Let’s be real for a second. There is nothing quite like sitting on your couch on a random Tuesday in late December, watching two teams you barely care about battle it out in a stadium named after a lawnmower company or a brand of potato chips. It’s a holiday tradition. But lately, that tradition feels a little... hollow. You tune in to see the star quarterback who carried your team all season, only to find out he’s standing on the sidelines in a designer hoodie. He’s gone. Bowl game opt outs have officially shifted from a rare occurrence to the standard operating procedure for any NFL-bound prospect.
It sucks for the fans. It's tough for the coaches. Yet, if you’re a 21-year-old kid with a $10 million contract waiting for you in April, are you really going to risk your ACL for the Pop-Tarts Bowl? Probably not. The tension between tradition and cold, hard business has never been more obvious than it is right now.
Why Everyone is Skipping the Postseason
The "opt-out" era didn't just happen overnight. It started as a trickle. Back in 2016, Christian McCaffrey and Leonard Fournette decided to skip their bowl games to focus on the NFL Draft. At the time, people lost their minds. Critics called them "selfish" or "bad teammates." Then, Jaylon Smith happened. Smith was a superstar linebacker for Notre Dame who played in the Fiesta Bowl and suffered a horrific knee injury. It cost him millions of dollars in his rookie contract. Players watched that. Agents watched that. The message was sent loud and clear: loyalty doesn't pay the medical bills.
Nowadays, bowl game opt outs are basically a business decision. It’s about risk management. If a player is a projected first-round pick, playing in a non-College Football Playoff (CFP) game is all risk and zero reward.
We aren't just talking about the superstars anymore, either. It’s trickling down. Now, even mid-round prospects or guys entering the transfer portal are heading for the exit before the band even starts playing. This has turned the "Bowl Season" into a glorified preview of next year's depth chart rather than a celebration of the current season.
The CFP Expansion and the "Meaningless" Bowl Problem
We have to talk about the elephant in the room: the 12-team playoff. For years, the argument was that expanding the playoff would fix the opt-out problem. The logic was that if more games "mattered," more players would stay. To an extent, that's true for the teams inside the bracket. You don't see many guys opting out of a quarterfinal game with a national title on the line.
But what about the other 30-plus games?
If you’re playing in the Gator Bowl or the Sun Bowl, you’re essentially playing an exhibition. The prestige of these legacy bowls has been cannibalized by the playoff system. When the media and the fans spend all year saying "if you aren't in the top 12, your season was a failure," we shouldn't be shocked when the players believe us. They aren't stupid. They see the writing on the wall.
✨ Don't miss: US Open Picks 2025: Why Everyone Was Wrong About the Sinner-Alcaraz Rivalry
The Transfer Portal Chaos
It's not just the NFL Draft causing these holes in the roster. The transfer portal window opens right as the regular season ends. It is absolute chaos. Imagine a coach trying to prepare for a bowl game while half his starters are literally interviewing for jobs at other schools.
Take a look at what happened to Florida State in the 2023 Orange Bowl. After being snubbed by the CFP committee, the roster basically disintegrated. They had over 20 players out due to bowl game opt outs, injuries, or the portal. They lost 63-3 to Georgia. Was it a "bowl game"? Technically. Was it a competitive football game? Not even close. It was a massacre of backups.
What Coaches (Actually) Think
Publicly, most coaches say they support their players. They talk about "doing what's best for the young man" and "the next man up mentality." Privately? They’re pulling their hair out.
Kirby Smart and Lane Kiffin have both been vocal about the state of the sport. They’ve pointed out that the current calendar is broken. You have the early signing period, the transfer portal, and bowl prep all happening in the same three-week window in December. It's a logistical nightmare. Some coaches are pushing for "bowl contracts" where players get paid a specific NIL (Name, Image, Likeness) bonus only if they suit up for the postseason.
- The Financials: Some NIL collectives are already doing this. They'll structure deals where a portion of the payout is contingent on postseason participation.
- The "Opt-In" Bonus: We might see a future where bowl sponsors themselves provide a "participation stipend" to keep stars on the field.
- The Roster Gap: Coaches are now forced to use bowl practices as a "Spring Ball 2.0" because the guys playing in the game might be freshmen who haven't seen a snap all year.
Is there a fix, or is this just football now?
Some people suggest moving the transfer portal window. Others think we should pay players a flat fee for bowl games. Honestly, none of it really "fixes" the core issue: the NFL Draft is the only thing that matters to top-tier talent.
Maybe we just have to change how we watch these games. Instead of mourning the players who aren't there, we look at it as a scouting mission for the following season. You get to see the four-star recruit who’s been buried on the depth chart finally get his chance. It’s different, sure. It’s less "prestige" and more "developmental league."
But let's be honest—it still beats watching a Hallmark movie.
Actionable Insights for the Savvy Fan
If you're trying to navigate the landscape of bowl game opt outs without losing your mind (or your shirt in a Vegas sportsbook), here is how you should handle December:
Check the "Out" Lists Daily Rosters change by the hour. Don't look at a team's November stats and assume that's who is taking the field. Use sites like 247Sports or specific beat writers on X (formerly Twitter) who track "opt-out trackers." If a team loses its starting QB and its left tackle, that double-digit favorite isn't a favorite anymore.
Look at the Motivation Factor Some teams are thrilled to be at a bowl. A program like New Mexico State or Liberty might see a bowl game as their Super Bowl. Meanwhile, a powerhouse like Alabama or Ohio State might view a non-playoff bowl as a consolation prize. Bet on the team that actually wants to be there. Usually, the team with fewer bowl game opt outs is the one with the higher "buy-in" from the locker room.
Watch the Lines Vegas knows. If you see a point spread move 7 points in three days, someone important just opted out. Usually, it's the quarterback or the primary playmaker on defense. Don't chase the line; understand why it's moving.
💡 You might also like: Start Sit Week 16: Don't Let Your Fantasy Season Die in the Semifinals
Embrace the "New" Stars Instead of complaining about who isn't playing, look up the backups. Often, the "new" guys play harder because they're fighting for a starting spot next year. The quality of play might be lower, but the effort is often higher than a bored senior coasting toward the draft.
Support Local Bowl Games If you live near a bowl site, go anyway. The atmosphere is still great, and the local economy relies on those fans. The players who do stay deserve an audience. Choosing to play is now a bigger statement of loyalty than it ever was before.
The reality is that college football has moved into a professionalized era. The "student-athlete" veneer is gone, replaced by "independent contractors" making business decisions. It’s less romantic, definitely. But it’s also the most honest the sport has ever been. We can't ask players to be professionals when it comes to TV revenue and then ask them to be "amateurs" when it comes to protecting their health. Bowl game opt outs are the price we pay for a multi-billion dollar industry. Adapt or get left behind in the snow.
Next Steps for the Postseason
To stay ahead of the curve, you should compile a list of the top 5 players on your favorite team and track their social media for "Declaration" graphics. Once a player signs with an agent, they are officially ineligible for the bowl. Additionally, monitor the "Intent to Transfer" lists, as these players rarely participate in postseason activities even if they haven't picked a new school yet. Knowledge of the depth chart is now more valuable than knowledge of the season's win-loss record.