Nobody actually tells you that the day you get promoted, you stop being "one of them" and start being "one of those." It’s a weird, lonely transition. Honestly, most people think learning how to be a manager is about mastering spreadsheets or running tight meetings, but it's mostly about managing your own anxiety while people stare at you waiting for answers you don't always have.
You’re basically a shock absorber.
If the executives above you are screaming about quarterly goals, you can’t just pass that scream down to your team. You have to translate it into something that actually makes sense for a Tuesday morning. If you don't, you're just a megaphone for stress. It's a hard shift. You've spent years being rewarded for your individual output—how fast you code, how many sales you close, how well you write. Now? Your personal output doesn't matter. Your team’s output is your only metric. It’s frustrating. It's humbling.
The big lie about "natural leaders"
We've all heard the myth. Some people are just born to lead, right? They have the "it" factor. Well, researchers like Carol Dweck have spent decades debunking the idea that our traits are fixed. Management is a skill, not a personality type. You can learn it.
The Harvard Business Review famously noted that the "first-time manager" transition is one of the most difficult leaps in a professional career. Why? Because the skills that got you the promotion—technical excellence—are the exact same skills that will tempt you to micromanage your team into the ground. You think you can do the job faster and better than they can. You’re probably right. But if you do it for them, you aren't managing. You're just a bottleneck with a fancy title.
📖 Related: Guide Fabrics Inc New York: The Real Deal on Where NYC Designers Source Their Material
Stop being the smartest person in the room
If you’re the smartest person on your team, you’ve failed at hiring or development. Kim Scott, who wrote Radical Candor, talks a lot about this. You have to be able to challenge people directly while showing you care personally. It sounds like corporate speak, but it's actually just about not being a jerk while still holding people to a high standard.
Think about it this way: if your best performer is consistently late but you never say anything because you're "the nice boss," you’re actually poisoning the rest of the team. They see the slack. They feel the unfairness. Being a good manager means having the stomach for awkward conversations.
Managing the middle is a balancing act
You're in the "sandwich" now.
Upward management is just as vital as downward management. You have to protect your team’s time. If a VP drops a "quick request" on a Friday afternoon that will actually take ten hours, a bad manager says, "Sure thing!" and ruins their team's weekend. A good manager asks, "Which of our current priorities should we drop to make room for this?"
It takes guts.
Google’s "Project Aristotle" spent years studying what makes a team effective. They thought they’d find a mix of IQs or specific backgrounds. They were wrong. The number one factor was psychological safety. Do your people feel like they can take a risk or admit a mistake without you biting their head off? If they're scared of you, they'll hide the truth. And you can't manage what you don't know.
The 1-on-1 is not a status update
Seriously, stop using your 1-on-1 meetings to ask for project updates. That’s what Slack or email is for. These meetings should be about the person. What’s blocking them? Where do they want to be in two years? Are they burnt out?
- Ask: "What’s one thing I can do to make your job easier this week?"
- Ask: "Who on the team has been killing it lately?"
- Listen more than you talk.
If you're talking for 40 minutes of a 45-minute meeting, you're just lecturing. You're not managing. You're definitely not learning how to be a manager who people actually want to work for.
The delegation trap
Most new managers think delegation is just giving people tasks. It’s not. It’s giving people ownership.
There is a massive difference between "Go buy these ingredients and follow this recipe exactly" and "I need a dinner that impresses a vegan client; you handle the menu." The first is task-setting. The second is delegation.
When you delegate, you have to accept that they might do it differently than you. They might even do it slower. That's fine. If you jump in the second things get messy, you've taught them that they don't really have to be responsible because "the boss will fix it." You're training them to be helpless. Don't do that.
Handling the "Friendship" Problem
This is the part that sucks. If you were promoted from within, your former peers are now your subordinates. You can't be "one of the guys" in the same way anymore. You can’t vent about the company's leadership at happy hour. You are leadership.
It feels cold, but it’s necessary for clarity. If you're too close to one person, the rest of the team will scream "favoritism" the moment that person gets a choice assignment or a raise. You need a little bit of distance to remain objective. It's the price of the promotion.
Radical Transparency (within reason)
People hate being in the dark. In the absence of information, people invent their own stories—and those stories are usually nightmares.
If there are layoffs coming, or a project is being canceled, or the company is pivoting, tell your team as much as you legally and professionally can. Don't use "corporate speak" like restructuring for future synergies. Just say, "The budget changed, and we have to pivot."
People can handle bad news. They can't handle being lied to.
Practical steps to take right now
You don't need a year of training to start improving. You can literally start tomorrow.
📖 Related: PRU Stock Price History: What Most People Get Wrong
Audit your calendar. Look at how much time you spend "doing" vs. "leading." If you’re still spending 80% of your time on your old technical tasks, you’re not managing. You’re just a busy individual contributor. Aim to get that down to 20% over the next three months.
The "Wait" Rule. In your next team meeting, when a problem is brought up, wait ten seconds before you offer a solution. Let the silence hang there. Force someone else to speak. You’ll be surprised at the ideas that come out when you stop being the "Chief Answer Officer."
Get a mentor outside your chain of command. Find someone who isn't your boss but has been a manager for five years. Ask them about their biggest firing mistake. Ask them how they handled their first underperformer. Learning from someone else's scars is much less painful than earning your own.
Define what "Done" looks like. Most frustration comes from vague expectations. Instead of saying "I need this report soon," say "I need a three-page PDF summarizing the Q3 sales data by Thursday at 4 PM." Specificity is kindness.
Stop checking emails at 9 PM. If you’re sending messages at all hours, your team feels like they have to be "on" all hours. You’re setting the culture with your behavior, not your words. If you have a thought late at night, use the "schedule send" feature for 8:30 AM the next morning.
The reality of the role
Being a manager is a career change, not a promotion. You are now in the business of people. People are messy, inconsistent, brilliant, and occasionally very annoying. If you want everyone to like you, you’ll be a terrible manager. If you want everyone to respect you, you have a chance.
Focus on being the person who clears the path so your team can run. If they succeed, give them the credit. If they fail, take the blame. It sounds lopsided, but that's the job.
Start by asking your team for feedback on your performance. It’ll be terrifying. It’ll probably hurt your ego. But it’s the only way to find out where your blind spots are before you drive the whole team into a ditch.