually Zachary Levi Pugh. He dropped his last name for his acting career because, well, "Zack Pugh" doesn't exactly scream "leading man" in a Hollywood casting office. But when it came to his son, Henson, they went back to the family roots.
What Most People Get Wrong About Them
A lot of folks think this was a "rebound" or a sudden whim. It wasn't. Levi actually started talking about his intentional "season of singleness" back in 2023. He was waiting for someone who was on the same "journey of self-discovery."
Maggie, who is 27 (making her about 17 years younger than the 44-year-old actor), seems to fit that mold for him. They’ve both been through the reality TV/Hollywood ringer and come out the other side looking for something more grounded.
Where They Are Now
As of early 2026, the couple is settled into parenthood. They’ve been splitting time between his place and wherever work takes them, but the focus has shifted almost entirely away from "who is he dating" to "how is he parenting."
If you're looking for the juicy drama of a breakup, you won't find it here. They seem remarkably stable, especially given how much controversy has surrounded Levi's career and political stances lately. They've circled the wagons.
Next Steps for Fans
If you want to keep up with the latest on the couple without falling for clickbait:
- Check the source: Look at Maggie Keating's photography portfolio or her official Instagram for actual life updates.
- Watch the name: Remember that "Henson Pugh" is the name to look for in official records, not "Henson Levi."
- Ignore the 2021 archives: Any article talking about Caroline Tyler is years out of date.
The era of Zachary Levi as the "perpetual bachelor" or the "guy with the 10-month marriage" is officially over. He's a dad now, and Maggie Keating is the partner he’s chosen for this next, much louder, chapter of his life.